Customer Reviews

The Persistent Desire: A Femme-Butch Reader

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is the one of the first serious books published on butch/femme within a historical context in the lesbian community. It's a huge collection of historical materials of varying quality, with poems, photographs, essays, etc. This book is absolutely necessary for anyone seeking an understanding of butch/femme as a multi-layered, many-faceted experience.

Though I do not consider myself a lesbian, I have been attracted to a butch woman before and wanted to understand the feeling better. This book helped me understand the dynamic of attraction between butch and fem. It was precisely because she was masculine that I was attracted to her, but because she was a woman there was a sameness I could relate to and identify with. It was safer in a way than a man, because it wasn't quite so opposite. You still have the masculine/feminine polarity, but at the same time a comfortable sameness. It cleared up a lot of my questions and validated a lot of conclusions I had come to regarding the butch/fem dynamic.

After a recent submersion into what is passing for lesbian erotica these days -- and feeling as if I just wasn't perverse enough to be a "real" lesbian -- I revisited this classic.

After finishing it, and being once again intrigued, informed, aroused and delighted, I realized what it has that so many more recent anthologies lack: it has human contact based on emotion. The women in it are real and their feelings have true context. Instead of cold and sterile sex acts between people portrayed as obsessed with looks and their own image, this anthology overflows with the fluid nature of human sexuality and genuine human warmth.

Some may read for the historical perspective and others may miss the explicit-anything-for-shock-value gender games and power plays that are required it seems in all of the "best of" lesbian erotica out there now. I read it for the emotional impact because when it comes to erotica I need the emotional tie. Given how many lesbians (whether they admit it or not) read lesbian romance novels, I don't think I'm alone.

Joan Nestle's collection of essays, poems and personal narratives on the butch/femme dynamic is both fascinating to read and a valuable contribution to the scholarly literature on the history of lesbian relationships in this century. Highly recommended!

This is a great book about the historical and cultural background of the Butch-Femme conundrum.Highly recommended to anyone curious about gender identity and roles in the lesbian community.

This astonishing collection never ceases to surprise me.There really is nothing less politically correct than the Butch/Femme dynamic, and nothing, as she says, as persistent.
The piece by Leslie Feinberg is one of the most radiant pieces of writing, ever.

Classic book that is strangely out of print. I had no idea how Huge the volume of essays, stories, pictures and poems this book contains.

So many fantastic selections: from Lee Lynch's short story `Jacky and the Femme' followed by her poem `Stone Butch', to the concluding work from Joan Nestle `Our Gift of Touch'.

A partial list of the many contributors -

Dorothy Allison
Pat Califia
Barbara Smith
Arlene Stein
Jewelle L. Gomez
Christine Cassidy
Amber Hollibaugh
Cherrie Moraga
Donna Allegra
Rita Laporte
Carolyn Gammon
Ina Rimpau
Merril Mushroom
Audre Lorde
Elly Bulkin
Leslie Feinberg
Judy Lederer
Lisa E. Davis
Radclyffe Hall
William Cullen Bryant

Do not skip the excellent introduction by Joan Nestle with the touching postscript.

This is a keeper from beginning to end!