Customer Reviews

Peleliu: Tragic Triumph: The Untold Story of the Pacific War's Forgotten Battle

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is probably the best account of this particular tragic battle I have come across. The battle alone, Peleliu, is not well known and now that it falls into the category of "ancient history" by the younger set, is even less heard of. This is a shame. The history of the U.S.M.C. is a testament to the ability and endurance of the American fighting man and woman Never has there been a better example than this forgotten battle. I have had the honor of having several conversations with two of the survivors of this epic battle...it is hard to imagine that the human body and spirit could survive such a thing. They did. The author has done his research with this one. He has been able to address the controversies surrounding this episode without distracting from the bravery of the men who took part in it. There is much to be learned here, both of the human condition and of military blunders and why they happen. I highly recommend this one be added to your collection.

With only two reader reviews to this point, it is possible that this book has not had much readership. Tis a shame, since when compared to some of the books written shortly after this engagement, this one is certainly more comprehensive and insightful. With the added benefit of the previous books and other documents, plus interviews and correspondence, this book reflects a wealth of research, in addition to being well written. Also, when compared to the more recent book, Last Man Standing, by Dick Camp, it is certainly a better choice for understanding this battle.

There is plenty of controversy about the need for the battle at Peleliu as well how it was conducted. Bill Ross addresses both and doesn't mince words with regard to his views. He extoles the courage and spirit of the fighting forces while questioning the "leadership". It begins with Admiral Nimitz's decision to pursue this battle despite solid evidence that it was no longer necessary. It ends when General Rupertus is belately overruled and the Army finally brought in from reserve to replace the few remaining combat capable marines.

Other books to consider on this battle are With the Old Breed at Peleliu and Okinawa (Sledge), Coral Comes High (Hunt) and The Devil's Anvil (Hallas).

I read this book after playing Call of Duty: World at War which contains battles that take place on Peleliu. Wikipedia indicated that Peleliu was the scene for one of the most difficult battles in WWII history and so it piqued my interest. After completing this book, I left somewhat disappointed. The book is clearly well researched and I actually like the pains the author takes to be "fair" with regards to not being a Japan bashing tome. But overall, I left without any particular takeaways after reading it.