4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Gripping even with Star Trekkian mis-physics, July 20, 2004
This review is from: Phobos (Hardcover)
A space-opera whodunit suspense, complete with "no one is leaving this room until the guilty person here is exposed" scene. Good characters and story line. However, I stopped mentally listing the physics faux pas halfway through. And not nitpicky ones - blatant.
It's not the second law of thermodynamics that is responsible for recoil (it's Newton 2nd law); the zero-G antics are fun but often wrong (a chair with 20 kg mass is still MASS even on Phobos and if it hits you going 300kph or whatever it'll kill you); the shuttle impact on the surface as described must have taken place at 20mph or less or the hero would not have survived being slammed agains the suddenly-stopped cockpit wall; rockets don't fly in arcs (and don't do U-turns!) except near gravity wells, and then you have to match speeds to the orbital arc you want; leaping from a spinning surface in zero-G means the spin you had is imparted to your flight via conservation of rotational inertia. You couldn't jump straight down the axis of a longitudinally spinning ship without eventually hitting a wall due to radial velocity imparted from the floor UNLESS you jumped right on axis...
(Conservation of linear and rotational momentum are violated often... )
If you're falling in low G, touching a wall would impart outward force and send you away from the wall... jumping up to the ceiling in lowG doesn't mean you hit with a thump and stay there... unless you grab a handhold you'll bounce off with almost as much velocity as you hit...
You might say, who cares? We ignore Star Trek creating new "bands" of radiation at every turn... but all these things add up since so much of the storyline depends on these antics...if you're a hard sciences purist anyway.
But read it! It's gripping and fun, even with information withheld by the protagonist. The ending was suspenseful and not totally predictable. Had me going there.
I've always been picky that way... as an engineering physics major. I love Star Trek, Star Wars, everything, but you don't want to watch it with me because I nitpick every physics mistake!
A good read; I'll read the sequel. Overall, a high recommendation. As Mike Resnick said, "a very impressive first novel."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Strange world, strange case, January 12, 2004
This review is from: Phobos (Hardcover)
The biggest mystery in Phobos may not be the case Peace Corps lieutenant Mike Brogue is sent to solve, but the universe in which Phobos is set. Some of the backstory is filled in, but many questions remain unanswered (at least for now--the ending suggests a sequel).
The mystery itself is an engaging one, reminiscent of another debut novel, Matthew Delaney's Jinn. While that novel used writing gimmicks to create shocks (such as withholding necessary information), this one doesn't. If anything, the book reminded me of an episode of "Scooby-Doo" (and this is a compliment): before long it is clear that there *is* a rational explanation for everything that's happened; it's up to Brogue et al. to find it.
The book moves along at a fair clip, with enough suspense and intrigue to carry you through to the last pages. If Drago writes a sequel, I'll definitely read it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Don't miss this one, April 23, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Phobos (Hardcover)
I can't believe this book is not selling better. Somehow word of mouth is just not getting out. This is a great story. It's fun, exciting, and everything you want in an SF novel. The mystery part keeps it moving, the characters are fully developed and interesting. Do yourself a favor and buy this book. It's a great read and I can't wait for whatever Ty Drago comes up with next.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No