Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
Perceiving God: The Epistemology of Religious Experience Paperback – September 29, 1993
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
"The elegant and comprehensive argument in this book is the definitive version of a position Alston has been developing over the past decade. It is arguably the most important investigation of the epistemology of mysticism from a sophisticated analytical-pragmatic perspective since James's Varieties."―Theological Studies
"This splendid book is the fruit of decades of mature and penetrating reflection. As you would expect, it takes discussion of the topics surrounding experience of God to a new level of insight and penetration"―Alvin Plantinga, University of Notre Dame
"A first-rate and truly important piece of work, Perceiving God is both a signal contribution to the philosophy of religion and a powerful treatise in epistemology. The book is philosophically rigorous and admirably lucid. It is in my judgment the leading contemporary work on the epistemic status of religious experience."―Robert Audi, University of Notre Dame
If you’re the author, publisher, or rights holder of this book, let ACX help you produce the audiobook.Learn more.
Top Customer Reviews
Alston projects his moderate foundationalism into philosophy of religion, in his model experience may be intimately conncted to experience of God, although it is never thought to be infallible. According to Alston theist belief is based on two pillars, natural theology and religious experience, where experience is the most important part.
The book may be read as a modern analytic philosopher's attempt to identify with the Christian mystical tradition, with its empahsis on direct awareness of God.
Alston begins by taking mystical experiences at face value. If someone claims a mystical experience of God, Alston accepts that experience as supporting a prima facie justified belief in God as possessing the quality or performing the act mystically perceived, unless it runs afoul of an "overrider system."
An overrider system is a socially accepted set of beliefs that negate (override) a particular perception when the perception is contrary to the accepted beliefs. For Christianity, "the Bible, the ecumenical councils of the undivided church, Christian experience through the ages, Christian thought, and more generally the Christian tradition are normative sources of its overrider system." (Location 4844.) Overrider systems vary by religion, and this throws Alston's theory into a morass of relativism.
Depending on the overrider system, the same mystical perception could produce a rationally justified belief within one religion while producing an identical but unjustified belief within another.Read more ›
Philosophers will enjoy "Perceiving God" even if they don't buy the conclusion. However, ordinary believers will be left cold, if they finish the book at all. I took off one star because I was unpersuaded by the author's finessing of the question of how Christian mystical practice can be veridical even though it clashes with the mystical practices of other religions. Overall, non-philosophers interested in mysticism should start with William James' "The Varieties of Religious Experience" before they tackle "Perceiving God."
Thesis: “The chief aim of this book is to defend the view that putative direct awareness of God can provide justification for certain kinds of beliefs about God” (Alston 9). Ironically, discussing religious perception raises questions about sense perception (SP). Therefore, Alston gives us his Theory of appearing: the notion of X’s appearing to S as so-and so is fundamental and unanalyzable (55). For S to perceive X is simply for X to appear to S as so-and-so. Applied to religious experience, this means:
*Is it possible that “God” should be appearing to S in y experience?
**Is it possible that God should figure in causation in that experience in such a way as to count as what is perceived?
***Is it possible that that experience should give rise to beliefs about God?
Alston then takes a brief detour to give an account of current epistemology. This is where the true "money" of the book is. I have some doubts as to how far his M-belief justification can be taken. But the book is worth it in terms of his Reidian epistemology.
The problem of criterion and regress will face every scheme (146-147). However, we seek the justification of beliefs on adequate grounds. These ground are certain doxastic practices (belief-forming practices).Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
This is a difficult read for anyone that is not trained to read philosophical literature. It is a challenge to get through, certainly. Read morePublished 20 months ago by InHisGrace0960
Alston is brilliant in his assessment of the reliability of sense perception, and his comparisons of divine perception to other sorts of uncommon(ish) perceptual experience is... Read morePublished on April 30, 2014 by HHH