9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Vibrant, Challenging Collection, September 15, 2007
This review is from: Past Watchful Dragons: Fantasy and Faith in the World of C.S. Lewis (Paperback)
"Past Watchful Dragons: Fantasy and Faith in the World of C. S. Lewis" is a collection of twelve essays from the Belmont University conference of the same name in November 2005. I attended that conference, and, because I attended several of the talks in the book, I have been eagerly awaiting this volume. It was well worth the wait.
Dr. Amy Sturgis, who helped host and organize the conference and who edited this collection for Mythopoeic Press, has chosen a real diversity of topics and approaches and conclusions about Lewis' faith, his works of fantasy, and his influence. Remarkably, every essay is a winner. My favorites were "Surprised but not by Joy: Political Comment in Out of the Silent Planet," by Karen Wright Hayes, "Sons of Adam and Daughters of Eve: Lewisian Perspectives on the Human in The Chronicles of Narnia" by Donald Williams, and "The Elfin Mystique: Fantasy and Feminism in J. K. Rowling's Harry Potter Series" by Kathryn McDaniel. This last talk, along with Andrew Lazo's talk at the same conference on Lewis and Tolkien as "modern writers," helped reshape my thinking about not only Lewis but Rowling (as a postmodern). Revisiting it in print was a great treat; as with all the essays collected here, it forced me back into the Lewis texts and those he influenced for an appreciation of them at greater depth. This volume is a must-have for libraries with Inkling collections and for serious readers of Lewis specifically and modern and postmodern English literature in general.
The volume is attractively and professionally done. Lest I only say uncritical things, I wish the cover had been in color and that the font had been one point greater. My wife thought the print easy to read, however, and she likes large-print books! De gustibus? Perhaps. I will say the absence of glitches, typos, poor writing, and of ideas that don't work in a collection of this size and diversity speaks well of the editorial hand. Thank you, Dr. Sturgis and Mythopoeic Press, for a book I know I will return to again and again in my reflections on Lewis and the authors he has influenced.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fantastic! Indispensable work on C.S. Lewis!, August 27, 2009
This review is from: Past Watchful Dragons: Fantasy and Faith in the World of C.S. Lewis (Paperback)
This is an essay book that I've returned to many times and has informed my own work and understanding of fantasy fiction and contributed to my own work.
When you buy a CD, you always know you're running the risk of purchasing a few skippable songs; the same is true for a book of essays. But there are no skippable essays in Past Watchful Dragons, edited by Amy H. Sturgis. I found myself consistently saying, "Oh, now this is the best essay in the book." That is, until I read the next one. These are 12 excellent essays; the two at the end which delve into Tolkien and Rowling are nice additions to the 10 on Lewis. I'm not going to get into any of them here, because I don't want to give away their arguments, and I won't do it justice. Purchase of a copy of Past Watchful Dragons. You won't regret it.
Lewis scholar Paul F. Ford wrote, "One hazard in an encyclopedic study such as this is the ever-present risk of analyzing the life right out of a story". This hazard is just as much a possibility for scholarly analysis of a story, but it's a hazard that Past Watchful Dragons completely avoided. This volume is a must-have for lovers of C.S. Lewis. It not only engages in excellent scholarly work, but it maintains the vital heart of Lewis's writings. You don't expect to have your heart moved while reading a collection of academic essays, but that's what will happen if you read Past Watchful Dragons.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No