Most Helpful Customer Reviews
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
More poignant than at first appeared, February 14, 2012
This review is from: Ordinary Girl: The Journey (Hardcover)
With the recent passing of Whitney Houston, this book came to mind. While we're all asking ourselves how in the world could such a gifted and successful artist like Whitney succumb to the drugs and seemingly non-nrealities of fame, this is a book of a certified superstar who was able to extract herself from the spiral of meaningless attention and find peace and joy in normalcy. It's a great read with this frame of mind. Take this simple excerpt from the book and you'll begin to see what I mean, "The public life of a singer who is on the charts, as I was at the time, becomes all-consuming and eventually takes everything out of you. If you're not extremely careful, if you don't keep a tight inventory on your own self-worth, you will wind up in some very strange places mentally and physically. That's why so many people in music take drugs or drink. It's their only way to cope, and it either kills them or forces them to look at the reality of their lives. The only way to survive the fame is get control of your perspective on reality, and to do that you have to have a fairly strong frame of reference to the real world. Often it is extremely difficult to know who you ca trust." To everyone who is trying to come to terms with Whitney's death, or the deaths of other stars such as Michael Jackson or Kurt Cobain, I highly recommend this book. It's not a preachy self-help, but that's sort of the whole point. It's a basic story of someone who was at the top, yet chose to step down to live a real life. Kudos to Donna Summer. Not only did she save her own life by choosing normalcy, she also preserved her own God-given gift, and still continues to share it with her fans many years later. She's always been my favorite diva, but not because she is a "Bad Girl." It's simply because she's extraordinarily gifted, yet ordinary at heart.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointingly sparse in detail and uneven in vision, November 6, 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Ordinary Girl: The Journey (Hardcover)
For people who are even nominally familiar with her name, Donna Summer is the Queen of Disco. Critically acclaimed as the only true artist from that musical genre, she left behind the many one-hit wonders and continued a career for the next couple of decades. So how disappointing is this book that is a highly personal look at her faith but says little about her music. The first couple of chapters are interesting, outlining her family background and her almost hippie past in German stage productions like HAIR, but she gives her biggest collaborator, Giorgio Moroder a light dust-over. This is the man who produced and co-wrote many of her biggest hits. This is also the guy who said that in disco, the producer is the absolute dictator! Surely there are stories to be told about working with him and Pete Bellotte for so many years. Surely there were stories when she split with Moroder to work with other producers. It becomes very clear that Summer has avoided dissing the living. She spends some interesting chapters looking at her love/hate relationship with Casablanca Records president, Neil Bogart, but he's dead. Meanwhile, she carefully and diplomatically mentions David Geffen but she glances over her well-documented turbulent years with Geffen Records. That omission is testament to Geffen's continued clout. (Summer fans may recall her thank-you notes in CATS WITHOUT CLAWS which thanked Geffen for 'staying out of the kitchen this time'.) Like other reviewers have noted, she also barely mentions the urban legend that she became homophobic when she became a Born-Again Christian. True or false? Where else but in her biography could she have either talked about her reaction or how she felt about the boycott against her music which effectively blockaded her work for much of the 1980s? But forgetting about the scandals and sizzle of her career, ultimately it is the music that gets shortchanged here. She does not mention one of her biggest hits, "Hot Stuff". She does not mention her immediate post-Born-Again decision not to ever sing her more provocative material and why she reversed that decision. And as the Queen of Disco, she has the unique perspective to talk about the music, its impact and its endurance. Even her critically-acclaimed THE WANDERER is barely mentioned here - and that was a record that John Lennon loved and that tried to move her away from disco into rock - the kind of dance/rock fusion that she had pioneered with "Hot Stuff". If she had any comments about her disco stereotyping, the state of dance music or how easy/difficult it was to be a female pop star in the music industry, she doesn't say here. Oddly enough, at the back of the book is her discography and it too is glaring in its omissions. She includes forgettable soundtracks like THE DEEP and FOXES but overlooks her hits with FAST TIMES AT RIDGEMOUNT HIGH and FLASHDANCE. Her many officially sanctioned greatest hits are also MIA - THE DONNA SUMMER ANTHOLOGY being the biggest one. Perhaps she was embarrassed to list them all? Overall, ORDINARY GIRL is a disappointing peek at a fabulous life and career. There's some selective amnesia going on so for anyone looking for the definitive look at the career of Donna Summer, this book is only 60 percent there.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Very Disappointing Autobiography, October 22, 2003
This review is from: Ordinary Girl: The Journey (Hardcover)
I agree with the reviews of many posters that this is an extremely disappointing book. As I began reading it, I wondered why she was spending an exponential amount of time in the beginning of the book discussing very mundane and insignificant events in her childhood. It would make sense to do this if these accounts offered meaningful insights about the impact that these events had on her later in life, but they do not. As I continued reading the book, I was struck by Donna's omission of important events in her career and life, most importantly her feelings about her place in the disco era, her struggles to maintain a place at the top of the charts, as well as more details on the impact of fame on her life during the disco days. Instead she spent a lot of time talking about cooking with Sophia Loren, her garden, moving to Nashville, and her struggles with her boyfriends and husband. Although these accounts may be the kinds of things Martha Stewart's fans may want to read, they certainly are not what the fans of the Queen of Disco want to read. The book, quite simply, left me feeling hungry, unfulfilled, dissatisfied, and empty. What I really wanted from this book, and what I did not get, was a detailed account of the disco era that defined the 70's and Donna's place in it, her experiences during that time, her feelings about her successes and winning Grammy awards, her relationships with other artists during that exciting time, her feelings about the challenges she faced staying at the top of the charts, her experiences with record companies, her musical experiences during the 80's and 90's when she was no longer on top, and the resurgence she is experiencing now. Many of these important issues are touched on in only a few lines. I believe these are issues that Donna's fans really want to hear about. For those of us who lived through the wonderful and exciting Disco era, a more detailed account on the events of her life within this context would have been an interesting read. I hate to say it but I believe Josiah Howard's biography is much better than this autiobiography. I was very bored reading Donna's book but very intrigued whilst reading Howard's book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|