Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Call It Whatever You Want, This Is A Classic!, June 26, 2006
Ten years ago when I bought the Andrew Hill Mosaic set, the most pleasant surprise for me was a session from February 10, 1965, which had first been issued on vinyl in the mid 70s as part of the double album "One for One." This date contained some of the best music I had ever heard from Hill, and the fact that it featured a stellar band of Freddie Hubbard, Joe Henderson, Richard Davis and Joe Chambers, operating on a seemingly telepathic level, instantly made it one of my favorite Blue Note albums. Now it has been reissued as a single title in the Connoisseur series as "Pax."
Unfortunately, a truly original jazzman like Hill has always had a tough time cracking into the mainstream. Until recently many of his albums had not even been reissued on CD, but fortunately that has now started to change. In fact, with the reissue of multiple classic Blue Notes (see my reviews of "Black Fire," "Smoke Stack" and "Judgment!"), a brilliant new disc entitled "Time Lines," and Mosaic's recent 3CD "Select" title containing all of his Blue Note sessions from 1967-70, this is probably the best time ever to discover and collect the music of this jazz piano genius. And I can think of no better place to start than "Pax."
|
|
|
23 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Blue Note is starting to piss me off..., August 3, 2006
...but more on that in a bit. First this CD. The personnel is Joe Chambers on drums, Richard Davis on bass, Joe Henderson on tenor sax, Freddie Hubbard on trumpet and Andrew Hill on the piano. It was recorded in early 1965. The music was unreleased until it was released as part of a double LP in 1975, then in the limited edition Mosaic Box in the nineties. This is its first individual CD release.
Michael Richman is right. This is a classic. From the opening notes of Henderson's solo on Eris you know that. Henderson is magnificent- no other tenor sounds like he does. His tone is so dry and he does these funny whispy little runs if the upper registers of the horn. Hubbard is on fire- stabbing out ideas and in absolute control of his horn. This was such a productive period for him.
As for Hill, one of the things I really admire about him is the sense he gives me of being so balanced. All the elements of his playing are so measured. He loves dissonance yet is lyrical, he is obviously very thoughtful about what he writes but he always sounds passionate.
Richard Davis and Joe Chambers are the perfect foundation for this group. They are both very complete players- they don't just keep time. They illustrate. They suggest ideas. And that gets to something that was so wonderful about Blue Note at this time.
Blue Note seems to have been a musical collective for some of its artists. It allowed them to work out their ideas in the company of other very creative and thoughtful artists. In this sense, you can hear on the best Blue Notes, the artists actually learning from each other as they play.
On Andrew Hill dates, in the company of the likes of Henderson, Hubbard, Davis and Chambers, the results are music that is timeless. Now why that music had to sit for ten years to see the light of day, then another 20 years to be released again is just bizarre.
Michael makes the observation below about Hill only recently coming again into prominence with the public. That recent prominence is simultaneous with the recent release of so much previously cached music. Do you think it might be possible that if some of this material had been easily available during all of the last 40 years that Hill might have had more prominence?
As you can tell, I have a real love-hate thing going on with Blue Note. But let me be clear. Blue Note is an important label for one reason only. Because (with amazing frequency) its stable of artists put out music that was and remains important, innovative and tremendously influential. As well as just great to listen to. This CD should have been released to acclaim.
That that acclaim comes 40 years late is a cultural crime. So let's get listening and give Mr. Hill his due and our thanks for yet another great grouping of music from a career that has been as productive as any in jazz.
|
|
|
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Wandering, Wonderful Sound, July 30, 2007
Andrew Hill was, like Herbie Nichols, Thelonious Monk, Bud Powell, or Sonny Clark, an individualist, a follower of his own internal beat, and a rare example of humaness laid out for all to see. An individualist is someone most people want to be, and who most people pretend to admire, but ironically someone who many people despise in actual practice. As a composer and player Andrew Hill could draw violent, venom-spitting reactions by simply following this own way towards a melding of the avant-garde and jazz tradition through the prism of his particular and unique point of view. It seems he had the unfortunate ability to make people feel stupid. The personal vision he shared of one possible future for jazz is characterized by an open-ended, meandering quality, one full of jagged edges, improvisation without resolution, caked with self-conscious vunerability, yet structured in a way that isn't a break from the tradition of Monk or Parker. For me it's much more interesting than say the course that Albert Ayler, Archie Shepp, or later-day Coltrane were following. In anycase the album "Pax" is typical of Hill's work in that it took a slow eternity to see the light of day, but fortunately Hill managed to avoid the common but twisted humor of fate, that ironic turn that only lavishes praise on an artist after he dies, by receiving some belated recognition with the release of this and other albums ("passing ships", "dance with death", and the new "timelines") a short time before his passing. On "Pax" Hill is teamed up with the creative, thoughtful, and frequent collaborator of Bobby Hutcherson: drummer Joe Chambers, as well as the bassist of choice for the borderline avant-garde: the always interesting Richard Davis. Like "black fire", "Pax" is accessible in relation to say "compulsion", and like "black fire" this recording shares the athletic talent of Joe Henderson. Unlike his first recording for blue note however, "Pax" is more out, and shows a more mature, more sure of his direction, artist at work. There is a lot of fine, textured blowing by the fired up Henderson, who shares his front line duties with the amazing avant-guard flirt: Freddie Hubbard (see "ascension", "out to lunch", "compulsion", etc.), who acquits himself very well, and always seems to stay with in the mood of the tunes here. The mood I spoke of is less ominous than usual, but still wonderfully wandering, and full of fast-paced flurishes. Sounds run together and seperate to create a complex web of a seemingly fragile sonic structure. If you are able to hear and dig the worth of Andrew Hill's musical individuality, you will be able to find in the album "Pax" this unique composer/pianist at his very best.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Interact With Your Music: Discover, listen to, and buy new music, all from the pages of SPIN's digital edition, free to Amazon customers.
by Andrew Hill 
