4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting and Diverse, September 17, 2011
Frequently enjoyable, occasionally heart-wrenching, and almost always a thought-provoking and immediate cultural immersion. The very diverseness of the collection was interesting of itself.
My VERY favorites for narrative strength:
1. Peter S Beagle, "UNCLE CHAIM AND AUNT RIFKE AND THE ANGEL"
2. Glen Hirshberg, "THE MULDOON"
3. Jonathon Sullivan's "NIELS BOHR AND THE SLEEPING DANE"
4. Tamar Yellin's "REUBEN"
5. Michael Blumlein's "FIDILETY: A PRIMER"
My favorites for uniqueness of plot:
1. Neil Gaiman's "THE PROBLEM OF SUSAN"
2. Matthew Kressel's, "THE HISTORY WITHIN US"
3. Max Sparber's, "ELIYAHU HA-NAVI"
4. Elana Gomel's "GOING EAST"
Wistfully beautiful:
Rose Lemberg's "GEDDARIEN"
Just plain fun, but with deeper layers:
Michael Chabon's "GOLEMS I HAVE KNOWN"
Disliked:
Rachel Pollack's "BURNING BEARD" (felt sacrilegious)
Don't give up after the first few stories, their quality gets better! The anthology could have been enhanced by including a few NON-fiction editorial essays on the subject matter.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No