Customer Reviews

Open Secrets: Stories

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

It astounds me that some people find Munro's prose boring; hypnotic is the word I'd use. These stories aren't talk shows or soap operas or "Oprah stories" with heartwarming messages at the end. What they're about, in my view, is the strange and slippery role that time and memory play in our lives, and in that sense they join the tradition of Proust and Wordsworth. Munro is fascinated by experiences of disorientation or dislocation in which one no longer knows quite who one is, and by our stubborn attempts to make those moments fit into the narratives of our lives. But she also knows that those are the experiences that allow us to change, to get somewhere: the moments when we risk all because we have nothing to lose. Her small towns are about as folksy and harmless as Twin Peaks, because gaps keep opening in the dull fabric of their inhabitants' existence. Read beneath the surface, don't be fooled by the prosy, matter-of-fact tone, and you'll find that these are some weird and compelling stories indeed.

If you want to know exactly what's going on, if you want to get all the nuances the first time around, if you want to be fed a simple little story, go see a movie. Don't read this book.

If, however, you enjoy reading, if you like puzzling over plots and taking notes, if you like realistic characters with realistic problems, if you like words and sentences, if you like books...read "Open Secrets."

Munro is "great literature." I suspect that in a few hundred years, Hemingway stories will have withered away under scrutiny and our past century will belong to names like Tobias Wolff, Grace Paley, and Alice Munro. She really is that good. And I think it points to something problematic about the quality of primary education Americans receive that a college student would find Munro's stories too complicated for an undergraduate literature class.

And while I'm ranting...

What is it with disparaging a book - comparing it to a talk-show - because it's written by a woman, with women characters doing womanly things? If a book is about women, does that disqualify it from being great lit? Does there have to be a war complete with trenches before it wins accolades? I also shy away from the term, "women's literature." Why categorize it so? Some people create a new category of literature to put their women into, so that they don't have to defend them from the pinheads who mindlessly laud the "classics" tooth and nail. Forget it! Viriginia Woolf, Toni Morrison, and Alice Monro are great authors and compete against any male writer...

Anyway...

"Open Secrets" is an amazing book. Right off the top, she hits us with "Carried Away," where a small-town librarian falls in love with an unseen correspondent, only to have him die in a factory accident before she ever meets him. Of course, that's where the story really starts. Plagued by longing, the librarian marries another man. Years later, she runs into her deceased lover who introduces himself to her for the first time...or is it really him?

It's a complex story, peopled with multi-dimensional characters. Love is at the heart of the story, and "Carried Away" manages to both disparage and glorify the strength of that peculiar emotion.

I'd go on, but suffice to say, the stories in "Open Secrets" are engaging, complex, interesting, and great.

I don't recognize Munro's work in the reviews (editorial and customer) I've read here. Are these stories about women? Are they heavy and soporific? Not in my view. For the most part, I see loving, humorous looks at a piece of geography and its inhabitants, stories which are beautifully written, tightly woven, relaxed, and full of delicious discoveries about people and places. Lots of short stories end with a bang and then they are... over. Not Munro's. Hers never glib, never lazy. They are daring, warming, readable and re-rereadable.

The best story in this collection is "Carried Away," and it, like many of the others, jumps around in time, and from character to character, revealing slowly what exactly it might be about, and then about-facing and revealing that it is about something else entirely, and then about-facing again, then again, until, finally, on the last page, one realizes that the story itself has been modeled after the very complexity of any group of lives as they move among one another, never quite knowing one another's whole story, or their own.

I've never read another writer quite like Alice Munro, and I don't expect I will anytime soon. This book is so its own that it resists the capsule review entirely, and must be experienced on its own terms, story by story.

In "Open Secrets", Munroe tends to delve deep beneath the surface of women's lives. The stories contain intimate descriptions of feelings that many women try to hide, or even deny. The stories are classified as being "short", however the emotions that are brought forth through these words tell a tale that may soothe the soul for a lifetime. In "A Real Life", Dorrie is depicted as a sort of wild woman who shoots rabbits for food and fur, yet still remains dignified; in "Open Secrets", Maureen is a woman who marries her much older husband because she truly loves him, despite his stroke, but does he love her; finally, in "The Albanian Virgin", Charlotte and her strange husband Gjurdhi are presented, both live eccentric lives and leave a distinct impression on those that they meet. "Open Secrets" is a book made for women who want to explore their souls, and are not afraid to find what lies within. Once again, Alice Munroe has truly captured what is is to be "woman"!

I love taking a look around and wondering what the people around me have been through in their lives, what drives them, where they are going. This book gives you snapshots into peoples lives. You find out what motivates them, where they have been, and where they are going. The best part is, they aren't all that special! They are normal everyday people, people you could come across in the grocery store. Its a wonderful read, I recommend it.

In "The Albanian Virgin" Munro contrasts an everyday life of a modern woman with a rather timeless, adventurous tale of another woman who got lost in Albania - and she romantically opts for the latter's life. This story and the "Jack Randa Hotel" seem to me pretty artificial and contrived, whereas Munro seems at her best in "Open Secrets" , "Vandals" , and "A Wilderness Station" - here the lives of common women take on a mysterious, sometimes demoniac quality, the pressure of taboos and fears can become overwhelming.
In all these stories there seem to be some aspects that the author takes up repeatedly: women in their relation to men, women full of possiblities when they are girls, but then they have to adapt themselves to the world, which is shown as run by men, women tortured by fantasies and taboos. Often the men are presented rather unfavourably and women as the ones who are active or superior yet dependent on men. The sense of reality is mostly extraordinary, but sometimes the stories seem to me to be a bit too vague and myterious (e.g. "Spaceships have Landed").

Alice Munro was one of those author's whose name I kept hearing and seeing and yet I never seemed to read. I finally picked up Open Secrets and am now desperate to collect her other stories and novels. Though definitely geared toward women-readers, as all the stories in this collection include women and girls as main characters, anyone who enjoys someone like Margaret Atwood or Jane Hamilton will enjoy Munro.

Many of these books are published in other collections. One could wish Munro had written more so we'd have fewer collections and more originals. However, every piece of writing is worth reading and rereading, so go ahead, buy.

In these not-so-short stories whole lives seem to be revealed. I must have read "The Albanian Virgin" "Open Secrets" and "Carried Away" half a dozen times each over the past few years--and each time I get something new out of it.

She does not fall in line with what we are told a short story should be. Some people may find this maddening; I found it fascinating.