12 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The impersonal nature of personal revelation, October 31, 2001
This review is from: The Passionate Eye:: The Collected Writing of Suzanne Vega (Paperback)
Suzanne Vega's Passionate Eye effectively points up some of her ideas in a fresh, readable and consistently interesting format. She uses her song lyrics, poems and prose both recent and juvenile, and a centerpiece radio interview of Ms. Vega by Leonard Cohen (the most "human" part of the book, as Mr. Cohen alternates between simple friendliness, quick wit, deep insight and good, old-fashioned flirtatious play to "illustrate" Ms. Vega's contradictions and the themes of her music through a spirited dialogue).
As in her songs, Ms. Vega writes in veiled themes. She tries to illustrate that one can own the artist's revelations without owning (or needing to know) anything about the artist herself. She quotes passages to support her idea that her particular muse stems from childhood experience, and that she is merely saying the same things she thought at nine. She repeatedly makes the point that it is the elusive (and by inference, the allusive) that appeals to her. As Ms. Vega points out, the communication medium of a songwriter includes in large measure the lyrics of her songs. Yet this is not a mere fanzine piece, but instead a well-done arrangement which highlights her ideas without descending into morose autobio. Although her spare, dark sense of humor peeks through the covers a time or two here, the book perhaps suffers from yet another Vega trait--her consistent effort to maintain a sort of "high seriousness" about her proceedings. I would have liked, perhaps, to see the lyrics of Christine Lavin's Vega parody "Mysterious Woman" arrayed beside Ms. Vega's own lyrics. Ms. Vega shows the reader that she understands the limitations in the persona she created, but we do not quite see what persona she wishes we had seen instead.
Still, I left this book convinced that Suzanne Vega remains a complex and interesting artist, wishing for fame, but disliking the toll it can take on the part of the artist which is not the public persona. Thank goodness this is not a morose "pity me, I'm famous" piece, but a set of images and wordplay, well worked out. Read this, even if you are not a "Suzanne Vega fan".
I left this book feeling that I understood a thing or two about the public person Suzanne Vega seeks to portray, and that I need not know anything more about Suzanne Vega herself. I believe this is what Ms. Vega wants the reader to feel, and therefore she has succeeded admirably.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A creative inner view, April 18, 1999
By A Customer
When you first pick this book up and you have no other knowledge of the writer of lyrics, a clear mind, then you will experience the very edges of the emotional scale, the realistic and the absurd, the sad and the ecstatic, the lonliness of the world and how great it is to be with other people. This book is a must for any who wish to travell the road less travelled. These are not glitzy love stories but words showing our inner lives that few dare to express.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Suzannes Wonderful Work, June 10, 2000
When I began to read this book, I soon found I couldn't put it down. Being a fan of her recorded work, I am used to the gentle, beautiful voice of the singer. Quite how she was fashioned from the childhood and other events in the book I'm not sure. Events such as her being in fights as a child with three people at once, I find it hard to reconcile that sort of early environment with the beautiful music she has created. It's beautiful writing. If you want to know a little bit more about what makes Suzanne tick, I think you'll find some insight here.
I recently atttended a concert of hers where she read passages from the book. Her reading added a lot to it. I had the chance to meet her, and I suggested to her that she record some of the stories from the book, which she seemed to think of as a good idea, so if we're lucky we may see an audio work in the future ( vega.net would be the place to get further details ). It's gorgeous work, and I strongly recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No