Most Helpful Customer Reviews
39 of 39 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best 50 inch dlp I've seen, November 12, 2004
This review is from: Panasonic PT-50DL54 50-Inch Rear-Projection DLP HDTV (Electronics)
I've had this tv for almost 2 months now. I'd like to first respond to one reviewer:
I've quoted the reviewer with >><<
>>when you turn on the TV , you will notice the fan noise from the projector lamp.. It sounds like the fan in the back of your PC, but a little more noticeable.. =[ .. <<
I haven't noticed any fan noise. no problem here
>>If you are planning on watching DVD's on this TV with a standard DVD player... THINK AGAIN !! You will have to buy a Denon DVD-1910 Single-disc DVD player with 720p/1081i DVI output in order to get a good picture !!<<
That's ridiculous. You don't have to buy any kind of special dvd player to get a good picture. You just need componenet video output or better, which is standard on almost every dvd player sold today
>>Anyway.. If you hook up your existing DVD player with an S-Video cable (Monster or not)! the picture quality is horrible !!<<
That is why the tv has HDMI and component inputs. Use the component inputs for dvd.
>>But you really do need to buy a DVD player that outputs in 1080i and upconverts the picture signal !! You can waste your money on a $170 Toshiba or Samsung Up convert DVD player.. <<
Again, that's ridiculous. Any dvd player with component output is fine. Just take off the stock "VIVID" picture setting on the tv and set it to the "CINEMA" setting
>>Also you don't need all the Monster cables , only an S-Video!! <<
S Video is not a great picture. Maybe that's why you're complaining about picture quality...
Now to my thoughts: I love this tv. I compared it to the Samsung HLP5063 and thought the Panasonic was the clear winner in picture quality. I didn't think the Samsung 5085 was worth the extra money either. It looked as good as the mitsubishi 525 series, too. This tv performs better than ones costing much more, so I went for it. I couldn't be happier. Even standard definition cable looks great, and HD sports is definitaly an amazing experience.
Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
46 of 48 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I'm very happy with this TV, February 17, 2005
This review is from: Panasonic PT-50DL54 50-Inch Rear-Projection DLP HDTV (Electronics)
I spent about three months reviewing big HD TV's and settled on the 50" DLP from Panasonic. This is how and why I made my decision:
1. CRT Projection - Not considered.
2. Plasma - Very expensive for a good picture (prices vary all over, but to get a great picture at 50", your are looking at over $6,000 for a Pioneer). Issues with life, heat, and burn in. Only a must if you want to hang it on the wall (which creates an issue with cable management).
3. LCD Panel - Too small, issues with viewing angles and speed.
4. Micro Projection - This is DLP, LCD or LCOS: LCOS (HDILA from JVC) was out based on many poor reviews. DLP won out over LCD due to life and picture quality. LCD has pixelization, DLP does not but can suffer from a rainbow effect. I looked at many models and types and could not see the rainbox in the DLP's but could clearly see the pixelization in the LCD's. LCD wears out over time, DLP does not (both require bulb replacements).
Brand - For DLP's the choices are Toshiba, Samsung and Panasonic. I was leaning towards the Samsung HLP due to its form factor (much narrower than the others) until I Googled "samsung dlp problems" and found too many horror stories (mostly audio sync issues and early hour lamp failure). I did not find nearly as many complaints about Toshiba or Panasonic. The Toshiba and Panasonic looked nearly identical and I ended up getting the Panasonic as it was on sale at the time ($2,500 at American plus $130 for an extended warranty which did not include the bulb).
Size: I went with the 50" based on my viewing area being about 10' from the screen. Having lived with the TV for a few months now, I would have gone up to the 60." 50" is fine for SD, but in HD, more is better.
Living with it: The TV has given me no problems. No one that has watched it has seen the rainbow effect. I have experienced an audio sync issue only once and this was on a homemade DVD. The TV takes SD cards for viewing photos which is a nice feature. Sound is great and picture is great (including no glare, which was a huge issue in my viewing room before). Once you see something in HD, the SD looks pretty crummy.
About HD: Note that at this time there is very limited HD available via cable or satellite. Where I live the cable is through Mediacom which has NO HD at all. I am on the Dish Network where I receive Discovery, ESPN, TNT, HDNET and HD Movies (you can also get HBO and Showtime in HD for more $$). Direct TV has a similar package. Network HD is available from your local digital broadcasting tower, which means you need an antenna and a HD receiver to get these channels. I have a set of rabbit ears plugged into the back of my Dish HD receiver and am getting all local HD channels except for CBS (I have heard that you can get CBS HD via Dish with an exemption from your local CBS station). HD is absolutely stunning!
You can look at TitanTV.com to see if your local stations are broadcasting in HD. Go to antennaweb.org to see where the towers are in relation to your house and what type/size of antenna you will need to get the signals.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
26 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic set at a great price!, October 21, 2004
This review is from: Panasonic PT-50DL54 50-Inch Rear-Projection DLP HDTV (Electronics)
I had been shopping for a big-screen TV for two years until I finally pulled the trigger on this set. If you are not familiar with DLP rear-projection technology, it allows for slim, light televisions with good brightness, reasonable viewing angles, and no burn-in at relatively low prices.
This set features what is currently the newest DLP technology from TI (the HD2+ chipset) along with an 8-segment color wheel. Television choice is highly subjective, but I compared the picture quality of this set to that of the equivalent Mitsubishi, Samsung, and Toshiba products and, for myself, found the Panasonic to be the best, along with the Mitsubishi. At the price offered by Amazon, it was a no-brainer.
With HD content, the picture is astounding. DVDs also look great. SD (or "regular") content looks dull and washed out, but no worse than any other TV of this size. The chassis itself also looks very nice. My only complaint is that there are not individual picture settings for the different video inputs, but this is minor considering the overall quality of the product.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|