Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great content, not so great "packaging", July 21, 2010
This review is from: Penny Arcade 6: The Halls Below (Paperback)
This book contains every PA comic from 2005. That wasn't a bad year for PA, so you're getting good comics... all of which are still perfectly available online. To me, the only point of these volumes is to have a physical copy to read while "dropping the Cosby kids off at the pool." Here's the thing: The first five PA volumes were published by Dark Horse. This sixth volume was published by Del Rey/Ballantine, and some changes have been made... and not for the better.
Until now, I never really gave too much thought to the books themselves; they're just typical comic paperbacks. But now that they've changed publishers, the drop in quality is instantly noticeable. The paper stock is lighter/cheaper than previous volumes, particularly the cover. Volumes 1-5 all had printed inner covers, they were covered by gray-scale patterns in keeping with the theme of each volume (e.g. the inner cover of Birds Are Weird was printed with a pattern of pigeons.) I never even noticed that before, but I notice now that I'm looking at vol. 6, which has blank white inner covers. They've used a weird new font for the titles of the strips, which is mildly annoying. In previous volumes, Holkins' commentary for each strip was always, ALWAYS directly beneath the strip he was commenting on. In this volume, sometimes the page layouts are such that there's no room for the commentary below, so they put it on the opposite page instead; seems kinda sloppy. (Though the commentary is as fun to read as ever, usually... a few of them do seem a bit "phoned in".) Moreover, vols. 1-5 all shared a common graphic design philosophy whereby at a glance it was obvious that they all belonged to the same series. Vol. 6 has a completely new design style, so if you put them all on the shelf together, suddenly there's an odd man out. Mildly annoying.
To sum up: Great comics, great commentary, mildly annoying drop in production quality, series consistency has been chucked out the window. On the bright side, at least now I have a new appreciation for how well vols. 1-5 were put together.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Lackluster, hard to read, July 23, 2010
This review is from: Penny Arcade 6: The Halls Below (Paperback)
The comics are excellent as always, but the printing of the comics is awful!
They're so blurry they're often hard to read. I could print better versions of them from their site with my Ink Jet Printer.
Also where volume 1-5 are printed pristine, and each comic has thoughtful, modern, commentary on it, this one often has either ramblings nothing to do with the comics, or Jerry explains that he has no idea what was going on here, its like they got lazy.
I am *very* disappointed with this. The other books were an awesome part of my collection. This one soils the series.
I LOVE Penny Arcade, and I wanted and expected the beautiful versions I got from Volumes 1-5, but this is bad, really bad.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Great comics, shame I cant see them., August 8, 2010
This review is from: Penny Arcade 6: The Halls Below (Paperback)
The first 5 penny arcade collections, published by Dark Horse, were great quality, heavy paper stock with great quality printing.
This is the exact opposite of that. Thin paper, blurry prints, Lazy commentary.
2005 was a good year for PA comics, but do yourself a favour, read them online, this collection really isnt worth paying out for.
Its obvious someones saved a bundle choosing to print these at sub par quality, but we as the consumer arent seeing any of these savings.
Dont bother with this collection, the only good factor is the rather classy front cover.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
