28 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Plain Life, March 24, 2000
This review is from: A Plain Life (Hardcover)
I attended an author reading in Portland, and found Scott Savage personally to be engaging, and utterly sincere. Buy, borrow, get ahold of this book and read it. It is inspiring, challenging, bordering on life-changing. It may change the way you view the Plain Folk, or it may lead to to incorporate plain ideals into your own life.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Simple Life - not that Easy..., June 12, 2000
This review is from: A Plain Life (Hardcover)
Savage offers insight on what a plain life really is. Some of us confuse this with the `simpler life' we hear about, a supposedly easier, leisure-filled life thanks to modern technology. As many have noticed, the technology we use in hopes of giving us more free time actually gives us more time to do more `stuff', often with more stuff. There can be an emptiness that comes along with all of the stuff, extra time some of us seek to fill with more activities and more stuff. What seems to be most lacking is a connection with people, with our community.
Giving up a driver's license is no small thing. Being able to drive an automobile in our society means independence - teen-agers and the elderly particularly find getting or maintaining possession of a driver's license paramount to their quality of life. But they aren't alone. If you do not drive, but travel by foot, bicycle or horse and buggy, you realize your world both shrinks and expands. Physically, it consists of places and events that are close enough to get to within a day. It expands because that smaller surrounding must be more filled with community, and the people you are more dependent upon.
Although he and his wife became Quakers in the beginning of their journey, most of what he writes about community comes from their experiences with the Amish families they first lived near.
This kind of community didn't exist at all if it only existed in one's mind, as for example in a computer-driven `virtual community.'"
"Unlike pretend or fantasy communities, the real one we were learning from wasn't filled with folks hand-picked for their similarities. They did not necessarily really, really like one another, nor completely share the same interests."
I thought if I read the book, I'd feel compelled to change my life completely, or to feel bad about the life I live. Instead, it gave me the opportunity to do a lot of reflective thinking, and to find ways and reasons to question how I am living my life, and to find small ways of changing it for the better. I found myself wishing I had the riches Scott Savage has, the family, the community, life partner, the strength of character, the determination to do without the things that seem to fill up my life, and that of my youngest son.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
47 of 56 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
not for me, September 13, 2000
This review is from: A Plain Life (Hardcover)
Everyone else has written such glowing reviews of this book, I almost hate to rain on the parade. Maybe I am just too cynical to be reached by this book, but I couldn't even get through it. His tone came across to me as smug and self-righteous. He and his community and his family can't possibly be as wonderful as he tries to convince us they are. He also seems (oddly) naive. As someone who grew up in a conservative religious community (though not "plain," I confess), I can tell you that for every positive, wonderful thing about it, there is an equally strong negative. They are not utopias. They are full of flawed human beings who can inflict deep, slow-to-heal wounds on those who don't fit in. Surely Mr. Savage can see that there is a big difference between voluntarily choosing as an adult to make the choices he has made and being raised in such a community with three or four generations of tradition behind you and feeling nearly strangled by all that weight. While that doesn't invalidate Mr. Savage's good experiences with the plain people, it does indicate that it is not the community he has chosen, but the fact that he *is* choosing, discovering his own values and making hard choices to live up to those values, that is important. His smug self-satisfaction with the plain lifestyle would be bearable if he acknowledged that there are other ways to achieve spiritual depth, but he doesn't--or at least, not in the first half of the book, which is as far as I could make it. I'm giving it three stars, though, because there were some very interesting descriptions of how the Amish and Quakers live and believe--and also for his daughter Tasha's wonderful puns, which I won't spoil for you if you are planning on reading it. :-)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No