Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Steelers Great Games, March 5, 2008
Last year yielded a healthy harvest of books about the Pittsburgh Steelers and Dale Grdnic's book, "Glory Days," is one of them.
Dale features the top 20 Steelers' games, beginning in the seventies, when they became one of the top franchises in the league, and covers all the great games including that special 2005 Super Bowl run.
Readers are offered superb stories about the Pittsburgh Steelers' players and coaches who took part in many of the greatest and most celebrated victories in the Steelers' legendary history, woven around the fans' personal touches.
Among the games covered is Franco Harris' "Immaculate Reception." Now recognised as the top American sporting moment when the "Same Old Steelers" shrugged off their losers' coats and proudly took their black and gold to the AFC Championship Game for the first time.
Franco's miraculous catch, from a Terry Bradshaw pass, snatched a last minute victory from their archrivals the Oakland Raiders with just seconds left on the clock. The Steelers' owner, Art Rooney, missed his teams' triumph; he was making his way to the locker room to commiserate with his players when they achieved their victory.
Among other games reviewed are Bill Cowher's first victory as the Steelers head coach in 1992 and Ben Roethlisberger's first win as a starting quarterback in Miami after Hurricane Jeanne.
Terry Bradshaw's last game, at Shea Stadium, is also featured in the book. Bradshaw was injured and Dale felt it was significant because until that game, the Steelers believed they would get several more great years out of Bradshaw.
A super book that brings back to life those magical Steelers' moments for all football fans to share and enjoy.
|
|
|
1.0 out of 5 stars
Poorly Written, Disappointing, February 8, 2009
As a lifelong Steelers fan, I had high hopes for this book, and was pleased to receive it as a Christmas gift from my parents.
Upon reading it, however, my disappointment grew stronger with each page. It's poorly written, badly edited, disorganized, and more than a little redundant.
Some of the little-known facts were nice to read, but Grdnic repeats them in chapter after chapter, as if he forgot he'd already revealed them. Even commonly known historical items are noted over and over again. For instance, Grdnic tells the reader in almost every chapter that Chuck Noll was hired in 1969 and finds a dozen different ways to say "things began to change."
One of the most scatterbrained chapters was the one about Gordan Dedman, a fan from England. The author spends half the chapter detailing how Dedman became a die-hard fan of the Steelers even though he lived thousands of miles away. Then, without warning, Grdnic switches gears, leaving Dedman's story behind to discuss the 1974 AFC championship, which appears unrelated. (Interestingly enough, the review of the book that led me to want it was apparently written by Dedman.)
There are many well-written books that cover various parts of the Steelers' glorious history. This isn't one of them.
|
|
|
|