From Publishers Weekly
Harrar (First Tiger) creates a balance of tenderness, humor and dramatic tension in this convincing portrayal of an ADD foster child adjusting to a new family. After being rejected by his birth parents, then several foster families, 12-year-old Andy is anxious to be adopted by a "normal" couple and the Sizeracys appear to fit the bill. However, his good intentions are often overshadowed by disruptive behavior. Confusing the conflicting values of his birth parents and his new guardians, Andy frequently gets himself into trouble. His antics escalating from vandalizing mailboxes to stealing to making false accusations of child molestation nearly threaten his chance for a permanent placement with the Sizeracys. A couple of subplots (Andy's brief encounter with his biological father, a crotchety neighbor's abrupt change of heart towards Andy) get short shrift, but overall this novel offers a persuasive portrait of the inner workings of Andy's mind. The author captures the hero's emotional turmoil and desperate need for acceptance. Readers will sympathize with both Andy and his adoptive parents as they seek and eventually find mutual trust and love. Ages 9-12.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grade 5-8-Andy Fleck's father is in jail and his alcoholic mother has turned her son over to the state because, as an ADD child, she considers him too difficult to handle. At an adoption party, he meets Jeff and Laurie Sizeracy, who agree to become his foster parents and who are interested in adopting him. Having lived in several foster homes, the 12-year-old knows that he'll need to learn a new set of rules. He has always been dishonest and uses lies to get his way. When he does not want to help Jeff with weekend chores, he falsely accuses him of improper touching. When he is taken away from the Sizeracys while the Department of Social Services investigates the accusation, he admits that he lied and needs to convince everyone that he is telling the truth. Eventually the couple officially adopts him. Readers are exposed to Andy's inner thoughts and turmoil. However, information about foster families and the adoption process is sketchy and the time line is inconsistent. Andy moves in with the couple after six outings, having never visited their house. He has very little respect for Laurie, but his attitude slowly changes by the end of the novel. Realizing the power of false accusations of molestation, Andy threatens Jeff with accusations a few times in the book. While a real concern, this inclusion lessens the powerful implications of sexual abuse. Most libraries will be better served by Jack Gantos's Joey Pigza Swallowed the Key (Farrar, 1998).
Shawn Brommer, South Central Library System, Madison, WI Copyright 2001 Reed Business Information, Inc.