10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Alive and Well, April 6, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: The Oxford Book of Sonnets (Hardcover)
Although most people would probably argue that the sonnet is "dead," this anthology proves that it is alive and well and thriving. Yes, the sonnet is more than 450 years old now, but, as a poetic form, it's definitely a survivor.
"The Oxford Book of Sonnets" contains only 328 sonnets, so cannot be said to be a comprehensive study. In his introduction, John Fuller tells us that considerations of expense limited him to including only one sonnet per represented poet still under copyright, with the exception of three (Robinson, Millay and Auden). This fact alone is definitely going to detract from the book, for I certainly would have liked to have had more of Robert Graves, Dylan Thomas, Richard Wilbur, and others.
On the other hand, Fuller does give us eight of Shakespeare's sonnets, eight of Wordsworth's, seven of Milton's, five of Donne's and five of Keat's, three of Yeat's, though only two of George Herbert's.
Female writers, usually forgotten or neglected, are well represented in this book, in particular, the wonderful Christina Rossetti. "The Oxford Book of Sonnets" contains the full text (14 sonnets) of Rossetti's, Monna Innominata, A Sonnet of Sonnets as well it should. This is a gorgeous work.
I'm something of a purist; I like octets, sestets, quatrains and couplets, so I was a little dismayed at some of the more "modern" selections included here, but that's my problem, not Fuller's and not this book's. Some of the works included did seem a little fanciful though. Take Leigh Hunt's Iterating Sonnet. Each of its 14 lines ends with the words, "United States." It was a little too much for me, at least.
What I liked most about "The Oxford Book of Sonnets" was its history of the sonnet as a poetic form. No foreign language sonnets have been included in this book; Fuller sticks to English sonnets here. And he traces the sonnets from the 16th century to the present day.
Purist though I am, I did enjoy Richard Murphy's, Beehive Cell and Jamie McKendrick's, A Shortened History in Pictures. In the latter work, each of the 14 lines evokes a famous painting...very inventive.
This is an anthology and, like all anthologies it cannot be all-inclusive. I am sure other readers will miss some of their favorite sonnets, just as I did. But, we can always buy a volume of our favorite poet to remedy that. Overall, I found this little volume to be quite instructive and informative and I liked the small size as well. It's easy to slip into my purse to read on the bus, on the train, on a plane, anywhere, really.
Those who can't bear anything but Shakespeare would best skip this book; they'll only come away annoyed. But those who are looking for something enjoyable and informative may find what they're looking for in "The Oxford Book of Sonnets." I did.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Working within the (Oxford) Form, April 21, 2001
This review is from: The Oxford Book of Sonnets (Hardcover)
A good one-volume introduction to sonnets in English. John Fuller's strategies for selection are rational, given limitations imposed by his publisher; I'd have prefered inclusion of modern sonnet sequences and more selections by American poets. Perhaps John Fuller will publish a second volume of North American poets; the Oxford "Companions" follow this pattern. Solid, but, oddly for the Oxford Press, neither a comprehensive anthology for scholars nor a compendium for the general reader.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No