Customer Reviews

Perfect

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I love the lyrics to "Perfect." I love songs that i can acutally relate to. I can get into some pretty nasty fights with my dad and there are times where i think he's overly critical and doesn't love me. Like in the song, I try hard to make him happy but he always seems to disapprove. Anyways, great CD. I'd recommend it to anyone.

If you love Simple Plan then you need this CD! It has the album version of Perfect, also the Acoustic and Happy Together! The acoustic is my favorite though!

I have mixed feelings, here...first off, they are quite talented with the drums and guitars and all--it's just the originality that bothers me a little.
Many songs sound the same as the one before...okay, let's see here, pop in the CD, press play...Track #1 playing...we have a loud intro of guitars in a catchy beat...okay, now track #2...wait, almost the same as #1...track #3...hm, the same as track #2...? What's going on here? What about some different styles, not just the over-used guitar introduction?It doesn't happen on all the songs, but some.

But, half of this? My opinion, that's all. Sure, reviewing movies and toys and stuff is one thing...reviewing music? Much different. What I mean is, if you like one of the songs on here, if that type suits your taste in music, then you'll like all of them on the CD...because they're all very similar to each other. But, if you don't find the beat too interesting in one of the songs, you may not be thrilled to here more of them on this CD, either.


Music is opinion, so I am not right or wrong, here...if you're unsure if you're going to like this CD, listen to other guitar-type stuff...not exactly punk-rock, just guitars and drums in the background. But, if you like a band that has different types of songs, this is not the CD for you. You are not RIGHT if you prefer different songs, nor are you wrong. Simple Plan die-hard fans, I am just saying that it depends on what you prefer; for those of you who are really into rock, I recommend getting this...for those of you who don't have a favorite style, those of you that don't have a specific preference in music, try something else.

So, bottom line, then: Simple Plan does not stink on ice. I think it's okay. It is not just "for girls," as a reviewer stated earlier. After all, there is no such thing as music intended for a boy or girl. Music is music. You listen to it.

Perfect - 5 stars.

Happy Together - 3.5 stars.

Cover Art: B-
Songwriting: B+
Vocals: C-
Vocal Emotion: C+
Production: B-
Length: B+

4.25 stars.

Overall: B-