Most Helpful Customer Reviews
23 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not Definitive, but a good survey with reservations, March 28, 2004
This review is from: The Perfect Soldier: Special Operations, Commandos, and the Future of Us Warfare (Hardcover)
Dunnigan's book is certainly timely. Special Operations Forces (SOF) from all US services (USCG included), and allies have been making headlines in Afghanistan and Iraq for almost two years. The "Quiet Professionals", contrary to US Media propaganda, generally eschew ANY sort of public attention. For the reader with an interest, and little background, in Special Operations then, finding surveys/histories is problematic. After giving a history of special operations forces and their derivation, the author shows how some of the selection methods are applied to many first-world nation's volunteer forces; thus making them also "perfect soldiers" into the 21st Century. His best work is the short history of warfare, where "warrior cultures" are bested by military professionals (US military bureaucrats spouting about "warrior ethos" take note). His descriptions of operations in Vietnam, the Gulf I/II and Afghanistan are quite good as well. The "reservations" I refer to above have to do with some of his linkage and conclusions. While it's probably fair to link the fieldcraft of neolithic hunting parties with that of SOF (John Keegan's belief is that the arduous selection and training is designed to reinstill those skills that our ancestors grew up practicing.), it's going too far to consider them "commando/SOF" units in any sense. WW1 Stosstruppen were simply line-infantry given some retraining in tactics and new weapons, no special selection or skills in operating behind enemy lines was given or expected. Also, the author gets some details wrong, details that could've easily been corrected had the manuscript been reviewed by someone with SOF experience-but this is minor. Overall,some good information, but some stretching of history to fit his thesis, keeps me from recommending this book completely.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not bad, but a lot of filler., July 14, 2004
By A Customer
The book gives a decent overview of 'Special' or 'Elite' forces, and their role in modern day warfare and counter-terrorism; all very interesting and timely. However, I found the contents amateurly structured and VERY repetitive. At times I thought I had accidentally lost my place and was re-reading whole chapters. With each new heading, much of the same information was reiterated, without actually casting much new light on the topic. There are also a few redundant instances of numbers being thrown around for the sake of sounding 'scientific'. Also, if I'm paying good money for a hardcover book, I expect someone to have done more than a cursory MS Word spellcheck, like maybe proofread it before it goes to print... Other reviewers have also noted some factual errors, and I noticed some topics the writer dismissed as "murky" (especially if casting Special Forces in a negative light), and declined to comment further. I found this odd, since some of these topics are well-known to anyone with any interest in the post-Viet Nam military and a matter of public record. In short, this book would have benefitted from a good editor. If you're new to the topic, you could do worse, but I would recommend Tom Clancy's Special Forces for information, and Robin Moore's The Hunt for Bin Laden and Charles Beckwith's memoirs concerning Delta Force for both information AND a good read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
the perfect book on The Perfect Soldier, March 27, 2010
Was better than I expected...
My son is an officer in the Green Beret, (I bought the book for him), and he agrees. Very professionally done. Thanks
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
1.0 out of 5 stars
who are you ,John Rambo ?
The perfect soldier is special operations, Special Forces, Ranger, Seal,Recondo, Airborne,pathfinder, etc, but all in ONE !
Read more
Published on February 17, 2004 by Allen
|
