Customer Reviews

Phil Ochs Live At Newport

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

In the spring of '76, Phil Ochs committed suicide at 35. He was a victim of inner demons such as alcoholism and depression, the decline of his songwriting gifts, changing tastes by former fans, failed attempts to become a different kind of singer, and sundry personal disappointments. Ten years earlier, I had attended a concert by him in central New Jersey in which he powerfully commanded the stage for two hours performing his best songs written in the first half of the '60's, on the topics of civil rights, military drafts, US foreign policy, poverty and personal idealism. A few of those songs are present on this disc, done live at the Newport Folk Festival. However, this one is weakened by the inclusion of three really long songs that just do not hold the attention of listeners: "Cross My Heart" and "Half a Century High" and "The Party" occupy 20 minutes, nearly half the program, but can't match the intensity and cleverness of his earlier songs "Medgar Evers" and "Birmingham Jam" and "Power and the Glory" and "Draft Dodger Rag" and "I Ain't Marching Anymore." Since Phil was a topical writer during one of the worst decades in American cultural and political history, some of his songs are outdated now, and more are just not understood by those too young to have remembered the events leading to their creation. So this CD is half great, half not. For a better sample of Phil at his best, try to find the Elektra CD "There But For Fortune." It has 18 tracks, only two of which are a bit under the quality of the other 16. He was never one of the world's best folk vocalists, registering a cut above Peter La Farge, and maybe Dylan, but way below Cisco Houston, Ed McCurdy or Logan English. Find the other CD, and listen to "Here's to the State of Mississippi" which is nearly six minutes of condemnation for the most violent anti-civil rights region of the country, but all too true. That one, along with the best on the disc from Newport, displays Phil's gifts well. Other great Ochs contributions include setting the Alfred Noyes' poem "The Highwayman" to music, along with Edgar Allen Poe's "The Bells." I like his personal anthem, "When I'm Gone", "Crucifixion" and the more famous "Changes." For the five years or so when Phil Ochs was one of the leaders of the urban folk protest "movement" he was a major influence on many fans. He faded fast, and fell far, but briefly, he was indeed a star.

This compilation of Phil's performances at Newport Folk Festival provide a timely reminder that this festival that germinated the counter culture in all its forms wasn't just about Dylan as TV documentaries have people believe. It takes listeners through his short punchy topical songs and segues to his more lyrical 'Pleasures of The Harbour' era songs in stripped down acoustic format though the later songs are longer and more leisurely- I love all points of the spectrum. A standout track to me is the way Phil's pointed verbal introduction is followed by the intensity of 'Links on the Chain'and the rapturous reception to a timely reminder that union leaders have the moral responsibility that Phil's life exemplified. This is followed by the charming way he seeks out the unplanned song for his encore.

Phil is one of those artists that was commented on as writing songs that current events made obsolete verty quickly. The timelessness of Phil's art is shown by how a song (not in this collection) called "White Boots Marching in a Yellow Land' written in 1967 remains contemporary by substituting "Arab" for "Yellow." Phil's humanity, his artistry and sheer committment is a shining example to us today and this collection aptly showcases all sides of Phil

This is the first recording I have by this artist and I think it is a great recording over all. He sings songs that I really enjoy like "Draft Dodger Rag," and "Pleasures of the harbor." The sound quality is so clear that it makes me feel as though I am actually attending the concert. The only thing that I would have against this recording is that there are too many songs that talk about murder and tragedy like "talking Birmingham Jam." I would recommend this recording to anyone who is not familiar with his music or those who enjoy him and want to try out other recordings.