Most helpful critical review
219 of 237 people found the following review helpful
Stay away at all costs
on July 29, 2010
This is horrible. They could have made an interesting Paul Is Dead film with all the old clues, but they didn't even get the simpliest facts straight. They say Paul dies in 1966. They then say the Beatles put clues in their songs. Some awful samples: The say they recorded the album "Yesterday and Today" (which was never an album they recorded, but left over tracks) after he died. On that album they claim that John wrote Yesterday for Paul. "Yesterday" was released in 1965 on the Help LP. They even played it in concert in 1966, before the date they claim that Paul died. The Rubber Soul album was recorded before the 1966 date that they say Paul died, but they cite clues in the songs and on the cover. The have the fake George Harrison voice say that John and Paul wrote "Only a Northern Song". George himself wrote it and sang it. They claim that Heather Mills was the girl in the car with Paul when he died (marrying him after Linda died on a bribe to reveal the truth) That was 1966. She was born in 1968. if she was an adult in 1966, she would be almost Paul's age now. Not even close. There are many more instances of simple facts they could have gotten right, and it would have been an interesting piece of fiction, instead of a horrible joke. Really shoddy fact checking on a band whose facts are easy to find.