10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
a fun and shocking eye opener, February 17, 2006
Audre Lorde said "We need a litany for survival." I sooo appreciate when black gay men and lesbians write about their lives, whether they were successful or unsuccessful in their struggles. Here, Simmons speaks of his life in the NFL, having sex with both genders, contracting HIV, surviving childhood sexual abuse, and battling drug addiction. I think this book will be helpful to many populations of readers.
When many people say, "I like doing X", they also mean, "I hate doing Y." or when they say, "I like group X" they let it be known that they "hate group Y." This can be painful for people in Group Y to hear. However, Mr. Simmons is a man who likes everything. Not only does he like men and women, he's cool with blacks and whites. He is proud to do all types of things in the bedroom. This is a football player who likes to pitch and catch, in addition to playing on both teams. This will make many readers comfortable.
My big critique is how he never acknowledges racism or homophobia. Here's a black man who never questions how he easily gets into predominantly white gay spaces. He never once links his jail time to the disproportionate number of brothers who are locked up. Simmons is clearly no Donald Suggs or Keith Boykin, but I wish he spent some time looking at the societal forces that affect him, and others like him. In so many ways, Simmons embodies the "down-low" phenomenon which J.L. King wants to solely represent. Straight women that have loved gay or bisexual men, especially within the African-American community, may appreciate learning more from him.
Usually, layperson-y, chatty autobios have photo sections. This book did not. That surprises me because many of his lovers and relatives still support him despite his lies and conduct while under drugs' influence. His co-author's name is misspelled on the spine of the hardcover. There are times when Simmons discusses scientific or historical matters and it is clearly information that his co-author found and inserted rather than something the football player actually knew.
I like the way that Simmons conveys that he is a work in progress. He may not have conquered drugs or promiscuity. Still, he may offer hope that people can do so. I won't say that I couldn't put this book down, but I will say it was highly enjoyable reading.
It's so amazing that though only 3 NLF players have come out, all have written autobiographies.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Crazy Life Makes Great Book!!, January 1, 2006
Roy Simmon's has lived one crazy life and he shares it with us in his great book Out of Bounds. It starts with the story of his childhood in poor Savanah and his rape at the hands of a neighbor, his realization of his homosexuality, right through his awesome career as a football player and his fight with drugs. It is one rollercoaster ride that you shouldn't miss. Gay or straight, jock or not, this is one great book. Lets just hope that other gay athletes start to step forward and tell their stories because only the truth will set us free.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Got A Little Tiring, December 13, 2009
This review is from: Out of Bounds: Coming out of Sexual Abuse, Addiction, and My Life of Lies in the NFL Closet (Paperback)
This book kept my attention and I was anxious to read it---but after Roy turned into a druggie, it got kind of boring. One slip up after another, making feeble attempts to stop. I got to the point where I was hoping he'd OD and die. Put him out of his misery. I find it rather strange that he uses all kinds of bad language and is rather descriptive in describing some of his sexual trysts, yet he gets religion in the book. It certainly didn't do anything to clean up his mouth. And now that he has found religion, is he claiming he's "cured" of being gay and finds it wrong and that it was a big mistake? The book doesn't say and there isn't much follow up available over the internet so I guess Roy's vanished into society. If he's been "cured" and now condemns homosexuality, I would be VERY upset with him, saying that he only used this book for profit. He was pro-gay through the book. I'm not saying he has to become a spokesman for the gay community or take up AIDS causes, but I think he has to remain true to himself and admit being gay. I also kind of got the implication that after he was outed and found religion, that he kind of used his being raped by a male neighbor as his 'excuse' for being homosexual, which I think is a big cop-out. He even admits he liked it and was interested in other guys at this same time. Is it who he's talking to at the time or is he consistent with his truth. Being the liar and self centered louse he was in the book, I do wonder.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No