Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not nearly as good as Gun Monkeys, July 15, 2005
This review is from: The Pistol Poets (Hardcover)
I bought Mr. Gischler's debut effort, Gun Monkeys, on Amazon last month and enjoyed it so much I immediately went back and purchased his next two books, the first of which is Pistol Poets. I was extremely disappointed.
Yes, Mr. Gischler writes simple, choppy, hard-edged prose that is appealing and he is also pretty funny too, reminiscent of Elmore Leonard and Kinky Friedman, and Pistol Poets features both qualities but.........none of the characters were in the least sympathetic. Every last character was self-absorbed, amoral and made me slightly naseous. I could not identify with any of the novel's characters, much less like them, with the possible exception of one very minor character, but of course Gischler kills him, while the disgusting main characters walk scot-free. For me this turned what could have been another fun and funny read into a dismal experience.
My advice: if you don't need sympathetic protagonists then get this book because you will probably enjoy it. If you are like me and want someone you can identify with, or even like, you'll do better staying away from this book. The whole experience reminded me of having to read Kate Chopan's "The Awakening" in college, another depressing treatment of neurotics without any socially redeeming qualiites. Ugh.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
EXCELLENT, March 22, 2004
This review is from: The Pistol Poets (Hardcover)
A few years ago I started reading mysteries on the internet. I found sites like Plots With Guns, The Thrilling Detective, and Judas. This is where I first heard of Victor Gischler. At that time he was writing a column for Plots With Guns called Hardboiled Dixie. And he had short stories all over the place. Gun Monkeys was his first novel and worth the price of admission for the first paragraph alone. It was a wild ride and I couldn't wait for his next. Last month The Pistol Poets was published. Was it worth the wait? HELL YES. Gischler has outdone himself. What's the book about? Glad you asked. Money Drugs Lust Sex Murder And that's all in the first chapter. Professor Jay Morgan: A "gypsy" on the academic circuit he teaches on a different campus from year to year. After finding a girl dead in his bed things go from bad to worse. Harold Jenks: A drug dealer from St. Louis who wants a new life and after stealing a dead mans identity he might just get his wish. Timothy Lancaster and Wayne DelPrego: Two poetry students who get caught up Jenks life and drug deal. Ginny Conrad: A student reporter who gets more than she bargained for. Fred Jones: Mysterious university benefactor who wants to be a poet. And Dele Stubbs: The craziest private eye you've ever read about. There are parts of the novel that made me laugh out loud and other parts that left me sick with grief. In all honesty I hated to finish this book but couldn't put it down. Why? Because I knew that once finished I was going to have a long wait until the next Gischler novel is published. Run to the bookstore and get this one Gischler is a genius, you won't be disappointed.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
It's good.......but.....it's not Gun Monkeys, March 23, 2004
This review is from: The Pistol Poets (Hardcover)
Maybe I was unfair with my high expectations for this book. If I had never read Gun Monkeys, I would have been pleasantly amused by the Pistol Poets, and might have looked for more from Victor Gischler, (but, frankly, not with a real effort). So, maybe I set myself up for failure because Gun Monkeys was so good. (It really is a great book!) So, I expected a book of at least the humor and "pathos" of GM. What I got was something that seemed more a "kooky kopy" of Dave Barry/Kinky Friedman/Carl Hiaasen, etc. Good writers, but they do the wacky mystery novel better than this - much better. I was disappointed. Most characters are one dimensional, and fairly uninteresting, (with the exception of "Jones", the amatuer poet/mob boss). They have implausable and unbelievable things happen to them, not as a consequence of a believable chain of events, but just to keep the "kookiness" at a high level. About halfway through the novel I lost interest, and put it aside for about two weeks, which I almost never do with a book. Even Professor Jay Morgan, the protagonist, lost my sympathy towards the end. The book had great potential, and I suspect was the victim of editing rewrites - at least I hope that that was the case. I look forward to the next Gischler novel, but if it is no better than the Pistol Poets, it'll be my last. Well, at least in hardback :)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|