18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another in a great series of books, February 3, 2008
This review is from: St. Peter's (Wonders of the World) (Hardcover)
Mary Beard is a Professor of Classics at Cambridge University. She is the editor of The Wonders of the World which is "a small series of books that will focus on some of the world's most famous sites or monuments." Several books have already been published, including Beard's
The Parthenon (Wonders of the World), Beard's and Keith Hopkins'
The Colosseum (Wonders of the World) and Cathy Gere's
The Tomb of Agamemnon (Wonders of the World). Keith Miller's first book is a worthy addition to the series.
Like the other books in the series, this book reveals the architectural and cultural implications of its subject. It is aimed not at specialists but at the general inquisitive reader ("the intelligent ignorant," as Beard often refers to herself).
Keith Miller starts his book in the 1st century CE at the Hippodrome of Nero, one of two places where the Apostle Peter may have been crucified. It continues 250 years later with the conversion of Emperor Constantine in the fourth century, and his building of the first Christian basilica, commonly known as Old St Peter's. Miller enlivens the step-by-step creation of the present-day basilica with some of the functions the building has performed: for example, the imposing of woolen pallia on newly consecrated metropolitan archbishops and the coronations of Charlemagne and other emperors.
In 1506 Pope Julius II had the fourth-century building mostly demolished. Miller carefully describes the complicated development of the new basilica. He describes how Donato Bramante's plan was superseded by Peruzzi (after Bramante's death in 1514), then the contributions of Sangallo, Michelangelo and Raphael. He explains Bernini's colonnades, baldacchino and statuary throughout the building. He provides an in-depth look at the underground grottoes and the necropolis.
I thought Miller was particularly good on the question of precisely where St Peter is supposed to be buried and whether his tomb is actually here. He reviews Pius XII's 1950 confirmation, and the later discovery that there were bones of at least four different people, one a woman. Miller provides a balanced view of the debate, including some irrefutable evidence that someone of great significance was buried on the site. He carefully analyzes the necropolis, with drawings and a chronology.
Miller's background is in art history, and he is excellent at describing the works of art still in the basilica or have been moved from the building. He is good at delineating architectural perspectives, magnitude and dynamics.
I would have preferred footnotes and a better bibliography; Miller does acknowledge a few texts including James Lees-Milne's
St. Peter's: The Story of Saint Peter's Basilica in Rome published in 1967, as well as "various texts" by Gottfried Semper. Despite these nits, this book is readable and well researched.
Robert C. Ross 2008
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
good read, May 16, 2011
This review is from: St. Peter's (Wonders of the World) (Hardcover)
had to read this for an art history class, its an enjoyable read and helped me understand when i went to Rome the summer after
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
