Customer Reviews

Page One: Whiteout (Robin Hamilton Mysteries)

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Perhaps it's the unusual location in Escanaba, a small town on Michigan's Upper Peninsula, a seemingly mysterious part of the country few people in the rest of the country know much about, that sets this story apart. Perhaps it's the tender toughness of Robin Hamilton, a young reporter swept up a bloody series of events as she seeks resolution following the still unsolved murder nine months earlier in Crescent, Illinois of her police officer fiancé Mitch Montgomery that caught my interest and sticks in my mind. For sure, the non-stop thrilling action kept my eyes glued to the pages of the latest Robin Hamilton mystery. The delicately swelling buds of romance with Nick Granati, Mitch's close friend who shows up on Robin's doorstep with new information, add extra interest.

The story starts a bit slowly as author Nancy Barr flies through groundwork covered in the previous two stories in this series, but it doesn't take long for the first body to appear. From there on, pages fly by as Robin and her cohort of Nick Granati, her finance's best friend, his cousin Tony, and her friend Charlie Baker, a local policeman, find themselves in one perilous situation after another. Several sinister scenarios unfold, involving forces that could span the globe. It seems unimaginable that such dealings could be going on in quiet little Escanaba. As the story develops, several seeming coincidences in Robin's life the previous few months begin assembling into a larger picture, leading to a stunning conclusion.

A supporting cast of secondary characters, including Robin's dog Belle, flows through the story to lend color and atmosphere. They range from Robin's eccentric professor aunt who is into auras and esp to Nick's mob-connected uncle and various drug users in the Escanaba area. Nancy Barr portrays each character so deftly that, for example, whether she mentioned it or not, I see a dimple in Nick's chin, the gleam of his smile and a twinkle in his eye. I feel Shasta's steely resolve, Tony's tender compassion, and the occasional stabbing intensity of Robin's freshly renewed grief.

She deftly describes the area around Escanaba so well I feel I could get around without a map. But the real thrill is the sense of having ridden along with Robin as she survived an Upper Peninsula whiteout blizzard and came out victorious. She is right up there with Sue Grafton's Kinsey Milhone or Susan Albert's China Bayles as someone I want to stay in touch with over the years, as the volumes continue to emerge.

If you love a masterfully-crafted mystery with plenty of gripping action, this is one you won't want to miss.

I RECENTLY BROUGHT A BOOK ENTITLED "WHITEOUT" BY NANCY BARR.
THIS IS A MURDER MYSTERY BOOK. THE WRITE IS LIKE THE NANCY DREW SERIES.
I WAS VERY PLEASED WITH THE BOOK I RECEIVED.
THANK YOU, MARLENE

I have read all three books in this trilogy and have to say this was by far the best, although "Page One: Vanished" had an awesome conclusion. I was glad to see the main character move beyond the boundaries of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan. Her ultimate goal from the first page of the first book was to resolve the mystery surrounding her fiance's death so it wouldn't make sense to have her try to solve the case while staying in the U.P. From a law enforcement perspective, this last installment is a very realistic portrayal of how the drug community operates in small towns and big cities alike and how it's all connected, sad to say.

I recommend reading all three books in a row. You will get a rich, full character progression as each person makes choices based on the actions of those around him/her. The conclusion of the trilogy was satisfying in that Robin realizes she can't wallow in her own misery, a lesson for all of us. I hope the author is considering doing a series based on Robin's Aunt Gina because she is so unique and fun.

Having thoroughly enjoyed the two previous Robin Hamilton mysteries, I had high hopes for this book. Sadly, I must report that I was rather disappointed.

It's not that the story is badly written. As usual, Nancy Barr imbues her characters and locations with vibrancy and believability.

What's lacking is the "Yooper-ness" that permeated earlier books and, at least for me, set this series apart. Instead of investigating local happenings in a small northern Michigan community, our heroine heads to Miami to help trap a hit man who may have gunned down her fiancé, a Chicago area police officer. Even when the action returns to the Upper Peninsula, the focus is still on what happened months earlier in Illinois.

Overall, the plot relies on too many coincidences. Also I felt the "and they all lived happily ever after" ending of the book, and presumably the series, was rather contrived.