From Publishers Weekly
Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Copyright 2002 Reed Business Information, Inc.
I very much enjoyed reading the thoughts of both authors, but Hirsch is simply not in Reinman's class as a debater and a scholar. Read morePublished 14 months ago by Stephen
The main perspective of Classical, a.k.a. Orthodox Judaism is that the Torah (written and oral) is divine; and accordingly a series of discussions and decisions (including the... Read morePublished on April 21, 2011 by Jacob L.
Very much enjoyed this book, I read it eagerly from cover to cover and will do so again. Contrary to most of the other commenters, I found Rabbi Hirsch's ideas more convincing and... Read morePublished on November 27, 2010 by tigermama
The book One People, Two Worlds was of interest to me as someone who grew up going to an Orthodox shul but since adulthood finding myself affiliated with the Re-constructionist... Read morePublished on October 23, 2008 by Book Reader Saul
One of the most direct and honest clashes of world views within the context of Jewish observance and values. Read morePublished on August 30, 2005 by L. Katz
In this book, Reform Rabbi Ammiel Hirsch, and Orthodox Rabbi Yakov Yosef Reinman debate the issues dividing these two branches of Judaism. Read morePublished on May 27, 2005 by David E. Levine
I thought this book was fantastic, and I really learned a lot about both Classical (Orthodox) and Reform Judaism. Read morePublished on May 18, 2005 by AML
This is book is a masterpiece. I found the Reform perspective interesting but Rabbi Reinman's positions to be entirely convincing. Read morePublished on February 9, 2004 by SimchaEsq.