13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A little too condescending, July 4, 2010
This review is from: The Physician's Guide to Investing: A Practical Approach to Building Wealth (Paperback)
I was very interested in this book as I saw some good reviews on it, am very interested in finances, and am also about to graduate medical school: So I had a ton of questions about what the financial future is going to look like for me.
I was actually really dissapointed in this book.
Firstly: The book hardly feels tailored to physicians. He makes some interesting points about not alerting salesmen to the fact you're a Doctor so they don't take advantage of you... but other than that: the real angle is that he uses a 250,000 salary as an assumption of what you make. I find this frustrating since I matched into Peds and I'm hardly going to make 250,000.
Secondly: The book is just rife with errors. It's the second edition: I would think they would have taken some of these problems out. (Duplicate words, truncated words, letters and punctuation missing etc.)
Thirdly: I felt like I was being talked down to the whole time. It's one thing to discuss everything in simple terms because you don't know the educational level of your readers... but to talk down to me is just insulting. This book is supposed to be for physicians... don't tell me "If you spend your tax refund splurging for something of luxury you might as well just put this book down now as you clearly aren't going to listen to anything else I have to say." I'm sorry... I used last years refund for a vacation after my extremely stressful 3rd year... are you punishing me? Do I not deserve this? what is splurging and what is enjoying life? This is never defined.
Fourthly: The book doesn't ever talk in great detail about anything... it merely skims the surface of a bunch of issues without ever really saying anything. The issues are usually then explained further with various metaphores and analogies of credit cards being like sirens making you crash on rocks or jedi's and the such... I felt like I was attending a church sermon and the only way the complex theory of good and evil could be explained was through little metaphores that really aren't applicable.
I think I was hoping for more substantial advice... something more clearly tailored to the common physician leaving medical school with 200,000 in loans and going into a specialty that really won't earn that much... but was hoping to find answers in how to stretch these sums of money for the better good of his family and the community... not merely "don't spend--put it all away... then when you retire don't spend much still... then die and donate it all" Ultimately that's what I got, and that doesn't answer anything.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
insightful, well researched, encouraging investment book: a must read, March 31, 2007
I am a physician who also enjoys teaching personal finances. This book should be a must read in every medical school curriculum. It is practical, full of insights, and easy to read in a weekend. I loved it so much, I bought a hardback copy as well so that I could loan the paperback to my colleagues. Although some of the advice is tailored to physicians, the book has valuable information for non-physicians as well. A great resource that is motivational as well as informative.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not realistic, January 8, 2008
The author is out of date or living in a different world. He assumes that physicians make at least $250,000 per year and that a 4000 square foot house with a little land can be had for $350,000. He also assumes a very high (unrealistic) rate of return for his investments. However, the book does offer some practical advice.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No