From Publishers Weekly
Death forges a supernatural bond between two lonely teenage boys in Barzak's well-intentioned and morbid first novel. Fifteen-year-old Adam McCormick is haunted by the earthbound ghost of his murdered classmate, Jamie Marks. Boy and ghost are drawn to one another by their shared outsider status at school, with the ghost providing support (and a surprising homoerotic romance subplot) for Adam as he survives a disastrous relationship with the sexually predatory Gracie (the classmate who discovered Jamie's body), a scary encounter with the ghost of a murderess and a troubled home life with his older brother and constantly arguing parents. Adam and Jamie's ghost eventually run away and find shelter in an abandoned church, where Adam is tempted to join Jamie, and Jamie delays moving to the next level in the afterlife. Barzak admirably defies convention by not having the two boys search for Jamie's killer, but the replacement plot—one of a bizarre coming-of-age—doesn't always meld well with the narrative's fantastical elements (closets, called dead space, are portals between worlds; ghosts burn memories to keep warm). The macabre tone won't work for readers looking for another
Lovely Bones, but the novel's approach to familiar material is refreshing.
(Sept.) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From Bookmarks Magazine
Christopher Barzakâs
One for Sorrow is a rare thing indeedâ"a horror novel with heart. Itâs not often that such a book, particularly a debut (Barzakâs reputation comes from his short fiction), is described as "lovely, melancholy" (
Village Voice). But Barzak balances his storyâs supernatural aspects, which he delivers with simple assuredness, with the uncertainties and complexities of adolescence.
One for Sorrow has been compared to
The Catcher in the Rye and Alice Seboldâs
The Lovely Bones. In the case of the latter, though, Barzakâs book is quite a bit edgier and focuses little on the search for Jamieâs killer. Instead, Barzak develops the adolescent relationships into "a coming-of-age story, more melancholy than morbid and, by the end, profoundly hopeful" (
Washington Post).
Copyright © 2004 Phillips & Nelson Media, Inc.
See all Editorial Reviews