Customer Reviews

Original Guitar Hero

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

When I listen to this CD, I can't decide if I'm listening with a Jazz musician's ear or if I'm listening for simple sheer enjoyment of the tunes. The tunes as well as the solos are blistering yet catchy. A showcase for virtuosos who don't forget they're creating music with other people. It's wonderful.

Unfortunately, the CD is VERY short. And like ALL of Christian's recordings, even though I love the entire Benny Goodman band, I never feel like there's enough Charlie Christian.

The sound recording is as good as you'll get for the 40's. It doesn't get better than this. You'll be amazed at how good the quality is.

This CD is definitely worthy of a space in your collection.

In the few years that Charlie Christian spent as a member of the Benny Goodman sextet and big band, he recorded solos on 70 different master recordings. if you Include complete alternate takes, which at least in Christian's and Benny Goodman's case often contain strikingly different improvisations from take to take, the music of Charlie Christian with Benny Goodman stretches to over 98 recordings, all of which are included in the full CD box set of this reissue. Although even dedicated Charlie Christian fans may not need six or seven alternate takes of "Benny's Bugle" or even "Breakfast Feud," for my money the box set version of this reissue is a far better buy than this skimpy sampler disc.

Columbia has not made it an easy choice for listeners. The box set arguably did not need to include every single completed take by the Benny Goodman sextet and orchestra which included a Charlie Christian solo. Also, the packaging of this set is cumbersome and buyers might want to transfer each disc to a one or two disc replacement jewel case to avoid scratching the CDs or dropping them as you try to remove them from the unwieldy "speaker box" in which the full set has been packaged.

But the pros outweigh the cons in considering the full box set over this single disc version. First of all, those who are even passingly familiar with Charlie Christians work know that he was truly "a genius of the electric guitar." His music is thoughtful, groundbreaking, endlessly inventive, and explores, like the music of his contemporary Lester Young, the outer boundaries of what we think of as "swing."

The 98 selections in the box set amount to just under 25 cuts per disc. Even if you only count the master takes, and exclude the alternate takes of the same songs, there would still be just under 18 cuts per disc. And even for the casual Christian fan the alternate takes are enjoyable in themselves as superb examples of the best that the swing era had to offer. Finally, Columbia, to its credit, has done an absolutely remarkable job of remastering these recordings. I have owned versions of these tunes going all the way back to the first Columbia two-LP set, and these new reissues are in a league of their own. They are simply breathtaking in the nuance and detail of the sound revealed.

To present an eight cut disc clocking in at about 23 minutes (think of both sides of an early Beatles LP) as a representative sample of Charlie Christian's music, is an artistic and commercial mistake, even at a budget price. I would recommend buying this CD over the box set only to listeners who had never heard Charlie Christian, and wanted to be reassured that they were not wasting their money in buying the four disc box.

There are so many fantastic recordings that are excluded from this disc: "Royal Garden Blues," the astounding "Gilly," with the great trumpeter Cootie Williams, "Six Appeal," "I Can't Give You Anything But Love," and even Christian's signature song with Goodman, "Solo Flight," to name but a few.

All of the music on this eight cut offering is great, there is no denying that. But to limit the listener to eight selections from a jazz master who influenced countless musicians from the 1940s through the 1960s, and who in his brief lifetime made dozens of timeless recordings, seems a shame. For listeners who want more Charlie Christian but not a four disc set in a cumbersome box presentation, I would recommend picking up the two earlier Columbia budget priced discs issued in the late 80s, "Benny Goodman Sextet Featuring Charlie Christian" with 18 selections, and "Genius of the Electric Guitar," containing 16 tracks. Even without the benefit of the newly re-mastered sound, this might make a suitable alternative to the choices offered by Columbia in this new reissue.

The wonderful remastering makes for great clarity, and CC's playing has influenced guitarists worldwide for generations. But as a sampler from the new Columbia box set, this CD is simply too short -- less than 25 minutes long. Why not put out a "best of" selection filling an entire CD? If you're looking for a one-disk volume of CC, you may not find better sound than this, but you can certainly find a more generous helping of his musical genius.

Yep, this one cd will wet your appetite for the wizardry of Charlie, but I think you'd be better off getting the 4-disc set. I've been studying his solos since the 70's, and I still find him refreshing. The fact that he died at 23 makes me think of him as another Jimi Hendrix (without the self-destructive tendencies). If you are a guitar player or a just a fan of this musical era, you won't be disappointed. My goal is to get everything he ever recorded. Make sure you get Swing to Bop.

I disagree with the reviewers who object to the length of the CD. 25 minutes is about as long as I care to listen to these groups. I have Selected Broadcasts & Jam Sessions, and not only are there multiple versions of the same tunes, but different tunes are often rendered in a similar way. Granted, Christian's solos are always varied, but the melodies and style are so similar that it gets repetitious sounding after more than half an hour's worth.

The group lineups vary considerably. Cootie Williams makes significant contributions on trumpet, and Count Basie and Johnny Guarnieri (the best 40's jazz pianist you've never heard of) tickle the ivories in joyous style.

As others have pointed out, this (and the boxed set from which it is drawn) have exceptional sound quality, the best your going to get for these Benny Goodman small group recordings. Unless you're willing to shell out for the Mosaic Young/Basie set, which contains five tracks with Lester Young that are heaven.

EIGHT SONG CD OF CHARLIE CHRISTIAN PLAYING GUITAR WITH BENNY GOODMAN SMALL COMBO. THIS CD WOULD GET FIVE STARS IF IT HAD MORE SONGS ON IT. ABOUT HALF THE SONGS ARE ALTERNATE TAKES OF THE RELEASED MATERIAL.

I knew that CHARLIE CHRISTIAN was among the first to play the electric guitar,but i had never heard him play before i bought this cd.The talent was there to be sure and god knows where it could have brought him if death had not reclamed him at such an early age.Liner notes here are excellent because they explain well the context of those recordings.You'll enjoy hearing about this guy from LES PAUL who knew him.Who can talk about a musician better than another musician?Considering the age of those recordings,the sound is quite good.If you think that BOY MEETS GOY is a boogie-woogie,you just might be not far from the truth.

This is a one-disk teaser for the newly-released box set and, at the same time, a brief but effective introduction to an innovative and influential musician. The remastered sound is excellent for 60-plus-year-old recordings and the peformances are, of course, outstanding. My only quibble is that, since Christian earned his fame with the commercially-released recordings of these songs, why does this CD feature so many alternate versions? This is one of those releases that can't decide if it is targeting beginners or collectors. Can't fault the music, though.