8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great book. Easy read and informative, September 19, 2008
This review is from: Pepi and the Secret Names (Paperback)
This book has great pictures and is very informative in an easy to read format. I am very Christian but in no way were we offended in the way it discussed the gods of Egypt. They believed in gods and they are taught as part of history.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful book!!, December 20, 2008
This review is from: Pepi and the Secret Names (Paperback)
When I first opened this book, I thought, "No way the kids are going to sit and listen to all this text," but was I ever wrong! The language is pure storytelling magic -- they were spellbound. Oh, and they learned something about ancient Egypt, their gods, burials, and hieroglypics. But the one detail that makes this book irresistable is Lady Miaou, the cat, eating roast duck. My kids will read it just for the tabby cat. :)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Passable as a homeschool resource, March 4, 2011
I bought this book because it was widely recommended in Christian homeschool curricula. I was initially disappointed in the book when we read it the first time, but I have changed my opinion as I have explored the genre further... finding a good conservative book on Ancient Egypt is not easy!
First the Pro's: The book is beautifully done. The illustrations are marvelous and appealing even to preschoolers. My little kids loved looking at the lion, hawk, crocodile, and cobra which come to speak to Pepi. They also related to the idea of a boy trying to help his father paint these creatures, and thought it was fun every time the creatures showed up for real in the father's temple. They also enjoyed the hieroglyphics and the idea of each animal having a secret name. And of course the running subplot of the tabby cat showing up. It was a good story and the author put a lot of time into telling it. There was nothing objectionable in the account either--no inaccuracies, inappropriate language, or liberal kooky things thrown in there. There wasn't even a lot about the Egyptian gods and polytheism, which is sometimes confusing for the youngest ages. It's just a good story. So I appreciate that.
Also, there is a great hieroglyphics chart on the back page. My second and third graders had a lot of fun using it to write each other messages because the glyphs were big and more well-formed than in some of the charts they'd come across before.
Now the Con's: The main problem is that the book is a good length but not formatted as well as it could be for younger kids. When I first read the book myself, I thought there was no way my younger kids would make it through all the text on each page. They didn't. And the storytelling itself was too far above their level (preschool, kindergarten, first grade). I had to dumb down sentences and skip some things in order for them to keep up with the story. They loved the story, but the text was more suitable for my third grader. Indeed, some curricula recommend this book for 3rd grade and up, but by then they have missed an apt audience in the littlest kids who would enjoy this most!
Secondly, the story is just SLIGHTLY scary. I mean, it is demystified as it goes on, and as you read it again and again, but my littlest ones were slightly intimidated the first time through with the creatures who threaten to hurt Pepi, his father, and the Prince if things don't go their way. I'm not sure they understood the context. If your children are sensitive or if this is their very first introduction to Egyptian literature (as it was for mine), it might help them to understand that these stories can be kind of strong. And that some of the Egyptian gods were represented by these animals--which is unusual for the Judeo-Christian mind. We did a small animal unit after reading this, to get the kids used to the idea of Egyptian animals showing up in the literature--but maybe I should have done this beforehand.
Lastly--and this is just a small thing--there is nothing very educational about the book itself. It doesn't explain the premise of secret names, hieroglyphics, or anything about Egyptian culture. It doesn't even have a moral. After viewing many other Egyptian stories out there, this definitely rose to the top of the list. I was glad we got it but mainly because of the junk it did NOT include rather than anything proactive it did include. I am not bashing the book in any way--it is a nice Egyptian fairy tale--I'm just not exactly sure why it's a staple in some homeschooling curricula.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
