1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Struggle between Love and Seduction, July 28, 2011
This review is from: La Pianiste / The Piano Teacher (Original French Version with English Subtitles) (DVD)
LA PIANISTE (THE PIANO TEACHER) goes places most film makers dare not tread - the dark aspects of frustrated sexuality where desire and affection cannot meet. In brief, this is the story of the inner world of an exceptional pianist and piano teacher who lives with her mother in a 'marriage arrangement' that appears to satisfy both with its accompanying fights, jealousies, cheatings, and clingings. This cold pianist (incomparably portrayed by the fine Isabelle Huppert) is absorbed by Schubert and Schumann and shares many of those composers' tendencies towards madness and melancholy. Her private acting out of her sexual life includes forays into pornography video booths, drive-in movies for voyeurism, and other sadomasochistic practices that leave her frustrated in her drive to be humiliated and beaten. Into this sad woman's life enters a sensuously handsome student (again, played with complete credibility and finesse by Benoit Magimel) and much of the film is a hard driving match between lust/desire and need/repulsion, the true approach/avoidance conflict.
The pace of the film is so correct for a story about the extended periods of ennui between moments of exhilaration that mirror the life inside a music academy. We are treated to some wonderful Schubert, Schumann, Schonberg, and Bach that serves as the 'dialogue' during extended scenes where the piano teacher listens with her eyes and ears and distorted mind, reacting to the music in equal parts with the performing students. Yes, this is a disturbing film, but it is not a grotesque film. Director Michael Haneke manages to place this surreal sexual tragedy for us to understand just how wide the bell curve of human sexuality stretches. An astonishingly fine film - if you are open to explore the dark interstices of the human mind without prejudice. An added feature of an interview on the DVD with Isabelle Huppert about the character she portrays is exceptionally apropos and well filmed. Grady Harp, July 11
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
5 stars for leading actors, October 7, 2005
This review is from: La Pianiste / The Piano Teacher (Original French Version with English Subtitles) (DVD)
The thema of the movie is that how far the man who is in love with a woman can be involved in her world, and also is that how far actors can be involved in their role.
I admire two leading actors, Isabell Huppert and Benoit Magimel, for thier courage to act these characters. They each got the best actoress and actor in Cannes 2002, they deserve it and should be given.
Erika, a main character and Huppert acted, had been a lack of sexial relationship with men then in a way she lost control of her desire outside school and home. However the movie reprensents it so directly then I can not get involved with. That is something I need to understand but I don't want to see.
Benoir Magimel, I became a fan of his by the movie, he is beautiful and attractive in the movie and that charm is even strange in his character. It is so strange a young attractive man fell in love with a woman like Erika and it takes so long time to realize and leave her.
The story tells us that it is fantasy love makes people strong and beautiful. Many of French movies represent this idea any way.
I don't recommend you to watch this movie, however if you want to challenge how far you can be involved as an audience with realistic, do it, maybe that worth it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No