5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing book, January 4, 2012
The Origin of Speeches title is a play on Darwin. Do you believe that human language develped from monkey grunts or that the Tower of Babel story contains the truth of an original universal human language (Genesis 11:1) being big neurological banged into all the languages of earth (From the Hebrew AReTZ, earth, TERRA reversed). In science this is called Monogenesis of Languqage theory). Did an Almighty Creator custom design language? DO ALL WORDS HAVE ULTIMATE MEANING? This book will explain how proto-Hebrew roots appear in all languages and all words. The research is ongoing. You will be amazed. Go to edenics.net for more information and an interactive dictionary. You will say a loud WOW.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Insightful and Fascinating but poorly written, February 24, 2011
This review is from: The Origin of Speeches: Intelligent Design in Language (Paperback)
Mozeson's "Edenics" hypothesis is truly intriguing, even if controversial. The idea of a single mother tongue for all of human languages has become a largely standard belief among linguists (see the NOVA video, "In Search of the First Language", for an overview of the issue of language origins) and the theoretical basis of Edenics is, in my opinion, as legitimate of a highly-contested theory of language origins as other controversial theories such as Nostraticism. Such endeavors are inherently hampered by the lack of solid (i.e. "accepted") empirical data and often severely criticized by the academic establishment (note how the linguists in the NOVA video mentioned above get a bit reactionary when giving their view of the Nostratic theory).
However, a significant difference between theories like the Nostratic theory and Mozeson's is that (in keeping with his hypothesis that classical Hebrew is the nearest extant equivalent to "Edenic") Mozeson puts more weight on the recursion of root-word _consonant_ patterns in seemingly unrelated languages, following the analogy of Hebrew, which was originally written only in consonants. This changes how data is looked at, because it minimizes the interpretive "clutter" resulting from the terribly fluid nature of vowel qualities in language change, which allows for more clarity in comparing data from seemingly disparate languages.
Why only three stars? While Mozeson explains in the introduction that he is targeting a popular rather than an academic readership, that is poor justification for the jargon-ridden, propagandist tone of the book. This obsession with punning, jargonism, and expressing his ideas through the lens of an us-vs.-them mindset severely detracts from the appeal and readability of the book. As a college English instructor (with a background in biblical languages and descriptive linguistics), I typically grade down for that kind of language use because it hinders effective and convincing writing. Reworking the material in a more appropriate style (e.g. that of an academic monograph) would really help, as Mozeson presents some rather intriguing data to support his hypothesis.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
left me speechless!, October 20, 2009
This review is from: The Origin of Speeches: Intelligent Design in Language (Paperback)
When the reality of what Dr mozeson reveals with this life changing truth and as one allows the truth to force out the fog of evolution (evolution as taught in the average church today the 21st century) & frees the soul & spirit of mankind to gain understanding to know the truth to teach the truth of the language of god from this perspective. The perspective of edenics all fresh truth flows from the mountain top, the e-met will set you truly free. Agro,bio,language!
I can hands down say these facts have changed my life forever (for the good) thanks Dr Mozeson , thanks Bradford
My g-d bless you all the days of your lifes!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No