Most Helpful Customer Reviews
19 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Debunking the Myths, March 11, 2008
This review is from: Onward Christian Soldiers: The Growing Political Power of Catholics and Evangelicals in the United States (Hardcover)
"If the Religious Right were suddenly to go out of business, the Religious Left would disappear overnight."
This assertion is provocative but Deal W. Hudson's beefs it up eloquently in his recent book about the influence of Catholics and Evangelicals in contemporary American politics. He documents how the followers of the Religious Left are the grandchildren of the 60's (and they have no shame accusing the Christian Right for being reactionary...) and why it will end up failing at successfully linking itself with the Democrats.
1. Secularists and religionists do not make a good match. From the moment questions will be raised in view to alter the Democrats agenda on social and economic issues, this fragile construction will be blown apart;
2. Liberal-leaning critics of the Christian (and Religious) Right condemn a movement that intervenes in the public sphere just like the civil rights movement in the 1960s. It is thus incoherent to blame one for what the other did - even if they're not on the same side of the spectrum;
3. "The Religious Left shifts responsibility from the individual to government on a variety of fronts." In a context were people seek more autonomy, this attitude won't bring Democrats and their allies more support than what they actually have.
From an academic, philosophical and religious perspective, I have always been interested in books related to the Christian Right. One of the disappointments I felt in the literature on the topic was that authors were either only academic - thus lacking real-life experience in the arena - or purely political, thus depriving readers of a beneficial intellectual framework which can explain a lot.
There is another fascinating element about this book. It details the involvement of the Catholics in the wider phenomenon of the Christian Right. For sure, Catholics bring their attitudes and particularities, but they've been at the vanguard notably in regard with family issues. One needs never forget that Buckley, Weyrich, Schlafly and Viguerie - luminaries of the Conservative movements - were Catholics. Deal W. Hudson also elaborates - although too briefly - on the Catholic influence on Barry Goldwater, a topic that certainly needs more attention in coming books. The Catholic conservative wing not only has deep historical and intellectual roots, but it's also vibrant in the current context.
While some critics have it that the Christian Right (or the Religious Right if you prefer) is only a political machine that serves to deliver votes on E-Day, Deal W. Hudson shows with eloquence and brilliance that this position in the marketplace of ideas is much more than politics only. It lays on deep philosophical, intellectual and cultural and - yes - religious foundations.
For anybody who does not drink the Kool-Aid that Republicans are automatically finished in 2008 and who really wants to understand why and how it could achieve another successful intervention (like it did in 1976, 1984, 1988, 1994, 2000 and 2004), this book is required reading. And the author debunks many myths and misconceptions.
In sum, a great and beneficial read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A defense of social conservatives, July 7, 2008
This review is from: Onward Christian Soldiers: The Growing Political Power of Catholics and Evangelicals in the United States (Hardcover)
So, why hasn't America gone the route of Europe into secular anti-Christianism? It may yet, but there is a group trying to stem the tide.
Social conservatives. They bring a frisson of terror to any liberal. Usually, they are referred to in the press by that much hated word, Evangelicals.
Well, what a shocker: the press got it wrong, as usual. The social conservative movement is much, much broader than just the Evangelicals, and it always has been, as Hudson points out in "Onward Christian Soldiers".
Remember Phyllis Schlafly, the Catholic who organized, fought, and defeated the Equal Rights Amendment? Or the Catholic Paul Weyrich? It was his work which formed "the strategy for bringing these Evangelical preachers and laymen into politics" (p 4) including Grant, Dobson, Robinson, and a score of others. Another early member was the Catholic William F Buckley, whose "National Review" was the intellectual magazine for all conservatives.
Catholics like Buckley and Bishop Sheen were charter members of the conservatives who fought communism. What is not usually recognized by the press is that Catholics form a large part of the social conservative movement today, and always have formed part of the movement.
"The year 1979 was the tipping point, when Democrats lost their allegiance to the party of their parents and began identifying with the God or social and religious conservatives" (p 25) as they voted for Reagan.
Hudson believes abortion alone wasn't the issue that launched the religious right. There was a growing and painful gap between those who wanted a new morality and those who continued to practice their faith. Everywhere, America was changing. About 40% of newborns are illegitimate. Partial birth abortion, with a baby's brains sucked out, is legal. Gay rights began to be taught by teachers to grammar school children, while Christmas displays were forbidden.
Catholic grassroots organizations, like Knights of Columbus, seem to run under the liberal radar, whereas those who claim to be Catholic but refuse to adhere to the tenets of the faith, like Pelosi and Kennedy, are well known. This may have added to the confusion of the liberals.
Other Catholics who form part of the social conservative network include Father Pavone, who in 1990 began Priests for Life. "As is the case for many conservative Catholic leaders, the Catholic television network EWTN played a decisive role in helping Pavone grow his organization" (p 147). EWTN was founded by Mother Angelica, an enclosed nun not supposed to have contact with the outside world, who had $200 and decided to start a television station. Father Corapi and the Franciscans of the Renewal's Father Groeschel were also introduced to the public by EWTN. `
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Must Read for Historical Perspective of Conservative Voters, November 9, 2010
This review is from: Onward Christian Soldiers: The Growing Political Power of Catholics and Evangelicals in the United States (Hardcover)
A must read for all Americans, Conservative or Not; Mr. Deal Hudson has brought together volumes of history and inside Washington political information that would take months, perhaps years, for some of us to ever research ourselves. His style, for the level of content, makes you walk away with a sense that you just received a Presidential briefing on the history of the American Conservative battle to safeguard the traditional family values we mainstream AMERICAN voters hold so dear. Mr. Hudson presents all the people and places, in their historical context, both for and against these values. This election and the 2012 election will prove to be historical and pivotal; this book clarifies our need, as conservatives to VOTE and to get every other conservative to vote for candidates who will keep our family and societal values primary throughout their years of service as President, as Congressman, Senator, at the national or State level. Please read this book and pass this review on to every conservative you know!!!
Thank you, your fellow American Conservative, Theresa Jordan
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
