Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Must For Civil War Buffs, August 27, 2004
This is the story of a Southern Lady, from a fine old Virginia family,in fact a superb example of the Southern womanhood that Confederates claimed to be fighting for
Only this one didn't want them to fight for her. She was loyal to the Union (and also antislavery) and when her state seceded her reaction was to set up in business as a spy for the North.
Narrated, in an original twist, by the heroine's ghost, this novel gives a fascinating picture of the war behind the lines. Spies (including a Black one right inside Jefferson Davis' White House) slave stealers, prisoners of war and loyal Virginians helping the Union Army (or trying to) give a whole angle on the war that Gone With The Wind never mentioned.
I do have one or two gripes. While the heroine (and the author, I suspect) have some reason to be aggrieved at the way the loyal southerners have been forgotten by history, I feel she makes a bigger mystery of this than it really is. Wars, even more than other historical events, tend to get remembered "in primary colours" and as the War passed into memory as a war of North against South, the dissidents on both sides got airbrushed out, all the more so as they still had to live with the neighbours, hence found it wiser not to brag about their war records. So by 1870 you got Southern Unionists saying they had served with Lee, whilst every Yankee claimed to have been a true blue Union Man, even if really he had voted for Vallandigham and spent every waking moment organising resistance to the Draft. So it goes.
Also, Miss Van Lew rather passes over the effect of Radical Reconstruction in smothering the development of a "loyal" southern tradition. Unlike her, many former Unionist disliked carpetbaggers and uppity blacks as much as any Reb, and (like Andrew Johnson, about the most prominent loyalist, yet whom the novel doesn't even mention) found in opposition to Reconstruction a quick and easy path to reconciliation with their neighbours
Still, enough quibbling. With all its faults, it's a great novel, and if the Civil War turns you on, it belongs up there on your bookshelf. Read and enjoy
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A worthwhile subject, June 15, 2003
This is a novel about the Union underground network of spies in the South during the Civil War. It is a story of ordinary people who took great risks to remain loyal while all those around them were rebelling. I have a great appreciation for this book because I feel loyalist in the South is a much neglected part of American history. This book uses the device of a ghost's perspective to both tell the story as a first person account and to interject present day perceptions and give hindsight explanations. Although these passages are admittedly necessary, they do cause the book to drag. The story is interesting, but there is too much lamenting about how today's world has forgotten the loyalist and unjustly idealized the South. Just tell me the story and I can figure that out myself.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A fascinating authentic look at the War Between the States, December 23, 2004
I've read many books on the Civil War and this is one of my faves, up there with Andersonville and Gettysburg. The protagonist, Eliza Van Lew, is based on a true person who aided the Union POW's in Libby Prison and provided info to the Union through an underground network.
The voice of Van Lew, spoken by her ghost, offers an intriguing perspective on the war and its outcome. Author Jakober invites us into a world where Jefferson Davis, Robert E. Lee and other main figures from the South continue to live in the past.
I especially enjoyed her takes on how the 21st century has idealized the South's culture and mores. The South remains the "romantic" side of the war despite, or because of its, loss and its strictly stratified society.
It is a story of a woman breaking free of her culture's bonds, leaving you no doubt as to who the true "Rebel" is.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|