Most Helpful Customer Reviews
17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Terrific for understanding the play, January 4, 2007
As a high school English teacher I struggle with students' bad attitudes toward Shakespeare. Forget reading it aloud! They have no idea what they are saying, and it is painful for all of us. And having them read it on their own is a joke, as they will stop after a page because they can't understand what they are reading.
This unabridged, dramatized reading of Othello is a perfect solution for anyone who wants to read and understand Shakespeare in his original vernacular without reading some kind of "updated" version. The characters are distinct, the pace exciting, and the included music really sets the scene. You could just listen to the CD, but if you're not familiar with the story or you have trouble with Shakespeare, I would follow along with a text as well. And of course, listen to it more than once because you will pick up new ideas or images each time--I know I do!
I have purchased this product twice (once on tape and once on CD). I would love to have a whole Shakespeare set of these!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Laughably Bad!, April 8, 2010
First, I'll own up: I haven't heard this reading of "Othello" to the end, though I've tried to do so twice. I've been forced to abandon the endeavour because I simply can't bear the way the play is being destroyed by atrocious performances in the two major roles. David Threlfall as Iago simply butchers the lines; it's almost as if he's trying to sabotage the part. It's possible that he's intent on making the lines sound "naturalistic" and "modern" so he skates over his lines in a Yorkshire accent with no effort to elucidate their meaning, making the occasional emphasis of a word here and there in a seemingly random way. He clearly doesn't understand what he's saying. One out of many examples: in lines 43/4 of Act One, Scene One: he races over the words, "We cannot all be masters, nor all masters/Cannot be truly followed" by emphasizing the word, "followed" rather than "truly"! And this is typical: when he singles out a word, it is invariably the wrong one.
And if Threlfall is execrable, Don Warrington as Othello is atrocious. Perhaps drawing the tenor of his performance from Othello's description of himself as "rude am I in my speech", Warrington reads his lines with an almost complete absence of expression! To hear him read speeches such as the "Her father loved me; oft invited me;/Still question'd me the story of my life" as though he's reciting "The cat sat on the mat" would be comical if it were a parody. However, this is an ostensibly serious offering! How the director let these actors get away with these performances is a mystery; surely he couldn't be so deaf to the meaning of the words as to give these desecrations the thumbs-up.
The supporting roles are generally better played but then these can only slightly mollify the dismal impression made by the two main parts. Truly of "Guiness Record Book" proportions for sheer awfulness.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Wonderful Dramatization, March 31, 2008
I love listening to British dramatizations of literary works! The Archangel Casts rendition of Shakespeare's "Othello" is extremely well done. Shakespeare's original text is read in a vibrant fashion, complete with sound effects and music. The themes of jealousy, revenge, racism, and deception are clearly evident.
The primise of this play concerns a Moorish general in the Venetian army who is in love with a Senator's daughter, Desdemona. The couple marry, much to the anger and chagrin of Desdemona's father, Brabantio. Before the couple can consummate their marriage, Othello is sent to Cypress in order to defend the island from Turkish invaders. Desdemona pleads to be allowed to accompany him, and is granted permission. She will follow her husband in the company of Iago, Othello's "ensign," or servant, who has his own agenda. Iago is bitterly angry with Othello for promoting an officer named Cassio to the rank of Lieutenant when Iago feels he is the one who deserves the job. Iago also believes that Othello slept with his own wife, Emilia. Resolving to be avenged, the psychopathically evil and manipulative ensign concocts a diabolical plan to convence Othello that Desdemona is having an affair with Cassio. What follows is a psychological drama in which Othello wrestles with doubts and confusion as he tries to learn the truth and ultimately descends into madness. Move over soap operas!
The cast in this dramatization is excellent. David Threlfall is unsurpassable as Iago. His soft, seductive voice, (almost reminiscent of melting chocolate), simultaneously throbs with pretended concern and demonic joy. His soliluquies will chill you as you listen to his remorseless tones crescendo into jeering laughter. Anne Marie Duff is wonderful as Desdemona, providing the listener with a portrayal of innocence and heartbreaking sadness and fear. A special note needs to be made for Clive Swift who portrays Brabantio so well. Swift portrayed Richard on "Keeping Up Appearances," and I enjoyed listening to him in a serious role.
My only complaint about this production is Don Warrington who plays Othello. His accent is very thick, and it might help you to have a text of the play in front of you when he is speaking. This is the only reason I gave this dramatization four stars, but please do not let this put you off. The production is excellently done and should be listened to. Please give it a chance.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|