Customer Reviews

Pillow Talk

5 star:		(78)
4 star:		(20)
3 star:		(6)
2 star:		(4)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

Rating for this movie -- 5 Stars.
Rating for the 2004 DVD version of the film -- 1 Star.

"Pillow Talk" stars Doris Day, Rock Hudson, Tony Randall, and Thelma Ritter. It remains today what it was when released in October of 1959, and that is -- a highly-entertaining and well-acted romantic comedy.

The film was re-released on DVD-Video by Universal Studios on April 6th, 2004. This newer version has been enhanced for 16x9 widescreen TVs, and the anamorphic enhancement has helped in many places. However, the picture quality here does seem to be a bit of a "hit and miss" proposition. Several portions of the movie still look rather crummy (artifact-wise), exhibiting obvious dirt speckles and "noise". The opening titles sequence is peppered with dirt and artifacts galore, as are a few other parts of the film, particularly ALL of the "split screen" scenes. For some reason, it seems that these "split screen" shots could not be cleaned-up nearly as much as the other portions of the movie.

But by far the biggest atrocity is the fact that this 2004 DVD print has been mis-framed! In some places pretty badly, too. Head room is way too tight here, with the tops of many character's heads being cut off. This was NOT the case with the previous 1999 DVD print of this movie.

When you compare the '99 print with this 2004 one, the mis-framing is obvious in many places. It appears that this new print has been "zoomed in" quite a bit, creating the tight head room. Some of the most blatant examples of this "zooming in" occur in Chapter 10, where the piano player's head is severely cropped. Whereas, on the '99 DVD, her entire head is visible in the frame. Plus, a few seconds later in that "Roly Poly" scene, we see a shot of several people singing along to the music and clapping their hands. In this shot, TWO ENTIRE PEOPLE (one on the left and one on the right side of the frame) are totally cut out of the shot! Plus, part of another man is cut out of the frame on the left! These "missing" people are all visible on the 1999 disc.

And check out Chapter 14! This scene is simply horrifying from a framing standpoint! Literally half of Rock Hudson's head is missing here! When we KNOW it should be in the frame (based on the 1999 disc, which is perfectly framed for the 2.35:1 aspect ratio of the movie). Yikes!

This is ridiculous carelessness on the part of Universal's quality control department! Many scenes are totally botched with this zoomed-in mis-framing of the print!

Looks like yet another case of a Universal product being mishandled in the DVD transfer department. A pity! For "Pillow Talk" is one of the best romantic comedies you're likely to see this year, or any other year. And it deserves better treatment than this. It's just plain stupid to let an obviously-botched DVD video transfer like this one get into any consumer's hands! Doesn't ANYONE check these framing issues before finalizing the product? Mind-boggling indeed!

This newer DVD version of the film contains the exact same Menu design and Special Features as the previous non-anamorphic variant (minus a text info page about Universal "Web Links"). The bonus features aren't very plentiful, being limited to the original theatrical trailer and some very extensive and informative text notes on the film and its cast members. (FYI -- These text-based items are verbatim to the older "Pillow Talk" DVD release; but definitely worth a read. Until reading these Production Notes, I never knew a sequel to the film was being planned in 1980. But, unfortunately, the project never got beyond the initial planning stages, and the film was never made. Too bad. I'd have liked to have seen that sequel.)

I'm severely disappointed with this DVD. I looked forward very much to having this film in an enhanced anamorphic state. But in this butchered, mis-framed version, it's nearly impossible to fully enjoy the film. Because the FULL film is not here!

If you've already got the older non-anamorphic DVD of "Pillow Talk", you'd be better advised to just hang onto it, and skip this version entirely. Upon looking over both versions side-by-side, the older one really isn't very much worse (fuzziness-wise) than this new one. And when factoring in the mis-framing problem of the new one, the old DVD displays the WHOLE picture; while this new one definitely does not.*

* EDIT/FOOTNOTE (OCTOBER 2005) -- Universal has supposedly fixed the mis-framing problem with this 2004 DVD release -- although I've ordered multiple copies of the "new" disc (from different e-tailers) and still haven't seen a properly-framed copy. I've had to return each one thus far (and they were ordered more than a year apart). Very discouraging. So, you're taking your chances when you order this '04 version of the film.

~throws hands in air in disgust~

Doris Day and Rock Hudson are perhaps the best duo in movie history. Pillow Talk is one of the most clever comedies ever made. This film is about a painful reality in the 50's- party lines. When Jan Morrow wants to use her phone, she must first listen to her other "party" Brad Allen romance the women. She finally works out a deal with him to each have a thirty minute slot where they can make calls, but selfish Brad doesn't adhere to the rules at all! Brad accidentally meets the other end of his party line at a restaurant, and makes a quick decision to become someone else. He ultimately romances Jan, while she has no idea that he is her arch enemy. For it's time, Pillow Talk was one of the more risque films, but yet one of the funniest and most romantic ever made.

On that note, I have to say I was so disappointed with this DVD. There are no extras to speak of other than the trailer and some production notes. As successful as the stars of this movie were, you think Universal could have put a little more punch into this DVD. The quality of the DVD is also quite poor. There was no digital remastering, only a direct copy from vhs to dvd. If you are a person who only has dvd's, I would still get this because this is such a classic, you have to have it around. If you still have your vhs machine, get it on vhs, it's cheaper and not any less quality than the dvd.

This is probably the most well known pairing of Doris Day and Rock Hudson. A laugh out loud comedy in which Tony Randall and Thelma Ritter also showcase their vast comedic talent. Jan Morrow shares a party line with Brad Allen, which she has tried to put a stop to, but the phone company won't cooperate. She uses it for her work as an interior decorator, while he uses it to seduce a multitude of women thru his song writing. When they meet by accident, he assumes another identity to get close to Jan hoping to deceive her until he has the opportunity to get what he wants. When she becomes wise to his deception, all bets are off!

Of all the classic comedies that starred Doris Day and Rock Hudson, or the two stars with other co-stars, this remains my favorite.The legendary late Rock Hudson was at his peak in this romantic comedy, and who better to showcase his charms against, than quintessential girl-next-door, Doris Day. Hudson thrives on his ability to charm indeed, as a songwriter named Brad Allen. Brad is a love-em and leave-em kind of guy, who entertains a seemingly endless array of lovesick females at his well equipped bachelor pad. He also sings to them over the phone for hours on end, tying up the telephone party-line he shares with Jan Morrow, interior designer, enter a perturbed Doris Day. Every time Jan picks up the phone, she hears Brad sing "You're My Inspiration...", and always with a new girls' name attached to the end. Flabbergasted at his womanizing, she sends a phone company rep to have a word with Mr. Allen, only to find that she TOO has fallen for the tall dark and handsome playboy.

Jan tells her boyfriend of sorts played by the wonderful veteran comedy legend Tony Randall, about her dialing dilemma. Randall, as always, plays himself. He's neat, dapper and proper, as not only Jan's boyfriend, but Brad Allen's friend and boss as well. After extoling the virtues of Jan to Brad, and mentioning that she shares a party-line with "some nut", describing the singing phone routine, Brad is too curious to find out what Randall is so wild about. After Brad Allen finally glimpses Jan Morrow dancing at a club, and sees the other end of his party line is not the shrew he expected, he sets out for his sweetest conquest of all.

"Pillow Talk" is a timeless gem of classic comedy. Amazingly, it was considered quite risque in it's time. This only goes to show just how jaded the world and cinema has become since 1959. Rock Hudson was actually embarrassed, and nearly declined the role. We can speculate in retrospect why he felt that way, but no one could've been a better cad than Rock as Brad! The one and only Doris Day is sweet as sunshine, until the duped decorator delighfully disarms Mr. Allen's charms, leaving him, for the first time, really in love with someone other than himself. Thelma Ritter is amusing as Jan's perpetually hung-over housekeeper. It's a truly comic moment when Ritter counsels Brad over a few too many drinks on how to win Jan over, and Hudsons' head hits the table with a thud, while Ritter babbles on oblivous to her companions condition. Tony Randall is his classic prim self, and laugh out loud funny, as he storms into his own place to rescue Jan from the smug seducer huffing the line "At least you could have had the DECENCY...to bring your OWN champagne!"

There are too many wonderful moments in this film to cover them all. If you somehow haven't, it's far better for you to enjoy watching this long lost genre of the innocent, fun, fresh feel-good romantic comedy, and experience first hand, the pure delight it has to offer in abundance.

I have watched this movie well over a dozen times, and continue to enjoy it immensely. While I have always been a Doris Day fan, here she really proves her ability as a comedic/romantic star. Although the premise of a party line is dated to us now, the basic idea is about how we never know who we will fall in love with. Doris Day is Jan Morrow, a sophisticated, successful single woman with a vibrant career as an interior decorator. Rock Hudson, quite handsome by anyone's standards, is a fun loving bachelor with a spate of girlfriends he woos over a party line he shares with Daoris Day's character. Doris Day's character, Jan Morrow, has little time for his nonsense on their shared phone line, and brands him a sex-maniac. It is again another role where Doris Day is portrayed, while not virginal, at least alot more prudish than Mr. Allen. They meet by accident, Brad Allen pretends to be Rex Stetson, ( the name alone is hilarious), and they fall in love. While Jan Morrow beleives she is love with Rex Stetson, the truth is she may actually have fallen for Brad Allen as well. The sets, costumes, witty dialogue and wonderful supporting cast help this farce breeze along nicely. Try this movie and get a feel for what we all would like to beleive at sometime or another,that love is grand and overcomes obstacles. On a personal note...I have always held this movie up as an ideal...It depicts a time when you could have a successful career, a great apartment, and fabulous clothes...all very clean and easy and how we all thought it should be...If it could only be a reality and not a dream!

I was so excited to see that Universal is making a special edition of PILLOW TALK's 50th Anniversary on dvd. The 1959 comedy romance movie about an interior decorator Jan Morrow (Doris Day) who shares a party line with a womanizing wolf Brad Allen (Rock Hudson),was an unbelievable box office hit in 1959, and I thought Universal will really make this Golden Anniversary of the film a great one! Upon viewing the film, I at once noticed nothing new. I am a huge Doris Day fan, so I pulled out my other Pillow Talk dvd copies, looked at them side by side and here's the facts:
This dvd is the EXACT dvd that was made for the 2007 THE DORIS DAY AND ROCK HUDSON COMEDY COLLECTION, which includes all 3 movies they made together: Pillow Talk, Lover Come Back and Send Me No Flowers.

This 2007 Doris/Rock Set is an improvement over the Pillow Talk dvd's that were made in 2004 and earlier, as Universal "remastered" it with a tiny bit more brightness, a tiny bit more detail and a tiny bit more frame area. 2007 was the first year Universal made tiny "upgrades" to Pillow Talk when they made this Doris Day/Rock Hudson dvd set. All they did for this 50th Anniversary Set, was use this 2007 Pillow Talk dvd.

This Anniversary Edition includes these Bonus Features:
Commentary with Film Historians Jeff Bond, Julie Kirgo and Nick Redman.
Chemistry 101: The Film Duo of Doris Day and Rock Hudson. Featurette that talks about how filmmakers first saw the sparks between Doris and Rock, and how that made them put the duo together for 2 more successful films.
Back in Bed with Pillow Talk: Film Historians, experts, authors, cast and crew discuss the many elements that propelled PILLOW TALK to a top box office spot for Universal Studios in 1959.
Theatrical Trailer.

This 50th Anniversary Edition is great to own, if you never bought the 2007 "upgrade" of Pillow Talk, as it is a slightly better copy over all the dvd's that were made before 2007. The Bonus Features are not that exciting, as Doris is not in anything new. I'm disappointed that Universal could have made a fantastic upgrade of this film, and included better Bonus Features, and included Doris- if only for 5 minutes!! (Look what they did for Disney's 50th Anniversary of Sleeping Beauty and Wizard of Oz's 50th- absolutely gorgeous.) If they had only included 5 minutes of Doris and spent another 5 weeks upgrading the original 35 mm film, they would have gotten my 5 stars!!

"Pillow Talk" (which premiered in U.S. movie theaters in early October 1959) features the likes of Doris Day, Rock Hudson, Tony Randall, and Thelma Ritter. It's an excellent cast, and all of these stars are quite enjoyable to watch in their roles here, with Doris and Thelma particularly entertaining (IMO). Ritter plays her part of the usually-intoxicated housekeeper to perfection. The scene with Ritter and Rock in the neighborhood bar is one of the many high points in this stylish and always-fun-to-watch sex comedy.

Both the 1999 and 2004 DVD versions of "Pillow Talk" (released by Universal Studios Home Video) feature the exact same Menu design and the same (limited) Special Features. But there are a couple of small extras that I like. The Original Theatrical Trailer is included on both discs. Plus: there are some text-only items -- "Production Notes" and some "Cast Bios". The Production Notes are very interesting to read and are quite thorough.

Until reading these text Notes on the DVD, I never knew that a "Pillow Talk" sequel was being planned in the year 1980. But, unfortunately, the project never got beyond the initial planning stages, and the film was never made. Too bad. I'd have liked to have seen that sequel.

Both DVD variants of "Pillow Talk" (the original 1999 DVD release and the 2004 re-release) are presented in Widescreen, with the original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.35:1. The earlier '99 version is a non-anamorphic DVD transfer; whereas the 2004 disc features an anamorphic DVD transfer that has been "enhanced for 16x9 TVs". *

* = Beware however! -- Many of the anamorphic discs of "Pillow Talk" released in April 2004 have been "mis-framed"! These incorrectly-transferred discs have a "zoomed-in" look to the image, with headroom being way too tight and everything within the 2.35:1 image feeling "cramped" (and many times the tops of heads have been completely cut off due to this improper zooming). The earlier 1999 disc features the proper framing, with no chopped-off heads.

From what I've heard, Universal has fixed this mis-framing problem and has re-issued new (corrected) discs. But there might still be some messed-up discs floating around for purchase.

If you want to immediately know if you've bought a mis-framed copy of the film, go right away to Chapter #17 on the DVD and freeze the image at the "1:37:45" (elapsed time) mark of the movie. If your copy is correct and has the proper framing, at this very point you should be able to see ALL of Rock Hudson's head on the screen. If you've got a crummy mis-framed (zoomed) copy, Rock's cranium will be cut off severely at the top of the 2.35:1 image area (this looks awful too, IMO, on the improperly-framed copies).


More "Pillow Talk" DVD Information ...................

Audio -- Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono (English only).
Subtitles -- English and French.
Animated Menus? -- No.
Feature Running Time -- 1:42:20.
Number of Chapter Stops -- 18.
Paper Insert? -- The 1999 disc has a 4-page booklet, which includes a Chapter Guide and photos of the cast. The 2004 DVD has no chapter-list insert/enclosure.

-------------------

"Pillow Talk" remains today what it was when released in late 1959, and that is -- a very entertaining and well-acted romantic comedy. A highly-recommended motion picture.

I grew up knowing about Doris Day because my mother was/is a big fan of her comedies. When I first saw "Pillow Talk" I was a mere child (the film was made the same year I was born). Over the years I have watched it frequently, and now have it also on DVD. The film continues to entertain and delight me, even as my impressions have changed with time.

Doris Day, Rock Hudson and Tony Randall had a wonderfully delightful chemistry amongst them! From the opening where Doris is humming "Pillow Talk" after the intro is completed, to the far-fetched but humourous end when Brad Allen (Rock) is trying to tell his friend Jonathan that he is going to be a father, the film is simply splendidly performed throughout! Credit must also be given to the script writers Stanley Shapiro & Maurice Richlin, director Michael Gordon & Producer Ross Hunter.

Even though I was born the year "Pillow Talk" was made, I didn't even know party lines existed until I visited a great-aunt in Northern Minnesota. I remember picking up the phone and hearing people talk. WHAT A DISCOVERY! It put the film in a new context for me when I saw it later (I am not sure if I had seen it before). I suspect that the younger generation might not understand even the notion of party lines in our age of cellular phones and internet. In this regard, the film takes us back to a less techonologically advanced time, but a time where life seemed somehow more relaxed.

I delight in seeing New York City, Central Park, and the American automobiles in the 1959 frame of context. One question that pops into my mind: did people in NYC really have such big apartments with a single woman living alone, and still affording a maid to come in each day??? Was the maid really paid enough to make a living from it? Did NYC really have that sort of "everyone knows everyone" feel such as when Kelly the police officer congratulates Brad Allen as he carries Jan Morrow from her apartment to his? I doubt it, but the fantasy is lovely!

Rock Hudson did a really fun impression of a Texan rancher up in New York. Tony Randall was extremely funny as the self-deprecating multi-millionaire in love with Jan, and Doris simply glowed from beginning to end. The last few times I have watched it, which has been recently, I have been struck by the sexual frankness it explored. Brad the playboy, always luring in the beautiful women, Jan the wonderfully moral interior decorator, who shakes her tush in a very sexy manner at a nightclub when Brad first spots her, and the budding romance that develops between the two when he becomes "Rex Stetson", a cowboy from Texas. "Rex" playing the moral companion who would do nothing to offend the proper Miss Morrow, while inside he is sizing her up and biting at the bit to ... well bite at her bits? When the gig is almost up, "Rex" innocently suggests that Jan join him for a weekend in Connecticut. While there was no actual sex occuring, it is made clear that it was about to happen when Jan figures out the ruse Brad Allen has played on her. Hollywood, perhaps afraid of the extent of this sexual frankness, has Miss Morrow crying at the diner where she and Jonathan stop for coffee, saying "I thought we were going to get married." Good girl image preserved!

Later, when Brad Allen conspires with Jan's boss to have her redecorate his apartment, the scene of the music beginning to play and the double bed automatically folding out with sheets in place left no doubt what sort of life Brad led prior to falling in love with Jan. He was a playboy through and through and measured success by the quantity of women he successfully "entertained" at home. Growing up believing that promiscuous sexuality was a by-product of the late 60's counter culture movement and "summer of love", it struck me how direct and unambigious this scene was. However, in a very moral and virginal way, Jan's virtues are protected until she hears that Brad wants to marry her and in fact, loves her very deeply.

I am particularly fond of stories where romance changes a person for the good. Being an adult and a male, however, I wonder if such a womanizing playboy could and would remain ever faithful to the woman he loves for all eternity and never feel the need to stray again. It is fun, however, to believe that love was the true redemptor and that Brad and Jan lived happily ever after. Isn't this the great promise of romance AND fairy tales.
In both genres, Pillow Talk succeeds beyond measure and I love it more each time I see it.

P.S. The music is great too. Love "Roly Poly", "Possess Me" and of course, the theme song!

I have to admit - I love this movie. It is very, very funny and so clever that even though it is a very dated product of it's era - it still always feels fresh and lively to me. Doris Day is adorable here and Rock Hudson is hysterical. (Shades of truths to come!) Tony Randall was a great comic foil and Thelma Ritter still makes me alugh out loud even after 100+ viewings. It is so 60's chic - the clothes, cars, apartments - it still seems cool! Enjoy! They can't make them like this anymore.

Without a doubt, this film is the apex of the Rock and Doris screen collaboration. It's an absolute delight from the opening scenes until the credits roll. It's also a wonderful time machine of the 1950's, and even though I was born after this film was made, it always make me feel as if I experienced this decade first-hand. Doris Day had a charisma on screen that is indescribable and it's never been put to better use than here. You just want to hug her to bits, she's simply adorable and her character makes the film. Rock gives one of his best peformances and he was always better when Doris was around. They screen chemistry is fabulous, exceeded only by Tracy and Hepburn. It's obvious these were two people who liked each other and felt comfortable in each other's company. Thelma Ritter and Tony Randall give superb supporting performances.

Another wonderful thing about Pillow Talk is that it's still extremely funny. There are many scenes where you will laugh out loud. The entire interplay between Doris and Rock (when he's Rex Stetson) is hilarious and holds up beautifully. Another favorite scene is when Rock is confronted with his re-designed apartment, all at the hands of the scheming Doris.

They don't make 'em like this anymore. People of all ages should love this film. I watch it every few years and always find something new to admire or laugh about. A highly recommended and enjoyable movie. One word about the DVD version: I was disappointed in the quality, it's a little grainy. There are also not many extras, excepting the theatrical trailer.