From School Library Journal
Grade 2-5-Inspired by watching The Picture of Dorian Gray on TV, Morty and Ray paint a magical picture of their own. Then the boys eagerly misbehave to see if their painting changes. Sure enough, as they clog toilets, push little kids, and stick "our butts out the window" of the school bus, the picture gets uglier. Then they get tired of it, give it to a friend, and go off to drink pickle juice. The two friends are sort of a junior version of Beavis and Butthead. They take true pleasure in gross and disgusting things, which comes through in the pleasingly grotesque, cartoon illustrations; heavily detailed and busy, the art is in full color, with movie scenes in shades of gray. Morty's narration captures the simple idiocy of the two boys: "`Neat!' Ray shouted. `It is a neat movie!' `Did you see what a neat picture?' Neat!'" The irreverent tone of the text is well matched by the art, but there's not much else to this book. The mischief-making antics might draw a laugh or two, but the inane plot has little else to offer. Compared to better-developed troublemakers such as James Marshall's Cut-Ups and George and Harold from Dav Pilkey's "Captain Underpants" series (Scholastic), Morty and Ray are pretty forgettable.
Steven Engelfried, Beaverton City Library, ORCopyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 1-3. A hilarious retelling of "The Portrait of Dorian Gray," this finds Morty and Ray watching the black-and-white Hollywood classic, and then trying to make
their (crayon) self-portrait turn ugly via assorted dastardly deeds. From leaving wads of chewed gum in a water fountain to mooning passersby from the school bus window, the mischievous chums cackle delightedly at each stage of the silly transformation. After squirting their friend Oscar with pickle juice and stuffing the offending vegetable down his pants, the drawing becomes too hideous even for Morty and Ray, and they come to their senses and call a halt to their reign of terror. Pinkwater's simple text makes the story easy to read, and the grossology a la Dav Pilkey's Captain Underpants books is sure to tickle even the youngest reader. Best of all, Davis' wry, delightful illustrations bathe the rather dark, gloomy tale in a kid-friendly light.
Terry GloverCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved