Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fuel Your Creativity, March 28, 2002
This review is from: Photoshop 6 ImageReady 3 Hands-On Training (With CD-ROM) (Paperback)
Because Lynda Weinman comes from the perspective of a real designer, I find that her books always provide fuel for the reader's creativity. While these books REALLY do teach, they also encourage the reader to experiment. I am a fan of Adobe's Classroom In A Book series, but I did not find the Photoshop or Illustrator books to be geared toward the beginner. Exercises were often very layered and complex with pages of steps. The book didn't not always adequately explain the purpose of all the steps. The risk of presenting such long exercises is that if the learner makes a mistake and doesn't achieve the intended results of the book, the source of the mistake isn't always easy to trace. In contrast, Kabili and Weinman provide short, simple exercises, adhering to the proven fact that learners absorb information in bit-sized chunks. The exercises in this book are paced so that the reader can take breaks and try what was just learned. Don't mistake this brevity for lack of information, however. The authors are very thorough and wise about choosing what's practical. Best of all, there's lots of good advice. Photoshop is presented as a tool for web design, and the authors remind us about the Web's capabilities and limitations. We also get honest advice about small Photoshop annoyances (thankfully there are few!) and how to design around them. I politely disagree that this book is "not focused." On the contrary, its purpose is obvious from Chapter One: how to set up Photoshop to work as a web design tool. We are taught how to deal with color and color settings and how to optimize graphics early on so that we can concentrate on more fun tasks. I believe Lynda Weinman is a born teacher, as are all the co-authors with whom she associates. This is my third HOT book, and I use them when I need to absorb an application's features and capability quickly. I encourage you to try this book and see if it doesn't spark your creative fires.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Really good hands-on-training, November 7, 2001
This review is from: Photoshop 6 ImageReady 3 Hands-On Training (With CD-ROM) (Paperback)
I've used many training/exercise books for learning programs (it's my favorite way of learning computer programs). This book is well-organized, thorough, and leaves no gaps (that is, if I encounter something unexpected, the author--Jan Kabili--has generally anticipated it and has a note on why that occurred). Also, it goes deeply into Photoshop/Imageready for the web like no other books I've seen. Unlike many other very good Photoshop books (that hardly touch on Imageready), this one is the one to have if you want to know everything about Photoshop/Imageready and the web.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Okay, now we're getting somewhere!, February 13, 2002
This review is from: Photoshop 6 ImageReady 3 Hands-On Training (With CD-ROM) (Paperback)
Okay, I'll be the first to adnit I'm not the fastest chip on the board, but with Jan and Lynda's good efforts, I'm finally making some progress! In fact, I've progressed farther with this book than I have with eight others I've purchased in the past year. Unlike most other manuals which just throw the information at you in big, indigestible chunks, the information provided here is easy to comprehend. Largely because you're encouraged to play around with the exercises and try lots of different things. One cannot help but learn. Just got through doing some layer masks...piece of cake! I now understand transforming type, shape layers, layer styles, backgrounds, not to mention slicing and rollovers. The physical layout of the book is clean, tight, and has lots of color. The language is precise and to the point. One small criticism: please, please, please, keep the silly cartoons and pictures out of the text. The grinning monkeys and the cute kids, (at least I hope she's cute, how can I tell?) making stupid faces. I have trouble enough trying to make sense of everything, and I don't need the silly distractions. All the writers do this, by the way. Nonetheless, this is an excellent book, and I highly recommend it to all my wannbe, newby, frustrated Photoshop guru friends. Now, if only Lynda would do a GoLive 6 book (hint, hint)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|