19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A nice addition., August 21, 2001
In John Knowles' "A Separate Peace" the reader is taken on a visit to the Devon School, a college preparatory school in New Hampshire. Through marvelously descriptive narration and telling dialogue, Knowles dissects the adolescent mind of the boys who were faced with the horrors of World War II. In his follow-up novel, John Knowles again takes the reader to Devon, and explores the psyche of similar boys at the time just after the War. Though the story is a bit more confined than that in the first book, I think that it has to be. This new batch of characters must look to themselves for a reason for the way they are, rather than to the oppressive state of the world. Knowles gives a brilliant depiction of the aggression that still remains in all of us, even in times of Peace. If you loved "A Separate Peace" as so many others do, myself included, then you owe it to yourself to read this book. It IS different, but it should be.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Peace Breaks Out, December 14, 2003
Peace Breaks Out begins with Pete, a man coming home
from war, coming to Devon. He wants to become a teacher there
because he was once a student there, and loved the peacefulness
of it. He felt that it was untouched by war. In his first class
he encounters three boys that particularly stand out from the
rest of the class. Their names are Wexford, Nick Blackburn, and
Hochschwender. Each of them with their own characteristics and
opinions. However, all of the boys have a certain image of war
because they were in the year of 1945. In class Wexford and
Hochschwender developed a gut-hatred for each other. This begins
to develop into something very serious as the story progresses.
They begin a newspaper rivalry because Wexford is the editor of
the school newspaper. Hochschwender begins sending in "Letters
to the Editor" challenging many of Wexford's thoughts. Pete,
being in search for peace, doesn't quite find it while he is at
Devon. Because of such disagreements on war the boys became
restless and argumentative. Throughout the story American
history is mentioned, and because of this topic enemies begin to
form. Pete ends up being in for a lot more than he bargained
for, when peace breaks out.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Knowles Style Keeps It Up, But..., December 10, 2000
'A Seperate Peace', Knowle's best known novel, is hailed not only for its absolute perception of the adolescent mind but also for its highly memorable and beautifully crafted style. His ability to move from this eloquent language into dialogue is another one of his greatest achievements in the novel. 'Peace Breaks Out', set again at Devon and referring to the characters of his earlier novel only fleetingly, lacks the storyline that appealed to so many young people- mysel included. His characters are far less intruiging- there is the tainted war hero, the bitter genius, the naive brother. ALthough they are all important, they simply do not resonate the way the protagonaists of his earlier novel do. However, whatever the novel lacks in character it more than makes up for in style. His language is so perfectly crafted, and his dialogue so vibrant, that reading it from a writer's point of view is truly inspiring. His language truly builds, and falls, and is absolutely melodic. His perceptions, handed to us so brilliantly, are stunning. John Knowles created a little-known phenomenon with 'peace Breaks Out' that is, unfortunately, better appreciated by lovers of language than by lovers of story itself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No