Customer Reviews

The Perfect Basket: Make Your Own Special-Occasion Baskets

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(2)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

I am not saying this is a "bad" book. It has good ideas for making a gift basket. However, I was disapointed that there were no pictures. The book is pretty general. I suppose I picked the wrong book for what I was looking for. I am going to go back and look at the other books like this one and purchase another one or two.... It is a good book if you are just really looking for some ideas. I wanted something that was more geared toward making gift baskets as a business, this is more on a personal level.

I wished I had read the previous reviews before I jumped to buy this book. Unless you really know about gift baskets before you read this book, it's not very helpful or clear.

I did not find this book helpful. It did not show how to assemble a gift basket, had no pictures, no originality, and little information that was innovative. Neither did it offer any business tips nor suggested resources.

Though pictures are nice, they can inhibit one's own creative thought. This book gives well-organized lists of gift baskets for a large variety of people: college students, various individual sports, even a French basket.

I thought that this book would give me at least a few pictoral examples on how to make gift baskets. I was disappointed. I'm not naturally creative, so my feeble attempts at using the book did not come off looking as good as I had hoped. On the other hand, one of my daughters-in-law loved it and wants me to order 2 for her.

I found this book to be very informative. I have arranged several baskets and given them as gifts. I also bought The Perfect Mix and found it very good as well. The mixes are made up of everyday ingredients and the items that are suggested for the baskets are things that are easy to find as well as inexpensive. Well worth reading!

I recently received my book. While there are no pictures, it gives you many wonderful ideas for making your basket. I actually preferred not having any pictures, that way, my basket would be unique and original not a copy out of a book. I have already made two bath gift baskets using the ideas out of this book. They turned out wonderful! My imagination was free to run wild without being limited to copying it out of the book! Whether you are a novice or an expert, it is a must have for basket makers everywhere!

When it comes to "creative gift ideas," I have none. This has given, and continues to give me great gift basket ideas. Everyone now thinks that I always bring the coolest gifts when I put together a basket like any in this book. I also recommend Diane Phillips' "The Perfect Mix."

When I bought this book, I thought that I would be getting info on how to assemble gift baskets. I was very disappointed. This book merely offers suggestions on what to put in the basket. It offered no thoughts on basket arranging, types of baskets to use. If you are a novice at gift baskets, this is not the book to buy because it does not tell you anything you don't already know. On a positive note, the recipes in the book sound delicious.

`The Perfect Basket' crafting / cookbook by Diane Phillips is an inexpensive little book which offers a wide variety of imaginative giftgiving ideas which require very little crafting ability. You can be all thumbs with the glue gun and still be a winner with many of the projects in this book. It is almost overstating it to say these are `projects', as the hardest thing about many of the suggestions if finding some of the components.

While a basket is the container you always picture when you imagine gift collections (except me, whose all time greatest gift collection came in a plain cardboard box, giftwrapped, at Christmas when I was five years old) one of this book's major suggestions is in how to use a lot of different kinds of containers. My favorites are a `Radio Flyer' little red wagon and a slow cooker.

These two examples point up one important fact that along with the `easy to do' aspect of these collections goes the `not exactly cheap' caution. The author does us a great favor of giving us up to three different price levels, adding more and more expensive items to fit a more generous presentation. But, even the least expensive collections will rarely run less than 25 dollars and some of the high end collections can easily run to over 100 dollars.

And, the price level may vary widely if you are not careful or willing to choose less expensive, and therefore less impressive items. For example, the `Festival Italiano' $25 basket includes extra virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar. The problem is that a good `everyday' (Bertolli, Berio, Colavita) brand and size (1 Liter) of extra virgin olive oil can run to $15 and a good `everyday' brand of balsamic vinegar brand and size ((500 ml) can also run to over $10. Premium brands of both products can run to $50 a bottle, and if your recipient has high standards, a below-average brand will create a below-average impression. But this gets into knowing your recipient. My only point is that some of Ms. Phillips' collections can be expensive and they can be a lot more expensive than her suggested price. One place where the author specifically underquotes prices is in some of the containers. That little Radio Flyer wagon may only be available in pricy speciality stores and I am certain that a backpack `basket' from The North Face company will run to $50.

Another virtue of this book is the variety of occasions for which the author offers suggestions. And, almost all the collections are general enough so that tweaking them a bit one way or another will turn a `Picnic Basket' into a housewarming basket or a Memorial Day or Labor Day or 4th of July gathering basket.

The book is divided into a larger section of `Special Occasion Baskets' which involve no cookery and `Food Baskets' where the centerpiece is one or more homemade mixes for baking or assembling cookies, breads, muffins, chili, tea, lemonade, scones, salads, salsas, pancakes, popovers, or you name it! Recipes for these goodies actually require practically no cooking skills. The most important skill is the sense to buy a really good set of measuring tools (and know how to use them) and secure glass containers in which to put the goods. The recipes all have two parts. The first part, which is generally very simple matter of measuring and mixing either all wet or all dry ingredients, is for the gift giver. The second part, presented on pictures of little index cards, is for the recipient, and it is up to the gift giver to transfer this recipe to a card and place it in the basket with the ingredients. I think the author really missed some good opportunities here. The very easiest way to transfer these `end user' recipes to the basket would be to scan them into a computer and print them on card stock, but the author gives no clue to how this can be done. I am not expecting a cooking specialist to also be an expert Kinkos operative, but a mention of this technique and some guidance would have gone a long way. Another suggestion would have been for the author to offer all these recipe cards on images on an internet site which could be downloaded and printed.

On perishables in general, the author offers excellent warnings to the gift giver to on what to tell the recipient about the shelf life of the mixtures.

The book opens with a nice section of general tips on assembling baskets. This includes the tip which always rubs me the wrong way, about being sure to pack the basket with raffia, shredded paper, or plastic to bulk up the appearance of the goodies. It seems to me that a superior method is to provide candy, hand towels, or shop towels as filler. That is, bulk up with something which is useful.

I'm sure there was some issue with publisher Harvard Common Press on keeping the book down to an easily marketable price, but I think a picture of each and every basket would have been a good thing here. I rarely feel the need for pictures for food recipes, but here, the presentation is the whole game. I don't know what the legal issues are here, but it would have been a very clever way to present recommended brands without mentioning them in the text. The quality of the pictures which are given give a small taste of what could have been done with a picture for every basket.

While I have not reviewed any other books on doing gift baskets, I sense that this volume is excellent for the price, but it could have been a bit better. The very test thing that even without the pics, the suggestions are imaginative and inspiring.