Customer Reviews

Photoshop 6 for Windows & Macintosh

5 star:		(5)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(4)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I agree with the "Gypsybells" review below -- this is a good book. Photoshop is an EXTREMELY difficult and complex program to learn, and it's kind of impossible to learn it without exploring. For any one way you want something to look (say, add an outer glow to items on a layer), there are umpteen million ways you could go about doing it. That's what makes Photoshop such a diverse and awesomely powerful application.

Using Photoshop successfully requires knowing in the first place how you want your project to look -- i.e. you have to start out with some sense of visual design. This book is NOT a text about graphic design or aesthetics. I think that's what's frustrating to so many reviewers below who don't have a graphic design background. The book won't give you ideas about how to design something. It WILL show you how to do some basic neat stuff with Photoshop's functions. You'll come out of the book with a sense of accomplishment, because you'll know how to do a few neat things, and the BASIC tools to which this book introduces you will encourage you to explore further. Which is really what you have to do. There's just no other way. It is the nature of graphic design programs -- you have to try things out, because each project will be entirely different.

I enjoy the Visual Quickstart series because it includes a lot of screen shots of how things should look, and they are usually straightforward in their wording. They don't have a lot of "side" material (commentary, "fluff"), so you can barrel right through the book and get down to business.

This should not be your only Photoshop book, because it doesn't go into deep detail about Photoshop's functions. But it's definitely a valuable resource if you're just starting Photoshop and want to know what the heck this program is all about.

This book is not for the newbie. It does not teach you how to make effects that wow the masses. 17 year old boys will not be able to make flames scorch rubber duckies just by picking up this book, and you will not be able to sleep walk through all of the functions that Photoshop 6 can give you merely by purchasing this volume.

However, if you own Photoshop 6, and have some familiarity with the program, and some idea of what you want your image to look like--this is the book for you. It tells you how to make Photoshop do what you want. Its functions are clearly explained, and you don't have to read the whole thing to be able to execute one function flawlessly.

I was relieved that this book does not "effect a breezy style" like the Dummies books and most of the computer books out there. You will see one or two "kute as a button" self-references by the authors (on the order of "we tried this function and were awed by it"). Nowadays, that is about as restrained as you get.You will never know about the authors' adorable moppets, how they truely feel about lattes, or that their cell phones eat batteries. You don't care. You want to learn how to use Photoshop, not babysit by proxy some self absorbed yup-geek. Hooray for being relieved of the authors' neurosis so you can get down to business. That is what you are paying for, and that is what you will get.

Also, you are relieved of the all but useless "Bonus CD" that comes with most computer books, which greatly reduces its price and annoyance quotient. I am sure you have long ceased to be impressed with the "Bonus CD" chocked full of: demo programs that blow up after 10 days, shareware that ends up costing you ... if you want it (which you weren't counting on when you bought the book), and crippled mini programs that do one thing well once and just end up taking space on your hard drive in perpetutity.

If you are a poor lost soul who flaps and flaps and just can't figure out a big image manipulation program, this is not the book for you--and Photoshop 6 is not the program for you. If you are a curious and dedicated user of Photoshop, and you want to get the best out of this huge and grand software, do buy this book and it will be of great help to you. If you lost your manual, this is the best substitute.

I'm surprised at the feedback I've seen on this book because I truly enjoy the Quickstart series of computer books. They're informative, detailed and the content is easy to find. In fact, their books were used as my textbooks in college and I liked them so much I continue to use them. But I won't say that these books aren't for a specific type of person. I will explain.

If you've ever picked up a Whatever-for-Dummies book, or the Idiot's-Guide-for-something or any kind of Textbooks-for-Morons you either like them or hate them. Why? Because they all seem to be written at the same level meaning they are real beginner books. If you are the type of person who doesn't know how to work a mouse, then I suggest that you stick to Dummy books. The Quickbooks are more geared towards people who like to play with programs to figure them out. They do give brief explanations of the basics, and I mean: "This is a pallet, this is a brush" but they only do it briefly. They are non-patronizing to the people out there who have a knack for figuring programs out.

Quickbooks are also informative. If you need information on a specific topic, such as adjusting contrast, you'll usually find it within seconds through the glossary. Not only that, but there are a number of visual aids to reference and shows step-by-step what you're going to do or use. Sometimes, they even include URLs to pages on the web (but that may be aimed towards different topics other than PhotoShop.)

The details are also worth their while to read. They give plenty of additional tips to use that you might not think of. It will usually be in a side box with a "did you know" kind of title. These have helped in my work plenty of times and given me ideas.

Plus, these books are for Mac or PC which is a plus for me considering sometimes I have to work on one or the other platform and don't always know the keystrokes or commands which can be quite different from each other.

Again, these are reference books. They are not tutorial books for the ultimate beginner. I continue to use these books with my work and enjoy them thoroughly. I recommend these books for people who like to play with programs and need something to look back on and research further.

As a technical writer who is new to Photoshop but generally experienced with software documentation, I was very disappointed in this book. As other reviewers have pointed out, this is more of a reference guide than a "QuickStart Guide" (which implies that it is for beginners). There are almost no explanations of how the various features and controls work together, nor why you would want to use one over another. If I was an experienced user looking for information on a specific item, I could hardly do better. As a new user looking for an introduction, I could hardly do worse!

As an eBook developer, I needed to get up to date with PhotoShop really quick. I found this book quite helpful.

The book does an excellent job introducing and explaining the many facets of PhotoShop. That being said, I think the book does an inadequate job explaining the different image/file formats. Also, by jumping right into things, a lot of a topic's essential intoductory information is left out.

I had a problem with rendering PNG images for a certain eBook format. Adobe's help file in PhotoShop 6.0, for saving PNG files has incorrect information. (It was applicable for 5.5) After numerous calls to Adobe support, I was left with the suggestion, "Go get 5.5." The book introduced me to ImageReady3 and subsequently I learned the difference between PNG-8 and PNG-24 files. The solution was found.

Not every basic thing is covered. For example, a bitmap image can not be saved as a JPEG. It must be converted to a different mode (like grayscale) first.

All in all, an excellent book with tons of useful information. Go buy it.

I just got this book and have been trying to read for the last few days. It's dry as toast, and goes into very little detail on how things are done. It will start a new subject and not even gin an explanation as to what it is. Magic wand;, just tell you how to use it, not what it's used for, no examples of what an image looks like before you use it, with another one after so one can see the difference. This is the first review I wrote, but I just had to get the word out. If you're a beginner you need something else, so my quest goes on.

So far this is the Photoshop book I'd tell you to buy last after my buying 5 different ones. It is the one in use in my college level course and I think they should use just about anything else. Its biggest problem is that it is just too complicated for a beginner to use. It throws an enormous amount of material before you.(That is the effect it has upon you as a student--data being dumped on you en masse) Hours later into reading it, you are no better off than when you started. It is also in black and white and every single page is jam packed with material. This off-putting visual style/format is no aid to learning either. Now that I'm steadily improving in Photoshop, I hope I am able to occasionally open this book and learn something I haven't gleaned elsewhere so as to get my [money] out of it. I have yet to be able to do this though. I can't really recommend buying this book and I think colleges should stop requiring it as the text.

I tried to use this book as a teaching aid, but it failed on two fronts. First, there are more than a dozen errors in the first 12 chapters, some editorial, some typographic, but all very problematic. Additionally, the examples given do not come as files for download off the net, or on an enclosed CD making it impossible to duplicate in a teaching setting. This also would have pointed out many of the editing errors... since the procedures given are fairly poor.

Previous books by this author were quite good, but I would advise passing on this book for a later edition.

I have been studying web design for the past year, and have utilized various books and resources during my training. I have found all of the visual quickstart guides to be far superior to any other means for gaining a thorough understanding of programs capabilities. Readers will benefit from an incredibly rapid pace of understanding the utilization of their software. In addition, these manuals are priced as an incredible value in contrast to other teaching aids.

Very good resource for learning the ins-&-outs of Photoshop. Nothing in the book was a "serious waste of time", which I find in a lot of books. You'll pick-up a great deal, but still there's even more to learn. Displacement maps & all those other tidbits are left out, but thats why Colin Smith, Kelby, Monroe, & other gurus, come out with the books they do.

As for those other reviewers who says its not for beginners, thats nonsense. If you not sitting in front of Photoshop practicing then perhaps the newly aqquainted will get lost.

One last note, Photoshop 7 is out now, I've toyed with it and used it, and this book for 6 is still just as good. In 7, theres a filebrowser, a cool new brush engine, and some [crummy]new tools in the toolbox that you'll never use.

:)