1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Philosophy on the move, August 7, 2011
This was the first of Le Doeuff's books (Recherches sur L'imaginaire philosophique, 1980) to be published in English (The Philosophical Imaginary 1989). Those with a feminist interest may have come upon only her more recent work, L'etude et le rouet (translated as 'Hipparchia's Choice', 1991) and Le sexe du savoir (translated as The sex of knowing, 2003).
What Le Doeuff did in 1980 still comes across as very fresh and to the point of controversies about the possibilities of philosophy. She goes right to the heart of our doubts about and derogation of the status of images -- and more importantly, operative systems of imagery - in philosophy. The title (The Philosophical Imaginary) itself is a milestone if you are looking for an alternative to philosophy as a mill-stone. You find here some of the makings of a precise and rigorous philosophy that works in counterpoint to analytical philosophy's ideals of the 'literal', 'explicit', 'no-stone-unturned' and 'no-word'unsaid'. (It is set at an even greater distance from the hermetic 'profundity' of a Heidegger or Levinas.)
In contrast with the inbred culture of analytical philosophy you might read something 'deconstructive' about the way the text works by close reading of one kind of text against another. She could hardly be further from Derrida, however, when it comes to the way she works. The style is terse, quick and economical. You can't stop a broad smile at the title of the preface piece - 'The Shameful Face of Philosophy'. 'The nerve of the woman!' blurts the traditionalist exposed in its sexism. But surely traditionalism made to laugh at itself while being coloured in with new shades and moods is traditionalism being transcended in the act.
Le Doeuff's work is 'beyond (the) good and evil' of moralising, and yet nowhere near nihilism or cynicism either. She is intelligent - canny with a sharp jibe. What she shows is that with spirit, fine thought and a free vocabulary you can go right into the den of the past tradition, paint sketches, bring back trophies and adventurers' tales and write in a way that is free of the past while being informed about and by it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No