Customer Reviews

P.

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

P. What to say about P? Is it a gag/novelty act that so many acts at SXSW were before it became a "serious" musical venue? Is it a vehicle for Johnny Depp and Sal Jenco, or is it a side project of the (...)Surfers' Gibby Haynes between his fabulous but brief on-air radio gig on the then brand-new alternative radio station in the mid-90s and his return to whatever self-destructive habits consumed him before the BHS resurfaced after such a long hiatus?

[What a glorious and surreal couple of months that was, hearing Gibby, daily, on the radio, my, the gods shined their light down on Austin until the bigwigs at the station thought Gibby and his co-host Robbie Jacks (Leatherface from Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2) didn't fit in with their vision. Whatever, I've digressed a bit.]

P, without Paul Leary on guitar, is definitely not like the (...)Surfers and maybe that was what Gibby was going for, but I didn't know that when I bought it when it first appeared at the local used bookstore shortly after it was released -- I saw Gibby on the label and grabbed it, much like most anything that has Paul Leary as producer -- with varying degrees of success.

[Sidenote, P has the distinction of being the band at Depp's Viper Room the night River Phoenix overdosed.]

So, stylistically, what the heck is it? BHS were so hard to describe in simple terms to folks not already into them, weren't they? No different than P. With the requisite song written by local Austin legend/resident psych patient Daniel Johnston (Nirvana fans will see Danny's famous martian toad artwork on Kurt's shirt in videos), and a nod to Abba with a twisted rendition of Dancing Queen, P hits everything in between -- you can hear hints of BHS, a bit of Meat Puppets, a whiff of Reverend Horton Heat. Or is it, perhaps you hear Gibby Haynes in all three? That must be it.

A little bit of punk-infused honky-tonk that was so popular in Austin back in the mid-90s, a bit of speed-swing, a little bit of blues, a little bit of that 50s teen death song style with that crying slide guitar and heavy reverb, kind of like the music they play at small county weekend carnivals that kind of creeps you out.

Final verdict? Only slighty less psychotic than (...)Surfers, but with Gibby at the helm, I have to qualify that, because the songs all have that little bit of irony and comedic tragedy inherent in most things Gibby touches.

For fans of Johnny Depp, you might be a bit disappointed because Gibby is the only vocalist, and if it turrns you on to Gibby, that's fantastic so don't consider it a loss.

For fans of Gibby Haynes, it's a good album to grab if you ever actually find a copy on a shelf somewhere. It'll complete your BHS/Gibby side project collection, and it'll showcase Gibby's talents outside the BHS in a way his work with Al Jourgensen never did -- Jesus Built My Hotrod is soooo totally a BHS song with Al as guest, not the other way around!

For others, it's a nice novelty act that'll have friend saying "I didn't know Captain Jack Sparrow and that (...)Surfers guy had a band!" as you flip through your other singer-turned-actor-turned-singer collection.

Even though I've given it four stars, it isn't one of those great album you constantly search for -- that's more for the loyalty I feel towards Gibby Haynes than anything else, and if it were anybody else I'd have given it a 3.

What it is is a nice addition to any already-stuffed music collection, a good segue when you want to switch between Wilco and (old) BHS or (old) Meat Puppets without making your ears bleed too much. The kind of segue that Depp and Gibby both did with this short-lived band before going on to bigger and better things.

P is a great side project CD which allows the peerless Gibby Haynes and some of his friends to test out some psycho/weird ideas that might not have even found a place on a Butthole Surfers record. The songs are hilarious, whether Gibby's making fun of Michael Stipe, referencing his famous Jimmy Carter suitcase encounter (on "Zing Splash"), rocking out, whatever ("Oklahoma" and "Mr. Officer"), or doing a cover of ABBA's "Dancing Queen" so inspiring that Tesco Vee would have a tear in his eye. Everything you'd want in a good record is here.

Most people tend to regard P as "Johnny Depp's band." Although I hold no resentment towards Mr. Depp, as he is actually a very good guitarist (if not nearly as untouchable as Paul Leary), this is entirely Gibby's show. Then again, nobody gives the Butthole Surfers the respect they deserve. P fits nicely between the noise-meltdown of "Independent Worm Saloon" and the alternative rockin' "Electriclarryland." All Surfers fans should own it, cause this innovative band created a truly great record.

It's not really what I expected at all. IT'S GREAT! Especially the song, Mr.Officer. Prepare to laugh. :)

This is the most well known (...) Surfers Side project, and the reason for that is simply because of the fact that Johnny Depp was in the band and that it came out before ElectricLarryLand and on capital records. Those are the reasons pretty much. What we have here is something very interesting. Most people have glanced at this because of Depp but this is completely Gibby Haynes' (of (...) Surfers) project here. What makes up the album is a variety of songs from weird instrumentals, blues, comedy and the most usage of the Gibbytronix since the BHS album Hairway to Steven. The two covers are standouts with Daniel Johnston's I Save Cigarette Butts outdoing the under produced original and Abba's Dancing Queen being just a joke really. I think it was just meant for the listener to raise their eyebrow as they glance over the CD. I think it's catchy but everyone I've played it for says the original is better.

As for the rest of the music. It's hit or miss, but none of it is terrible. It's fun to see if one can make it throughout the 9 minute Instrumental of John Glenn (Mega Mix). However none of the music is as captivating as most Butthole Surfers Music, but its definitely something to own if your a (...) Surfers fanatic. This band p. only made one album, and do not expect them to make another as it is from 1995. it has been long out of print and you're more likely to get a copy of eBay for $20 give or take. These guys just wanted to get together and have some fun basically. Your much more likely to find them eating at a barbeque then playing at a concert or anything.

On the Japanese import and on a single, there is a bonus track titled Mumble. I haven't had the pleasure of hearing it, if anybody else had please post about it, I wouldn't be surprised if it's just an instrumental or something. Well I hoped this helped, its not essential, unless you're a collector, but remember they made this for fun, so you should listen to this for fun as well.

Honestly, I love it. If you listen to music for the lyrics or to get a good feeling or blah blah blah you're going to hate it. You have to appreciate the raw power of blues and weirdness to like this CD unless you're just a giant Gibby fan.
I bought it last year because Johnny Depp was on it, and coincidentally i like strange stuff like this, and I'd still like it not matter who did it. But if you're just buying it to hear Johnny on guitar, I wouldn't. Listen to a song on youtube to satisfy yourself.
If you're a collector or weird and offbeat punk/blues music, buy it. If you're a Gibby fan, you'll probably enjoy it. If you just saw pirates and want to hear Depp play music, don't.

I happen to be a big fan of songs that sound similar musically with different lyrics. A real fave is Footsteps by Pearl Jam and Times of Trouble by Temple of the Dog. The music is the exact same music, which is fine because the writers participated in both projects. Now, on to P. I love it because it makes me laugh, but there are remarkable stolen riffs on this that NO ONE seems to want to talk about, so I will. Oklahoma is a total steal from Boy from Hells Kitchen from Johnny Depps old band Rock City Angels. Michael Stipe cracks me up because it's clearly Who Will Save My Soul by Jewel. There are more, but I will let you listen to the album and discover the wonderful stolen licks.

To be frank, I only bought this CD because I was curious to see what type of music Johnny Depp would play. I don't know much about alternative music. I didn't hate the CD but I had a great deal of difficulty figuring out alot of the lyrics and I guess I am one of those people who wants to "understand" the lyrics. Some of the music I liked and some of it sounded exactly like what my grandchildren play on my keyboard and they are only 5 and 6. What do I know, maybe they should have their own CD too. But in the end, the big test is that I put 3 of the songs on my iPod, which is why I gave it 3 stars.

Might be good for Tom Waits fans. Not for me but it has potential.

This is definitly a great cd. This deserves 6 stars! Who wouldn't love Johnny playing the gutair?

Hey all! I have been trying to find P for a long time now and can't find it new, or in the UK where I live as I don't think american CD's will play here unfortunately! I have tried the amazon.co.uk site but they do not have it either! Do you know where I could try? Please reply as a review if you know!
Thanks a lot!
:-)