From School Library Journal
Grade 9 Up—When Wrenn, a slightly overweight sophomore, is convinced by her friend Zoe to try out for the school musical,
Grease, she decides to go after what she has always wanted: popularity. She is cast as Rizzo and begins a strict diet and exercise regime that gets way out of control when she starts using laxatives. When the in-crowd accepts her, Wrenn spends less time with Zoe, and as her eating disorder consumes her, she begins to lose herself. When she passes out at the cast party, her family and friends take action. Her mother enrolls her in a rehab program, where Wrenn works on feeling good about herself and learning to do things in moderation. This is perhaps a less-stark view of eating disorders than Robin Friedman's
Nothing (Flux, 2008) or Madeleine George's
Looks (Viking, 2008), but it is still realistic enough, and there is no happily-ever-after ending. The characters are well developed and three-dimensional, even the adults. This engrossing novel lets readers see this issue up close without being completely pessimistic.—
Robin Henry, Wakeland High School, Frisco, TX Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
One Wish is a poignant story of a girl s struggle to find herself in the midst of family turmoil and new temptations. Wrenn captures the reader s heart .... Readers will wish Wrenn success as she tries to make her dreams come true ... and proves that even when they don't, life can be better than we ever thought. --Mary Beth Miller, author of
Aimee and
On the Head of a PinBrescia tackles important issues ... and Wrenn's thoughts and the characters' dialogue feel honest .... Wrenn show[s] growth and depth when she is undergoing therapy for anorexia, and begins to reflect on the choices she's made. --Publishers Weekly
Brescia tackles important issues ... and Wrenn's thoughts and the characters' dialogue feel honest .... Wrenn show[s] growth and depth when she is undergoing therapy for anorexia, and begins to reflect on the choices she's made. --Publishers Weekly
The characters are well developed and three-dimensional .... This engrossing novel lets readers see this issue up close without being completely pessimistic. --School Library Journal