4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
get this book!, October 7, 2009
This review is from: Pharaoh's Boat (Hardcover)
A review I read in Kidlitosphere and agree wholeheartedly with follows:
Nonfiction Monday - Pharaoh's Boat
When I was 13 I began reading Agatha Christie novels. Around the time I read Death on the Nile, my uncle (and godfather) was living and working in the Middle East for Kodak. I still treasure the picture I have of him sitting on a camel in front of the pyramids at Giza. Together, these two things (the book and the picture) started my life-long love affair with all things Egyptian.
Today I regularly spend time in elementary classrooms in Virginia where young children (second graders) learn about the contributions of ancient Chinese and Egyptian civilizations and how they have influenced the present world in terms of architecture, inventions, the calendar, and written language. I'm thrilled to report I have a new book to share with them.
Pharaoh's Boat, written and illustrated by David Weitzman, tells the story of a miraculous find near the south face of the Great Pyramid at Giza and how it was ultimately reconstructed. The book begins with a Prologue that hints at a mystery beneath the sand. With a turn of the page readers are transported back to ancient Egypt to the time of Cheops death. While Cheops had prepared for his own death by building a pyramid to house everything he would need in the afterlife, there was still a task that remained to be done upon his death.
Djedefre, Cheops's son, succeeded his father as pharaoh, and his first concerns were the rituals that would assure his father's safe passage into the afterlife. He ordered the construction of two magnificent ships: one to guide Cheops safely through the dark, perilous underworld of night, and the other to carry him up across the sky to embark on his eternal journey with the sun.
What unfolds is a description of the importance of boats to the Egyptians and the utterly intriguing tale of how such boats were built. Here are just a few of the many things I learned.
Egyptians were expert boat builders.
Ships were powered by woven sails of cotton and leaf-shaped oars.
Ships had no rudder but rather large steering oars at the stern.
Pharaoh's boat was built using cedar, sycamore, and acacia trunks.
Master shipbuilders used no written plans.
Workers used tools like the axe, saw, chisel, adz, and sandstone.
Final assembly included sewing the ship together with rope woven from grass.
The science behind the shipbuilding was amazing. Here's one of the most interesting things I read.
The rope lashing did more than just hold the hull together. When sewn ships like this were launched, the wood soaked up water like a sponge and expanded. At the same time, the rope shrank as it got wet, pulling the planks together and closing any little spaces between them to make the ship watertight.
I gained a tremendous appreciation for the work of these ancient shipbuilders in reading Weitzman's description of the process. I was not, however, prepared for what came next.
While Cheops's funerary ships were being finished, workers carved two pits--each a hundred feet long, eight feet wide, and eleven feet deep--out of solid limestone bedrock at the base of his pyramid.
As soon as the boats were completed, they were taken apart and placed in the pits.
What?! To say I was flabbergasted would be an understatement. In just a few pages of description and illustration I came to appreciate the beauty and craftsmanship in these boats. Taking them apart seemed like sacrilege.
The story of the building of Pharoah's boats ends with a description of their placement in the pits and the steps taken to protect them from tomb robbers. Weitzmans' book however, does not here. Readers are taken back to 1954 and the discovery of a boundary wall in an unexpected location. The workers continued to dig and found rows of limestone blocks where there should have been bedrock. The Egyptologist in charge of the work believed the blocks to be covering boat pits. With a bit more excavation he was proven to be correct.
The text goes on to describe the work of Ahmed Youssef Moustafa, the "chief of the Restoration Department of the Egyptian Antiquities Service, and the man chose to direct the recovery, preservation, and reconstruction of the huge ancient ship--an almost impossible task that no one had ever undertaken before." This section of the book is distinguished from the rest by modern (realistic) 3-D illustrations, while the portion of the book describing the work of the ancients is rendered in the flat 2-D style seen in hieroglyphs and tomb paintings. To get a feel for the artwork you can view some sample pages from the book.
I found the story of Moustafa's research and work to unravel the secrets of ancient shipbuilders simply fascinating. While Moustafa and his workers tried to unlock the secrets held in the pieces of the boat, they assembled and disassembled it FIVE times before they were satisfied they had it right. When the boat was finally installed in a new museum in 1970 near Cheops's pyramid, it took them only three months to assemble. You can see the piece in all its glory at the end of the text where a stunning gatefold opens to reveal the completed boat. (For some actual photographs of the boat, visit Mysteries of the Nile: Pharaoh's Boat (Solar Barque).)
The Afterword provided by the author describes efforts to recover the second boat buried underneath the one Moustafa put together.
If I sound a bit starry-eyed about this book it's because I am. I find the fact that shipbuilding techniques have remained largely unchanged in more than 4000 years to be simply amazing. Weitzman reeled me in on the first page and never let me go. When I reached the end I wanted to know more. Kids will undoubtedly feel the same. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Book: Pharaoh's Boat
Author/Illustrator: David Weitzman
Publisher: Houghton Mifflin Books for Children
Publication Date: May, 2009
Pages: 32 pages
Grades: 3-8
ISBN: 978-0547053417
Source of Book: Personal copy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not a little kids' story, March 7, 2011
This review is from: Pharaoh's Boat (Hardcover)
Ok, normal homeschooling mom here... not avid shipbuilder or Egypt fan like the other reviewers here, or anything important.
I was excited to pick up this book because it was new enough not to have made it into all my homeschooling catalogs yet. I was planning an Ancient Egypt unit and was sure that it was going to be a hit. The book was enjoyable, but slightly disappointing. It is a great book for boat engineering, not a fun Egyptian story.
The Pros: the illustrations are probably the best part. My boys in particular loved looking at the boats with all their details. They counted the sailors on the ships, asked questions about the building, and enjoyed the Egyptian artistic style. Truly, the book goes into incredible detail about the shipbuilding process--almost like a David Macaulay book except in color--so it will delight any boat fan.
Cons: it is incredibly boring. While this book looks like a children's story, it is NOT. There's no story really. My preschooler was gone before the fifth page. Each page and illustration is basically the same--the boat, the boat, and the boat again. Then, the story of the shipbuilding scholar begins, and that confused my little kids a lot. They thought they were just reading about the past but then the restorer of the boat, an Arabic historian, is suddenly drawn into the story. My older kids seemed to understand this transition fine, but then the text was still above their heads. Or else they just weren't interested enough. They didn't have enough engineering knowledge or attention to enjoy it more than once through.
So in my opinion, this is not a book for kids under third grade, really, unless you have an unusual shipbuilding aficionado.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
