37 of 39 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent room correction, great AVR so far!, December 3, 2010
This review is from: Onkyo TX-NR3008 9.2-Channel Network Home Theater Receiver (Electronics)
This is a cross post of my review on AVSforums, a discussion thread is also over there about this AVR and my experiences thus far. Also, there are some pics of my install and of the OSD for this device (which I could not find anywhere), including the HDMI overlay:
[...]
Unfortunately, the first one I purchased from Amazon (warehouse deals) was bad, it has a hiss/click in the 2 front speakers. They were great doing the return, and sent me another one that; so far, has been perfect..
To begin, here's a list of my gear:
Epson 8500
Axiom M60v2, VP150, and QS8s for surround, surround backs (7 channel)
Epik Castle subwoofer
Dedicated theater, ~20X17
Room treatments (NO bass trapping, just for highs)
HTPC w/5500 series video card (HD bitstreaming)
I'm coming from a Pioneer 1018, a ~500 dollar AVR that's ~2-3 years old. This is a good AVR, and I've been happy with it. The biggest reasons for my upgrade is to get OSD (all my gear is behind me in a closet; I can't see what mode/volume/etc I'm in on the Pioneer on screen, and it's driving me nuts), better room correction, and dual sub balancing EQ correction. The Pioneer also supported HD sound, so that's consistent between the systems; as well as the speakers (everything is the same).
First off, for those who have been reading the 3008/5008 thread, I'm on my second 3008; the first one sent had a "hum/buzz" in the front two speakers (L/R). So my initial impression was "how about some QC!". 2nd AVR seems fine so far, the buzz/hum is gone..
As soon as I got the AVR I upgraded the firmware to the most recent available. I did it once via USB, and once via network. Both times it took a long time to finish (30+ minutes), but went without a hitch. As such, I can't comment on the "old" firmware or what the upgrades "fixed".
After running the FW updates, I then ran through Audessey. Easy process, took about 1-1.5 hours to measure 8 positions and calculate the results. The calculation took much longer than I expected (10 minutes or so), on the Pioneer the room calculation was much faster (but much less sophisticated). As you can see, I mounted the Audessey mic on my photography rig using some blue painters tape. I think that the tape adds a nice "color" and "transparency" to the final EQ calculations.
Anyway.. On to listening. I setup the default audio modes, a feature I didn't know I wanted, but man, I couldn't live without it now. For those who don't know, it allows you to select the default mode for different types of audio; stereo is output as 2.1, TrueHD is output at 7.1 in THX Cinema mode, etc. Once you set this, all the switching between modes is fully automated. Really nice when you have one source (HTPC) that can play tons of different types of audio/video files! I set stereo to 2.1 and the HD audio codecs to 7.1 THX Cinema mode.
First thing I played was music. Bass was significantly/dramatically better (depending on the source material). From the main listening position, it was tight, clear, and very easy to listen to. Also, stereo separation was better; there's a much higher "sense of space" with the new AVR. Not sure how to explain it, but I'm very happy with the results. Set the sub volume a little higher (apparently I'm a bass head, I like it louder than reference) but that was my only listening tweak. Music was much "easier" to listen to; probably because some of the ringing or smearing is being processed out by the room correction software in the 3008. Regardless, very happy with the music results!
On to video.. I've watched a few movies since the install (I haven't slept very much), and all of them were "improved" to "much improved" over the Pioneer. Again, the bass is SO much better that it's really hard to say if that's causing everything else to "sound better" too. The surrounds are much more noticeable (not in a bad way, just more ambient sound), and the system sounds better "blended" than it did with the 1018. I'm in love with the immediate OSD, for folks with gear in a closet (or out of sight) it's exactly what the doctor ordered! I haven't been through all the listening modes yet; I'm stuck on THX Cinema because I like the results so much! Overall, again, very happy with the video results.
General stuff.. This thing runs MUCH hotter than my Pioneer did (driving the same speakers and at the same volumes). It's not "dangerous" hot (IMHO), but much, much hotter than it's predecessor, that's for sure. Also, this thing weighs a TON compared to the Pioneer.. A TON! It's hard to move with one person (you can do it, but don't put in into a glass rack (which is what I have) without help!). The rear of this device is laid out really nicely! I'm very happy with it; easy to connect the speakers (takes bananas securely) and the source component(s). Audessey was easy to run, and correctly detected all my speakers and room layout both times.
The OSD (overlay and full menu) is pretty snappy (it could be better), much faster and nicer to look at the the older Pioneer. However, it's nothing "great", it's still mostly text; it get's the job done, but isn't going to wow you with graphics (I'd much prefer simple and fast over pretty and slow, so this works well for me).
AVR seems to be able to handle high volume just fine; I played some music at 5 under reference and it kept right up. Didn't hear any clipping or distortion; but, to be honest, my Pioneer was just as good at this volume and didn't get as hot..
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Awesome receiver., January 21, 2011
This review is from: Onkyo TX-NR3008 9.2-Channel Network Home Theater Receiver (Electronics)
I decided to go with Onkyo after having a Pioneer Elite (VSX-92XH) that lived most of its life at a repair facility more than on my home theater stand. I conferred with several people who own Onkyo equipment, one of whom has a high-end Klipsch setup, as well as read many reviews on their latest line of high end products (TX-NR1008, 3008 and 5008) before deciding to purchase the TX-NR3008. I made the right choice. For the money, you get many more features and power out of Onkyo than you would with Pioneer or Denon ($$$). Setting up this beast (50+lb) was a breeze and it sounds no different than my Pioneer Elite. I know this is a point of contention because there are camps out there that believe receiver X is better than receiver Y--which very well may be the case, however, for the purposes of watching movies, I can't really tell the difference between my Pioneer Elite and this Onkyo. Before I get flamed, keep in mind that most if not all high end receivers are THX U2 certified and the mode that allows you to up-convert from 5.1 or fewer channels to 7.1 is arguably the same from receiver to receiver as it is a process proprietary to THX. Beyond that, the only major differences are listening modes which I largely don't/didn't touch. I leave BD movies whose digital tracks are 7.1 alone and those that are 5.1 I listen in THX U2 Mode. I have no complaints. This receiver is driving my 'prosumer' setup consisting of a Klipsch RC-64 II center, SUB12HG sub woofer, Polk towers and Polk surrounds (working on upgrading the Polks to Klipsch Reference towers and surrounds).
As far as cons go nothing major but it should be said that the TX-NR3008 generates a ton of heat. I do not recommend placing this unit in a cramped TV stand or near other hot components as you are probably sure to experience heat related failures if you do so. After watching a movie, I can feel the heat emanating from my receiver from about a foot or so away and for that reason it stands on a tower in a well ventilated area. Secondly, it clicks a lot when switching from analog to digital modes or between different sound tracks. This mainly happens when watching TV (Cable, satellite, whatever) and moving from analog to digital signals. If you change the channel once or twice, no big deal, if you're channel surfing, you'll hear a lot of clicking. I read online that this isn't really an issue at all and that there is no real way to 'fix' this so its something you'll have to deal with if you purchase an Onkyo receiver. Having said that, this 'issue' wont prevent me from buying another Onkyo as it seems to be unique to them in some way.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Sounds Great When It Works, June 26, 2011
This review is from: Onkyo TX-NR3008 9.2-Channel Network Home Theater Receiver (Electronics)
Of the 10 receivers I've owned over the decades, this is the best one for controlling sound (and video in this case). But, there are some of these models that have a known deficiency with the power module that could have disastrous consequences. Here are the symptoms; the remote stops working with no control of the power. Then other buttons fail, but the receiver still works with the front panel buttons - Onkyo technical service will tell you it is the remote. A couple of days later the receiver will turn on by itself (this is really bad if you aren't at home) and the only way to shut it off is unplugging the power cord. Finally, the power fails entirely.
The first one failed after two weeks was returned to Amazon and replaced immediately. Unfortunately, after reading outstanding reviews, I chose a replacement which failed within 5 weeks. This now puts me into warranty delays with Onkyo service providers.
Here's my issue; Onkyo admitted they had a problem with a number of the TX-NR3008 models - one that had the potential of starting a fire. This is a safety issue - they should have pulled the affected lot(s) from the market until the problem could be fixed before selling them to consumers.
I am very disappointed!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No