Customer Reviews

The Pacific War Companion: From Pearl Harbor to Hiroshima

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

This book provides a number of different strategic perspectives on the Pacific War in World War II. It is made up of a number of articles written by leading thinkers in the field of military history. Most are professors at universities. As mentioned in one review, one article has inaccurately identified that the US used Avengers for torpedo bombers at Midway when they used Devastators. However, the rest of the articles are accurate in the basics, and some of the strategic perspectives are interesting. Here are a couple for you. (1) Although the US used a Europe first strategy, the most powerful naval units fought in the Pacific, and the number of army divisions provided to MacArthur were still significant (when the divisions in Europe were below necessary), and the most advanced bomber (B-29) was provided to the Pacific War in mid 1944 when the bomber offensive in Europe would have needed them. Obviously, all along, the US had decided to fight a major two front war, and expected to win in Europe with Russian and British help of course. (2) The Japanese expected the US to back off because they expected the US not to be willing to fight a war with significant casualties. Consequently, Japan was not prepared for a long war and essentially fought the war with the same resources at the beginning as at the end: the same fighter planes, the same carriers, the same infantry weapons, etc., while the US technology increased. So, by the end of the war, Japan was outclassed. These are just some of the interesting perspectives of the book. I especially liked the chapter on Central Pacific campaign and the debate that went on between Nimitz and MacArthur to conduct that. However, I didn't give the book 4 stars because some of the articles are weak including the one on Midway that wrongly highlights the use of the Avenger. In spite of this, I do recommend this book especially for anyone interested in WWII.

As one who doesn't read such book for the pictures, but for the ideas and analysis, I found this book outstanding. Each topical chapter was fascinating. While it isn't a narrative history of the war, it helps put the key elements in focus; a highly readable, academic quality dissection of the strategy and tactics.

The best synopsis of the Pacific War I've ever read. Who would've thought that a bunch of history professors could be clear in concept and still be entertaining? This is my Christmas present to others.

I expected more thorough presentations of information aboutthe war. Much was theoretical, generic for the theater.

I wrote Osprey Publishing and pointed out that in the chapter on Coral Sea and Midway; TBD Devastators were identified as TBF Avengers. The 35 Torpedo Bombers that were slaughtered at Midway were not all Avengers(Except for a small Midway detachment.)
There were NO TBF's at the Coral Sea. How does this get through the editing and printing stages?????
They said they would correct the error in future printings, I am stuck with a DUD copy. This is POOR publishimg at its best. I own thousands of dollars of Osprey books and I am mortified to say the least.