Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
112 of 113 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A great release, even if I have a few objections., November 10, 2004
So, Finally it's here, the 5th official live video release from Phil's 6th worldtour as a solo artist (previous releases count the Passadena 1982 video, the Dallas 1985 video, the Berlin 1990 video/2DVD, and the Paris 1997 video/DVD). As such, one cannot quite keep from comparing this release to these former releases, when one wants to make an evaluation of the DVD. This being said, I shall emphasize that if your relatively new into Phil's music, or simply haven't bought the older releases for one reason or another, this is an excellent show, featuring a wide range of his greatest and best loved hits, and giving a very fine overview of how Phil is on stage. Furthermore, you'll have a large amount of extra features thrown in as an added value.
- THE TRACK LISTING -
Perhaps the greatest pro of this release is, that it features the FULL concert. A full 24 tracks are we treated with, which can only be described as generous. The only other complete release so far was the 1990 Serious Hits In Berlin (re-released in 2xDVD last year), and it is always a great frustration to the fans, when one of their favorite songs are cut away in the editing.
Furthermore, the set-list of this tour is quite well-balanced, featuring practically all the greatest, old as well as new - In The Air Tonight, Susudio, One More Night, Dance Into The Light, Another Day In Paradise, Can't Hurry Love, Can't Stop Loving You, and I could go on and on. Of course, a few tracks that I'd love to have seen here are missing - not one track from the Both Sides album - according to Phil his best, and I agree - is included, the title track would have fitted in perfectly; his most recent hit-single from the Brother Bear soundtrack, Look Through My Eyes, is omitted, this soundtrack being represented instead by the ballad No Way Out - which is in fact not a bad treat. I should have loved to have had the piano version of Do You Remember?, as performed on the '97 tour, but of course the line has to be drawn somewhere.
Instead, we are treated with several very pleasant surprises: An absolutely amazing gospel-version of True Colours, far superior to his '98 remake; a lovely version of Come With Me from his recent Testify album, again drawing on his amazing 5-piece of back-up vocalists; an impressive rendition of the gospel-like No Way Out, again using the full power of this vocal potential; and nearly last but not least, another track from the Testify album, It's Not Too Late, another of my favorites, and again presented in a wonderfull new version.
- THE PERFORMANCE -
The performance is, overall, great without being superb. Phil is in good vocal shape, but not as amazing as on the Live And Loose In Paris release from '97. The musicians play amazing, and overall this will probably rank second - after the 97 Paris concert, that was probably Phil's best ever - amongst his live releases. The arrangement is excellent, the upbeat songs are perfomed spotlessly, and the real power of the shw comes with the amazing vocal arrangement on several of the ballads, as mentioned above - True Colours, Come With Me, No Way Out and It's Not Too Late.
Generally, the on-scene performance is pretty dynamic and goes well along with the music - still, the scene doesn't quite give the same space for playing and entertainment as did the circular in-the-round stage used on the '97 tour. The lighting is ok, but I was not impressed - again, comparing with the amazing work on the '97 show, this was a minor let-down.
- SOUND AND FILMING -
The sound is virtually perfect, at least I can't find anything to complain on here. The sound of the music is much more pleasant than on the Berlin '90 show, which was perhaps the greatest weeknes of that show in my oppinion. The filming is excellent as well, the picture quality is great, and I don't miss the multi-camera angles option, which is even included on a few tracks.
- EXTRA FEATURES -
All the videos for the featured songs are included - a generous treat for the fans. Ok, most of the videos are quite mediocre, but still, Phil could've released a seperate video-DVD and ripped the fans of another 20 £. Of course, this is no guarantee that such a release will not come, as the videos of songs not played in the concert are not included. Of course, that should've been nice ... we're talking another 5 or 10 videos here I think.
Some old live-footage is included here, but frankly, this is nothing to go for. The Live Aid Against All Odds performance and the Secret Policeman's Ball In The Air Tonight performance are both in pretty lousy quality, mainly of interest for the serious fans. The 'wild card' features a 20-minutes performance with the Big Band, which never was my taste, so I can hardly appreciate this piece. Instead, there are loads of rare footage not included, that would've been obvious to include: The fantastic Policeman's Ball performance of The Roof Is Leaking, the very rare 1997 performance of The Same Moon with Laura Pausini (not sure whether this was a radio or TV show, this might not have been filmed), the 2002 TV performance of Wake Up Call, and I could go on. Perhaps one day, on future releases, these gems will se the light of day.
Still, these features, and also several documentaries, TV-specials and a gallery, are much more that what've been included on earlier releases, and with a full 224 minutes of extra material (yes, that's nealy 4 hours!), and a 133 minutes live-show, this can only be described as an extremely generous release, and defenitely woth bying, die-hard fan or newcommer.
Overall Rating: 9/10
|
|
|
31 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
I don't care if Phil's not cool - I love this stuff, February 15, 2005
I've been a diehard Genesis fan from the old days. Love Peter for Peter, but Phil pulled the band together as a unit far more effectively until "Genesis", as far as I'm concerned. The pop approach suited him much better than the pensive, romantic style of Mike and Tony, who sounded like a string quartet playing Depeche Mode once the latter day stuff came out. I love both their voices.
While my tastes do not lean toward peppy pop, when I listen to this music with some years in between this and my Lamb/Wind and Wuthering heyday, I realize that this is just darned fine pop. he works his butt off, the music is full of hooks and high-points, some silliness, but it is Pop Art, and it makes me happy. Would I like a reunion of prog-era Genesis? Absolutely. but for what it is, this is a great show, full of love and effort and world-class playing. And, though it may not matter to some, there is an all-too-brief nuclear drum solo, the only one (save for an obscure Brand X CD, Live at the Roxy) on legitimate record by Phil, which contrasts with the more conventional fireworks of the wonderful Chester Thompson, followed by an astounding drum duo and trio with master percussionist Luis Conte. Phil's solo and the percussion ensemble are pieces of music, not gymnastics, complete with fancy tricks and crowd pleasers, but as close to a drum "song" as you're likely to find in the mainstream.
So liking Phil ain't cool. Tough. This is one of the hardest working, crowd-pleasing, laugh-at-yourself and have a good time, heart on his sleeve performers out there. And the DVD offers enough goodies to make for a great farewell gift for his fans.
So it's not "deep" - but it is fun pop artistry. Just enjoy it. There's plenty of serious progressive music out there to go around. What's so bad about a simple song with a groove, played at a world class level? Nuff said.
|
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Collins DVD is FABULOUS, August 12, 2005
It is sometimes hard for me to be objective when it comes to my favourite singer Phil Collins, but I must say that the quality of this DVD is FABULOUS! The audio is great and the video is clear and colourful. The selection options are impressive and exciting, which include music videos that I have never seen! I love seeing Phil in his last concert tour (one of which I could not see in person), so this is a very emotional concert to watch. I love how he speaks to the audience in French, which shows he makes an effort to make the audience before him feel right at home! OK, enough about Phil, tears are beginning to fall! Thank you, Amazon, for bringing Phil into my home. :)
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
DVD ~ Genesis
DVD ~ Ronnie Caryl
DVD ~ Genesis
DVD ~ Tony Banks
DVD ~ Huey Lewis & the News
