Borthwick, who authored all the pieces in this self- produced and self-released CD, walks both sides of the street, playing excellent, if not quite distinctive, straightahead piano throughout, while adding her shimmering, wordless soprano lines to selected ensembles along the way. She does this sparingly, sometimes subtlety, and frequently hauntingly, never scatting or soloing but instead embedding and camouflaging herself deep into meticulously orchestrated unison lines in which her voice seems to float on piano, guitar
(Listening To Love) and horn
(Gaia)... For a work intended to be personal and perhaps introspective, the music is unusually alive, frisky and free from brooding pensiveness. --- JOHN McDONOUGH,
"The HotBox", Downbeat Magazine, May 2010
'One of Us', the latest CD of the Indo-American composer-pianist Ramona Borthwick confirms the favourable impression and perceived interest that had already been raised in her previous work,
'A New Leaf'. A first listen to
'One Of Us' makes it apparent that there has been a eightening of artistic maturity on the part of Borthwick. Not so much as in the use of instruments, something she was already gifted with, but in the stylistic approach and creation of music, and in the dynamics of the arrangements. There is a lot of attention to rhythm, with frequent and brilliant development of it. The rhythm is always characterized by a vitality that captures the listener with an intensity that draws him/her toward a positive and relaxed state of mind.
The theme that Borthwick explores in this recent work is the preservation of the integrity of the earth so that future generations can benefit from its gifts. This is indeed one of the major issues of concern in contemporary history, undoubtedly related to the sensitivity and spirituality which undoubtedly Ramona inherits from her Indian origins. In this journey, a concept-album created with entirely original compositions, Borthwick explores the diverse souls of the earth, representing them with music blended by Latin sounds, and cultural ideas originating from her place of birth, India. This music is built off solid differing jazz structures, as well as classical music. This realization of this attempt through music develops a narrative power with a capacity to achieve and subliminally coerce, interrogate and lay bare the conscience of the listener while reaching the most profound level of awareness.
The spirit of the entire CD is well summarized and represented in
'Who s Your Mama'the opening track of the CD, which has a mixture of swing marked with 'post-bop' compositional influences and a recurrent use of the voice as an instrument. Considerable attention has been paid to the instrumentation, something that Borthwick has always done and which is evident in this self-produced CD. And there are rare moments of great lyrical composition, as in
One Of Us , the song that lends its name to the album, and
Gaia , which evokes the drama and genesis of the earth. Refined and elegant, the serene opening of
'Eight Winds', where swing meets Latin rhythms, has the theme masterfully developed by the brilliant and passionate trumpeter Ingrid Jensen. With Borthwick's characteristic generosity towards her collaborators, the the opening phrases of the CD are entrusted to the trumpet. This is bolstered by a substantial contribution from the double bass and voice. Samba and bossa rhythms - again joyfully represented in
'Rio Alegre', display Borthwick's luminuous pianism and highlight another protagonist that must be mentioned, Noel Borthwick. Partner in adventure to Ramona, he has produced the project. Noel is also a great technician and guitarist of rank, and assumes a full role as player in the group. In this song particularly, his playing displays the Brazilian spirit, showing great ability to play themes originating from the southern hemispere. Worth mentioning are German double bassist Johannes Weidenmueller, whose fluid and solid touch appears throughout the entire CD, his bright and harmonic lines sometimes the real focus of the composition; and the brilliant drummer Adam Cruz, whose playing reflects his experience with the best exponents of South-American jazz, and who strongly contributes to enhancing the spirit of the entire Latin-jazz project.
--- MAURIZIO SPENNATO, Sound Contest, Italy, May 2010