6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
one of oliphant's best, April 9, 2009
Wonderful novel. It helps if you have read the Carlingford Chronicles before reading this since it refers to characters from her previous novels. My favorite was The Perpetual Curate, next, MIss Marjoribanks, then this one. There are 6(?) or 7 in all of the chronicles.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Cold Comfort Farm Meets Middlemarch?, August 14, 2010
This is one of my very favorite 19c novels, and it's Oliphant's very best, in my opinion--even better than _Miss Marjoribanks_. Like Miss M, it follows the adventures of a preternaturally self-reliant, capable, and ambitious heroine who navigates the complexities of her social milieu to achieve her goals. She's a more engaging protagonist than Lucilla Marjoribanks, however, because she is smarter: more quick-witted and perceptive about the motives of others.
What's especially interesting about this novel, though, is how ambivalent the author is about her own heroine, Phoebe Beecham, and how Phoebe's flaws actually make her a more interesting protagonist. Her shrewdness, self-importance, ambition, and frankness about the difficulties of her own class status (the educated daughter of upwardly mobile parents, she spends the novel caring for her grandmother, a shopkeeper's wife) make her a complicated heroine for whom the narrator seems to feel fluctuating levels of affection and disapproval. But these qualities also mean that Phoebe speaks on the subjects of class, gender, and female ambition with a refreshing clarity. She ends up in roughly the position of _Middlemarch's_ Dorothea Brooke, having a career of national importance through her husband, but she gets there with much less trauma. Clear-eyed and pragmatic, she works within the confines of her world, using her brains and her talent for persuasiveness to make her way.
In this way, Phoebe has a certain kinship to Flora Poste of _Cold Comfort Farm_--both characters are confident, well-educated, relentlessly modern (for their respective time periods) and have a fantastic ability to manage situations, people, and--not least--their wardrobes. Both provide a fantasy of feminine prowess and control over the domestic and personal sphere, and _Phoebe Junior_ particularly argues that this same capacity for management translates seamlessly to the national stage.
The ending **SPOILER ALERT** has presented readers with difficulties since the novel was first published, but in a way, Phoebe's husband--whom the narrator describes as a "lout"--is a surprisingly progressive guy. He's entirely willing to let his wife mastermind and manage his career and, one imagines, their personal lives; he's endearingly if somewhat lumpishly loyal; and he has the good taste to be drawn to Phoebe because she has "brains." The narrator makes is painfully clear that he is not the romantic choice, but one develops a certain sneaking fondness for this inarticulate underdog, with his unusually liberated outlook. </END SPOILER>
All in all, it's a delightful novel that lets us have our cake and eat it to: it illustrates the class and gender constraints to which most people were subject in Victorian England, but then it gives us a heroine who is able to transcend both.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No