26 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Absolute Must Have for "How Life Works!", July 27, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: The Phallus Palace: Female to Male Transsexuals (Paperback)
I am so impressed with the accessibility to the reader who may have no knowledge or may have a faulty perception of this special group of people which has never been presented to the public in this wholistic way...beginning with the excellent personal writing and fine-art museum quality photographs by the author, to the courageous "before" pictures and poignant, varied statements of many other FTM's. And this is what seems so ground-breaking: there also are writings by physicians, therapists, historians, politicians, family members and "straight" friends, all of whom congregate to comprise a phenomenal, diverse community of expertise and information not only for the initiated, but for the uninformed socially inquisitive as well.
All other books I have seen on similar subjects seem to be "vanity" publications, with a much narrower audience possibility, in which I don't feel welcome!
This one is so rich and complete, it could be 3 or 4 books: for the members of the extended FTM community, for the documentary fine-art photography connoisseur and collector, as a text for clinicians and physicians, and for the autobiographical writer. I recommended it to the University
librarian, my minister, a gallery owner and my Mother!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Best Source on the Topic!, July 6, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: The Phallus Palace: Female to Male Transsexuals (Paperback)
Finally, a book authored by an FTM who has enabled us to hear directly from a multitude of FTMs as well as their therapists, surgeons,researchers,and families. This is also the first book where the reader is able to witness actual sex reassignment surgeries in progress through a succession of graphically detailed photographs. Kotula's photographs and his own writing are beautifully crafted and punctuate the authenticity and authority of this book. While the book is laced with facts the information is presented in such a variety of ways one can't help but be engaged throughout the entire volume. This is a fascinating, moving account of female to male transsexual lives and will no doubt become a primary source on the topic. This is superb and a must read for anyone remotely interested in the subject.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Surgery-centered, January 12, 2006
This review is from: The Phallus Palace: Female to Male Transsexuals (Paperback)
Dean Kotula, in his book, Phallus Palace, argues that "what is common to all transsexuals and what distinguishes them from other sexual minorities is an aversion toward or awkwardness with one's genitals and a desire for sex-assignment surgery" (xx). More specifically, a differentiating aspect of Phallus Palace is its foregrounding of transition (surgical reassignment surgery from one sex to the other) as the central characteristic of transsexuals. Kotula supports his argument in part by: 1) speaking from his own experiences as a female to male transsexual; 2) gathering support from contributing authors, including Katherine Rachlin, Ph.D. and interviewed subject, Milton Diamond, Ph.D.; and 3) presenting the stories of several other FTMs. Kotula's purpose is to make clear the difference between transsexuals and transgender people in order to reaffirm that while they have been born in female bodies, transsexual men are indeed male, and to reaffirm their desires and need for surgery. In addition, Kotula's text is also concerned with educating and encouraging transsexual men, but also their allies to advocate for more, better scientific research, as well as improved surgical outcomes.
Katherine Rachlin's essay, "FTM 101: Dispelling Myths About the Invisible and the Impossible" nicely presents the misinformation in scientific literature that has skewed the knowledge base on FTMs. Specifically, Rachlin points to the way in which particular framings of research and particular research questions lead to findings that are shaped in specific, biased/limited ways (reminiscent of Kath Weston's introductory chapter in her 1998 book Long Slow Burn: Sexuality and Social Sciences).
Particularly interesting is Rachlin's assertion that "most [FTMs] do not become actively interested in changing their body and living in their chosen role until they learn that it is possible. Most report that the wish was always there, but without the belief that it was possible, they did not attempt to actualize their potential" (10). Phallus Palace is certainly a book that could not only introduce the possibility of (surgical) transition to FTMs, but also fortify the conviction of those considering undergoing surgery. In fact, Kotula's "Conversation with Milton Diamond" and its demystification of surgery and of some of the issues surrounding and processes leading up to surgery further acts as a resource and reaffirmation for those seeking surgery; as does "Part Four: The Surgeries" which provides interviews with doctors who perform sex-assignment surgeries, as well as detailed photos of such surgeries.
Personally, I'm skeptical of any assertion touting homogeneity of a group of people, as Kotula seems to do in regards to FTMs and their relationship to sex-assignment surgery. Also, I wish that other dimensions of difference (e.g., race, class, nationality) took an integral part within Phallus Palace's discussion of sex-assignment surgery. (I do have to give props, though, to Diane Ellaborn's essay, "Seeking Manhood: An Introductory Guide to Assessment of the Female-to-Male Adolescent" for its attention to age and the issue of transsexual youth.) Still, whether for trans scholars who may or may not agree with Kotula's narrow definition of FTMs, FTMs exploring their surgical options, or those with a general interest in LGBT Studies, Phallus Palace is a text worth glancing. (Besides, it isn't overly dense, and for some could be a relatively quick read.)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
